7 ms·
San Francisco is officially $10B in the hole
- godzillabrennus 9y agoLooks like the costs are being driven by offering generous compensation and retirement packages to government employees. I don't see that changing.
- Fede_V 9y agoI'm not sure how you could call that generous give the col of SF. Do we just expect government employees to not be able to live in the city they work?
- refurb 9y agoThere is a difference between a pension that allows you to live in SF and a crazy generous pension (that encourages gaming the system) that is far more extravagant than anything you'd find in the private sector (who have been moving away from pensions generally).
- toomuchtodo 9y agoI don’t know why public sector workers should give ground on benefits simply because private sector workers have rolled over to corporate interests. If you don’t want a union, cool, but don’t complain about the outcome then. Comparing to private sector workers is disingenous.
- Agustus 9y agoI don't know why the public should be forced to have a reduction in public services because the public sector rolled over political interests to their favor.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- eldavido 9y agoLook, obviously you and I have pretty different ideology, I get that. But I think you should consider why union membership is declining in the US. It's not some giant right-wing conspiracy. It's because the structure of industry is changing, firms are getting smaller, and the overall economy is getting more competitive. It's not like all the employees just decided, hey, we should all voluntarily decide to take a worse deal, great idea, let's do it. What upsets me as a taxpayer is why this same thing doesn't apply in the public sector. Like, I get that teachers work hard, but if we paid by outcomes, the way any sane private-sector company does, half of teachers would just get fired. Look at any major big-city school district if you want to see the mediocrity in action, whether Chicago Public Schools (CPS), Oakland Unified, etc. So yeah, it seems a little unfair that one sector of the economy gets paid for being mediocre at best, and other fires people and demands performance. Yeah, I'm a little upset.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoI can appreciate we have different viewpoints. I can appreciate that, as a taxpayer, you’re upset. I also see the issues with institutions like CPS (having lived in Chicago proper). I don't believe paying teachers for outcomes when outcomes are primarily driven by influences outside of a teacher's control [1], but that is a discussion for another thread. I don’t think it’s a secret I’m hard to the left. People first. That’s how empathy works, economic efficiency be damned. Are there issues with how pension systems are gamed? Certainly, and fixes need to be put in place (benefit systems should never have the capacity to be gamed). Should public sector workers have reduced benefits or salaries because the American public has allowed their representatives to hand all the gains to Corporate America? Absolutely not. We have slowly, over decades, mortgaged the future (at local, state, and federal levels, speaking specifically about the US). The bills are coming due, and everyone is surprisingly shocked. I can’t tell you what to do, but I have gotten involved in politics and intend to contribute to a solution. I encourage you to do the same. [1] https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/social-sector/our-insights/drivers-of-student-performance-insights-from-north-america https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/social-sector/our-insigh...
- eldavido 9y ago
- xienze 9y agoIt’s a pension, you don’t have to live in the city to collect it. And a lot of those CA pensions are along the lines of “85% of your average salary over your last three years”, so guess what happens? Get a transfer to SF or LA and juice your average by doing ungodly amounts of overtime. Then fuck off and retire somewhere cheap pulling in 100k+ until you die. Pretty sweet setup, but local and state municipalities are screwed.
- bassman9000 9y agohttp://sfdhr.org/benefits-overview http://sfdhr.org/benefits-overview https://mysfers.org/wp-content/uploads/Plan-Provisions-Misc-603.pdf https://mysfers.org/wp-content/uploads/Plan-Provisions-Misc-... Working 20y covers 100% health benefits when retiring. Working 20y allows you to retire at 53. Pension calculated averaging only the 3 best years. Regarding Do we just expect government employees to not be able to live in the city they work? Do they have more right than others to live in the city they work in? Because thousands commute to SF every day because they can't afford it. edit: formatting
- david38 9y agoI work in SF. There is no requirement I be able to afford to live there. Do no, I don't expect the employees to necessarily be able to live there. Ferrari mechanics cannot afford Ferraris. Stanford regular employees cannot afford to send their kids there, etc. So what?
- anameaname 9y agoIt will change as SF's credit goes down the tubes. Unlike the federal government, there is a chance that SF could default on its loans. If they can't get a loan and they squeeze the rich out of the city, there won't be any money left.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- eldavido 9y agoJust because it's promised doesn't mean it'll happen. Look at Illinois.
- Taniwha 9y agoRead the article: $10B is the budget, $250M is the amount of that that isn't funded, it's still a big hole, but 40 times smaller - please change the header above
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- avalys 9y agoNo, there’s a $250M deficit annually, and a total of $10B in future liabilities. Coincidentally, that is the same amount as the entire annual budget. But $10B is the right number.
- danielvf 9y ago"Using the official numbers, San Francisco is $10 billion in the hole ($4.2 billion of health care liabilities, plus $5.8 billion of pension liabilities)." Then later, he estimates that the actual amount is approximately twice that, since the official ten billion figure is based over optimistic assumptions.
- kaennar 9y agoHe states that it could be twice that not that the actual amount is that value. He was stating that the 7.5% return they wanted is not likely, that 6.5% is much more likely, and that he wouldn't be surprised if the return was less than that 6.5%.
- lph 9y ago$10B is the sum of health care and pension liabilities. This is the hole referred to by the title.
- pmoriarty 9y agoCould taxing all the marijuana businesses that are springing up like mushrooms all over SF help?
- gwern 9y agoThe tax revenue numbers here seem like they would exclude recreational marijuana but would include medical marijuana. Unless you think legalization alone will increase SF-local sales by like $1 billion/annually (that's a lot of weed! and most of that will be in cash, making it harder) it's hard to see it making a big difference. I didn't see that much marijuana being consumed when I was there last week, and the one recreational dispensary I went to was selling fairly small quantities in dollar terms... (I bought $17 of edibles, so I'm afraid I didn't help much in plugging the SF deficit.)
- pfarnsworth 9y agoThe $300 million per year that SF spends on homeless should be reevaluated. The fact that there is no metrics, targets, or accountability should make this the first thing on their list.
- eldavido 9y agoThis is how it starts. City booms, everyone whines about cost of living going up, unionized public sector employees extract massive concessions from politicians whose campaigns they fund. I'm not saying this in an ideological way; it's inevitable, given that unions get dues by default which most employees don't bother to opt out from, those dues get spent influencing local politics to favor union members, and over 50% of US union members are in the public sector [1] - only 16% of the US workforce is unionized, but 1/3 of public employees are - it's hard to see how this ends any other way. Eventually business wises up and realizes the obscene salaries and taxes they have to pay their employees go a lot farther elsewhere, then they relocate and (rightly) leave this mess behind, on the hands of the local government, taxpayers, and politicians who ran on promises they could never deliver on, and the public sector employees who all but extorted the taxpayers out of their money. This is the story of Detroit yesterday, Illinois today, and SF tomorrow. I don't see how this ends any other way. Look at how many companies are already hiring remote employees -- time for SF to wake up and realize how limited their bargaining power is. [1] https://www.economist.com/news/united-states/21737318-supreme-court-poised-strike-decisive-blow-unions-are-confronted https://www.economist.com/news/united-states/21737318-suprem...
- jacobolus 9y agoTeachers in SF are living in closets, out of cars, two to a bedroom in shared apartments, commuting long distances, etc. Their salaries are comparable to the state average, but the cost of living is dramatically higher here. The problem in SF is obscene housing costs (and, like everywhere in the US, obscene healthcare costs), not overpayment of public employees. In CA municipal budgeting would also be much more straightforward, effective, and robust without prop 13. As for unions: the US has seen several decades of intense ideological war on organized labor, with dramatic erosion of workers rights across the board, and in particular legislative and Supreme Court interpretation changes that make labor organizing much more difficult and dangerous than a half century ago. Public sector unions are some of the last hold-outs. The overall result we’ve seen for the past 35 years is continually rising productivity but stagnant wages and working conditions (for all workers, unionized and not), and skyrocketing inequality. The future does not look bright for the bulk of American workers. (Great for the financial sector though, like the hedge fund manager [and Peter Thiel protégé] who wrote this op-ed.)
- imjustsaying 9y agoEntirely predictable and only a matter of time, but talking about it IRL is equivalent to downvote fodder on HN. I want workers to get fair wages, but it often seems the boomers/Gen X achieve that by loading debt onto millennials and future generations. >BART janitor grossed $270K in pay and benefits last year https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12852104 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12852104
- throwawaymanbot 9y agoSo according to you... its public employees who have caused the 10 Billion dollar hole like this janitor?? lmao...Suuuuuuuuure! Why not check out how SF finances its loans, and some of the extortionate sweetheart deals that have been giving. Chicago is another prime example of this. (Example their parking meters etc..)
- Boxbot 9y agohaving seen what BART janitors have to deal with, I say give them a raise and double the headcount.
- eldavido 9y agoWe don't need more janitors. We need to get serious about fare enforcement. Fence in all the fare-paid areas so people don't blatantly jump over them, and get rid of the swinging doors that people walk through with zero consequence. BART is totally lawless. In the past 4 years, I've had a knife pulled on me, and had someone try to steal my computer. Every day I see dance shows, littering, people passed out on two seats, people blasting music, rampant fare evasion, and drug use at Powell/Civic Center. I'm tired of it and want the system's rules to be enforced.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- xienze 9y ago> I'm tired of it and want the system's rules to be enforced. Won't happen because, let's face it, minorities are going to predominantly be affected by enforcement. SF's far too progressive to let that happen.
- sethev 9y agoIt seems weird to insist that all future obligations have to be funded with money that's set aside now. To give a small example, it would sound crazy if someone said people had to set aside a fund whose interest could pay all the cost of raising a child in advance.
- bko 9y agoIf you're promising someone something in the future (pension) for work that they're going to do now, then you should fund that. If your salary included a big bonus or deferred benefits, would you mind that your manager doesn't set aside any money for that promised benefit?
- sethev 9y agoIt's the indefinite funding of a fixed obligation that seems weird to me. If my manager said, "I'm sorry I can't pay your $5000 bonus next year because we don't have $111,000 set aside in a fund earning 4.5% in perpetuity" i'd be a lot more upset. Honestly there's probably something about the accounting that I don't understand.
- closeparen 9y agoPension is not bonus. You don’t get to modulate the amount depending on how generous you’re feeling in a given year. Workers have as much right to it as to the wages they’ve earned and saved into a 401k or IRA. It’s the enployee’s money; the employer is just a steward. Failing to pay a pension is the same as robbing a former employee’s house to take back the wages you’be already paid them.
- ghthor 9y agoI'd never take a pension over a 401k. I'd much rather be able to pick some of the investments my retirement is funding/being funded by then none. Seems crazy to me not researching and picking the investments, but maybe I'm bias by my understanding and intelligence versus the average American.
- diogenescynic 9y agoIf Jane Kim becomes mayor it will get exponentially worse. The city is incredibly poorly run and dirtier than any other city in America that I’ve been too.