3 ms·
Another possible explanation could be that animals feeded on an artificial monotonous diet and set free from predation pressure, start showing genetic/colour de
by pvaldes 9y ago
Another possible explanation could be that animals feeded on an artificial monotonous diet and set free from predation pressure, start showing genetic/colour defects quickly. Similar colour issues happen with captive birds and fishes unless we provide extra charotenes to complete its diet. In the wild the diet is much more diverse and finding charotenes is not a problem.
Or that when the mice population increases the animals just fight more. Domestic mouse males fight and bite other males. Mother with litters will attack males also. More animals in the same place = more scars by bites, and this could easily lead to an increase on white (regrown) hair patches. A simple explanation that does not depend on human contact. Is normal in birds to create white feathers after a predation event to quickly replace missing ones and cover bald patches.
And another explanation could be that when the mice population increases, their individual size decreases because there are less food for each one (and different hormone interactions non necessarily human related). If we extract some of those mice and put it in a new cage subject to the same human manipulation but with a more diverse sources of food, would the average skull size quickly increase again? Would the animals with white patches decrease? I bet that yes.
- hchasestevens 9y agoYes, these are all possible explanations, but the specific symptoms observed - development of spots and smaller cranial capacity - are well documented as common effects of human domestication across a broad range of mammalian species. That the same mechanism is driving the changes observed in these mice would be a simpler explanation than various disparate, piecemeal effects combining to produce them.
- pvaldes 9y agoDomestication, like in the foxes study, needs a small genetic pool to work and a deliberate selection of the sexual reproduction by humans (killing the non-desired ones, mating only animals with desired traits). Nothing of that is happening here. One of the problems with the article is that does not try to discard those explanations. A simple check to investigate if white spots are linked to sex or age would help. A check for scars in those patches would positively help us to understand what is happenning. It does not mean necessarily harming the mice, they could just rasurate some white patches and take a look. We are concluding that animals sort of "deliberately increase" their "cuteness" to please humans but this conclusion is not justified. What if aggression is just being increased as response to animals being marked with strange human odour?. This kind of articles should discuss at least some of those alternative explanations.