6 ms·
Booting Windows NT 4 on a DEC Multia
- 13of40 9y ago"My understanding of this procedure is that I would mount the hard drive on another computer and match the Administrator password hash to a known password" For future reference, all you need to do is temporarily replace services.exe with an exe that runs "net user administrator xyz123" (to change the password to xyz123), then reboot. Then put the original services.exe back, of course.
- mschuster91 9y ago... which would require getting your hands on a toolchain able to compile for this decades-old Windows on a pretty rare architecture.
- 13of40 9y agoNot really. This is pre-ASLR, so all you need to do is push a string pointer on the stack and call an address. Probably less than 15 bytes of machine code you'd need to hex-edit into an existing exe.
- Neil44 9y agoIf you have hard drive access you can replace the logon.scr screensaver executable with the command prompt executable, then a few minutes after boot up a command prompt with system privileges will appear by magic.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- poizan42 9y agoLike gcc[0] or Visual C++[1]? [0]: https://virtuallyfun.com/2016/12/09/gcc-windows-nt-dec-alpha/ https://virtuallyfun.com/2016/12/09/gcc-windows-nt-dec-alpha... [1]: https://winworldpc.com/product/visual-c/6x https://winworldpc.com/product/visual-c/6x
- nitrogen 9y agoIt's also possible that the Linux chntpw utility might be able to change the password in the old registry file directly.
- 13of40 9y agoI believe the format of either the registry hives or the the way the password hash is stored changed between Win2K and WinXP, so a modern tool likely wouldn't work. That's why you can use a Windows 2000 CD to boot to a recovery console in later windows versions without a password: It thinks the registry is corrupt and skips authentication.
- chungy 9y agochntpw works on all versions from NT 3.1 through Windows 10. The hive format, nor password storage format, actually hasn't changed in all the time. :-) Mind, the trickest part of dealing with pre-4.0 is mounting the file system, assuming the OS was placed onto NTFS rather than FAT. ntfs-3g only likes the "modern" NTFS format, which is found in NT 4.0 and up.
- yuhong 9y agoAFAIK the SAM format changed a few times during the life of NT 4.0, including when SYSKEY was introduced.
- einr 9y agoMind, the trickest part of dealing with pre-4.0 is mounting the file system, assuming the OS was placed onto NTFS rather than FAT. A couple of times I've tried mounting an NT 3.51 disk in a modern Windows 7 system and while it works (you can read from and write to it fine,) once you even mount it, NT 3.51 will never boot from that disk again. It hangs during the blue NTLDR stage. I'm not sure what would ever possess anyone to think it a good idea to write to a filesystem immediately upon mounting it, but Windows 7 does something to old NTFS volumes which renders them incompatible with NT 3.x.
- 9y ago
- djsumdog 9y agoI remember playing with a MSDN copy of Win NT 3.51 in my cousin's cubical back at AMI in the late 90s. We had NT4 on a Pentium Pro I got to admin back in high school. I even tried to see if I could get the library computers to login off a Samba PDC instead of the NT4 Server. A lot of stuff didn't work, and group policies were pretty janky. I like how the author also has an SGI and two Sun machines next to this one. We got a hold of some old Sun Stations in University back in 2001; paid like $12 for a crate of them. They were made in the 80s and had dual 100MB SCSI hard drives, tons of ram slots (I want to say 32 or 64MB of potential ram), and those crazy optical mice that needed the grid based mouse pads. I think I got RedHat running on mine and didn't do much with it. I'd love to collect and work on old stuff like this, but I started to do some hard core backpacking in my 30s and my parents threw out nearly everything while I was over seas for a few years. I'd really like to stay minimal with a room full or less of stuff, so I don't see myself getting into old computing any time soon. I'll just read posts like this and read The 8-Bit guy to get that nostalgia fix. Oh and if you're ever in Seattle and love old machines, check out The Living Computer Museum. They have actual Altos, HP UX, TIs, Apples, and DEC Alpha machines you can log into and play with. It's pretty amazing.
- an_account_name 9y agoThe Living Computer Museum is indeed fantastic. I’m partial to the mainframes but my daughter hates the loud noise in the cold room so we spend more time playing old PC games.
- lukeh 9y agoGroup policies were introduced with Windows 2000 and Active Directory.
- djsumdog 9y agoSorry, I meant System Policies, the predecessors to Group Policies.
- maxerickson 9y agoI knew someone who had a DEC running Windows NT around 2000. They admitted it didn't work as well as they would have liked.
- Maarten88 9y agoNT 4 prepared Win32 for synchronization with Windows 95. I hated it for that: they moved the presentation layer into the kernel (to allow features like "Active Desktop" widgets) which negatively impacted reliability and security for years to come. Windows NT 3.1 and 3.5 were much more reliable. The CD-ROM's containing the OS from MSDN came with the Microsoft C/C++ compiler on it, somewhere they even added Visual Studio 1.0. There was hardly any client software for MIPS and Alpha, but the i386 versions ran 16 bit versions of Ami Pro, Excel and Mosaic well. Which is probably why MIPS and Alpha NT versions never became popular, despite the fact that they were very fast for the time.
- yuhong 9y agowin32k has nothing to do with active desktop which was mostly shell level.
- JonathonW 9y agoWindows 95 and NT 4 didn't even ship with Active Desktop-- it (along with IE integration into Windows Explorer) was added as part of the Windows Desktop Update that shipped with IE4, and didn't become part of the OS out of the box until Windows 98 (and 2000 on the NT series). GDI in the kernel (win32k.sys) was a performance optimization.
- stevekemp 9y agoWindows 2000 was always my favourite release - most of the reliability of NT4, but with the added ability to use USB.
- gh02t 9y agoAlpha NT didn't become popular because of price and compatibility. DEC wanted to sell Alpha in serious workstations and servers and only made some half-hearted attempts to target the consumer market. Meanwhile the consumer marker coalesced around Wintel and Intel could leverage that larger volume to reduce costs, while consumers were locked in to x86 for compatibility. Dunno much about the history of MIPS but I imagine it was a similar story. Once Windows on x86 hit critical mass it steamrolled the rest. PowerPC was the exception with Apple, but even they didn't really start biting into bigger market shares until they switched. The dominance wasn't technically motivated (I know at least Alpha and SPARC had superior performance in many areas), it was economics and compatibility (and some shady dealings).
- mrbill 9y agoI ran NT4 on a MIPS Magnum R4000 for a while. It worked okay. Could run 16bit x86 Windows/DOS stuff in a weird sort of translation/emulation. All my Multias (I owned 2-3 over the years) usually ended up with RHEL on them; nobody in the nerd crowd I was in wanted to run Windows on them. They ran so hot that if you sat it horizontal it would keep your coffee cup warm if close enough. I believe someone got VMS running on one after some hackery with the firmware/BIOS.
- michrassena 9y agoI bought an Acer PICA (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Acer_PICA https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Acer_PICA) back in the early 2000s, obsolete by then, just to play with it and Windows NT 4. MIPS still seemed exotic, and there was little free software to use on the platform. I think a port of Office existed, and maybe an early Internet Explorer. I'm not sure what the point of the ARC ports of NT even were, except Microsoft's attempt to keep its fingers in as many pies as possible and crowd out competitors.
- mrbill 9y agoThey weren't sure if x86 was going to be competitive in the long run at that point, so they were porting to all the major architectures. I even heard rumors of a SPARC port of NT 3.51 but I've never seen it in the flesh. Solaris even ported to PPC (specific RS6K boxes) for Solaris 2.5.1; I've got a copy of that ISO image around somewhere but never had the right hardware to run it.
- ben1040 9y agoI realized the only other time I'd heard of the Multia was from Slashdot posts from nearly 20 years ago. https://tech.slashdot.org/story/99/08/02/0219235/free-multias-pay-shipping-only https://tech.slashdot.org/story/99/08/02/0219235/free-multia...
- dmeeker 9y agoPSA: don't click the link to the linux store in the Slashdot article. Someone super dodgy owns that domain name now.
- walrus01 9y agoI remember seeing NT3.5 running on an Alpha at a trade show around the same time period. A higher end model than the one the author posts here. The reason why it never found "consumer success" is that in late 1993 dollars it cost $7800 , equivalent to about $13,600 today. When at the same time it was possible to buy a 486DX/33 for just under $2000 in a pretty decent, though not nearly as capable configuration. That is what consumers could afford.
- miah_ 9y agoIn ~1997 I bought a Multia off some online auction site pre-Ebay. My local PC supplier had to special order 64MB ECC RAM for me as they didn't carry it. For a teenager at my first IT job it took me a few months to afford the RAM and was a bit before I had it running. I mainly used it beta testing Redhat Rawhide and experimenting with Linux. It was my first non-x86 system. I did try WindowsNT 4.0 on it for a week, but it was slow and almost nothing was compatible with it. Later I got some Alphastations but they were almost the same spec as a Multia, just better form factor. My main PC around this time was a Sun Sparcstation 20 with a ROSS Dual Hypersparc module and 2GB RAM. I remember paying around $2000 for it in 1998, probably too much! Unfortunately the magic smoke escaped from the CPU one morning in 2000 :(
- projektfu 9y agoNot bad for the SPARC considering it was introduced at around $25,000. Of course, by 1998 it was only as powerful as a dual processor Pentium Pro. I think the RAM maxed out at 512MB though.
- jibanes 9y agoI did my thesis (and wrote code on) a sparcstation lx running an (very) early version of openbsd/sparc.
- projektfu 9y agoI'd often sit down and write papers at a SPARC IPX in the computer lab because nobody else knew what they were doing. It was a pretty slow computer, but the windows PCs were all on Win 3.1 at the time and that was pretty annoying. You had to boot the PC from scratch each time, while the IPX was ready to go. Anyone else remember Pitt's computing evironment around 1996?
- Paianni 9y agoThis isn't SPARC, it's Alpha.
- qplex 9y ago
- mkesper 9y agoThe article mentions Service Pack 6. You needed to install 6a which fixed up many faults of 6, like e.g. not being able to disable Nagle's algorithm for TCP (not funny when you wanted to send around short TCP messages).
- hestefisk 9y agoThis brings back so many fond memories from the late 90ies. I dual booted Windows NT 4 and Red Hat Linux for many years on an old Pentium 166 with an Adaptec scsi controller (remember that?). It was wonderful. Could never afford an Alpha machine though. WinNT was good stuff, miss the good old blue boot screen.
- Fnoord 9y agoYeah I remember having a server with an Adaptec SCSI controller. It only booted with Linux 2.4. When we attempted to boot Linux 2.6 I had to drive 300 km to the datacenter to fix it. "trying harder", it printed. Fun stuff.
- other_herbert 9y agoI messed around with one of these I got in college at an off lease / salvage type place... The boot loader on those was really cool and because it was an alpha, you had a license for digital UNIX...
- ecopoesis 9y agoI had an Alpha Multia back in ‘98. I remember having to scour eBay for the appropriate SCSI adapters since DEC used something proprietary. And even with the adapter, I never got the Linuxes of the time to recognize the HDs. The key to running NT4 for Alpha was DEC’s FX!32. It crosscompiled x86 code to AXP. Thanks to Alpha’s better design this made my 233mhz 21066 a lot faster running x86 code the my Pentium MMX 233.
- jdwithit 9y agoAs a kid who grew up in Massachusetts in the 80s and 90s, I'd love to go back in time and experience the competing tech that was being built in my back yard before the west coast totally won out. I had friends whose parents worked for both DEC and Wang Laboratories, and had those companies' gear in their homes. At the time I only cared about what games you could put on or write for them, but it would be awesome to poke around on them again as an adult.
- Jaruzel 9y ago> Finding software written for Win32/Alpha, though, is likely to be a challenge. As someone who actually had one of these at work[1] back in the early 90s, there was hardly any software compiled for Alpha even when it was a current product. Lack of software support, was one of the reasons that WinNT Alpha never gained a foothold. Which was a shame as the Alpha hardware was pretty great. -- [1] It was the only one we had, I think we got it as a freebie as the rest of the computer room was choca full of DEC VAXs.
- randomerr 9y agoI remember a local college loved them because you could teach 3d modeling. They really weren't used for the actual modelling but rather as cheap render farms that could run at night.
- gaius 9y agothere was hardly any software compiled for Alpha even when it was a current product I ran SQL Server on NT on Alpha in the 90s, it was actually very good, but you had to treat it as a dedicated appliance rather than a general-purpose computer because as you say, there was very little software available. Then the industry took a weird meander through DEC StrongARM and now Microsoft is looking at Windows on ARM seriously again...
- youdontknowtho 9y agoIf I remember correctly there was something called FX32 that was like a dynamic transpiler from X86 to Alpha. You could run Win32 apps, and they would get faster over time as it cached translated binaries. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FX!32 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FX!32
- randomerr 9y agoI miss the simplicity of the NT / 2003 era of servers. You could make setup as simple or as complex as you now. Now you have to have a BSA to configure so many arbitrary standards just to connect to a NAS.
- aap_ 9y agoI have Windows 2000 RC2 running on an Alpha :) It's really neat, you can even execute x86 programs.
- paulirwin 9y agoSo at the time, to compile software for Windows NT Alpha, was there an Alpha IDE and compiler available (something like VC++) such that developers were writing and debugging locally, or would developers usually cross-compile from an x86 machine?
- paulirwin 9y agoTo answer my own question, now that I'm not on my mobile: it looks like there was an Alpha version of Visual C++ 2.0, as well as a cross-compiler for the 68k Macintosh! [1] I was firmly in VB land at the time (as a ~10 year old) so this bit of history eluded me. [1] https://accu.org/index.php/journals/1771 https://accu.org/index.php/journals/1771
- drewg123 9y agoI had an alpha (miata, AKA Personal Workstation 500au, I think) running NT on my desk for a while, while we waited for space to open up in a rack..(1) The NT on it seemed quite usable, thanks to the FX!32 emulator. When running x86 compiled stuff, it felt mostly as fast as contemporary high-end PCs, once you'd opened the x86 program and used it for a while. (1) We used FreeBSD/alpha, so we always bought the "NT" version of machines to save $$$ on the DEC UNIX license fee. Eg, just like today, the Windows version of a machine was cheaper.. FreeBSD did not support the ARC firmware needed by NT, but you could easily switch the machines to SRM in order to load FreeBSD.