5 ms·
No CEO should earn 1,000 times more than a regular employee
- troydavis 9y agoThis article doesn’t seem to give any reasons to support the opinion in the title. It describes ways to accomplish this - mostly legislation and shaming - but not why a limit should exist, nor why 1,000 is a more logical limit or goal than any other multiple (10,000? 100?).
- pmoriarty 9y agoI have a suggestion. Make the pay equal. The janitor and the CEO should make the same amount of money.
- crispyporkbites 9y agothen you'll have no CEOs and lots of janitors
- pmoriarty 9y agoCan't say I'll miss 'em.
- jazzyk 9y agoYou are kidding, right? If money is not a factor, I want to feel important, have people suck up to me, travel on corporate jet, etc. :-)
- crispyporkbites 9y agoYou’d get bored of that after a week. If you’re not getting paid more you’ll resent having to work 24/7, with no real breaks and suffer watching your relationships and family crumble. You’ll have no hobbies, no real friends and be incredibly lonely. But you won’t even notice because all you care about is the business and your facade. The janitor goes home after their shift and is completely free. They get their 4 weeks vacation and max 40 hour working week and can do whatever they want in their spare time.
- lkrubner 9y agoThe CEO job is the most fun job at any company. Everyone wants that job, and they would want it even if it didn’t pay any money at all. I personally would be happy to work for free as the CEO of a lot of these companies.
- lulmerchant 9y agoThe CEO job is the most high pressure job in an organisation, and by definition comes with the greatest level of responsibility. Statistically speaking, you would likely be a terrible CEO, and hate doing it.
- bryanlarsen 9y agoI remember reading a study saying that middle management had the most stressful jobs. The worst stress is caused when you have responsibility without power. CEO's have a lot of responsibility, but they also have a lot of power.
- Erlangolem 9y agoI’d add that failing as a middle manager gets you fired with very little, while failing as a CEO gets you fired with a golden parachute. Failing as a CEO also seems to do little to harm your future prospects.
- lulmerchant 9y agoYou're really only talking about a minority of CEOs here. Most of the time, failing as a CEO will mean the end of your career.
- Erlangolem 9y agoThat’s a fair point, I overstated things. I’d rephrase by adding “at a F500 company” after both “middle managers” and “CEO’s” in my original post.
- maxharris 9y agoIf doing the job of a founder/CEO were so easy, why do so many people fail at it? When Steve Jobs came back to Apple, it made terrible products. It had a market cap of $3 billion, hadn't had profits in years, and was six weeks from bankruptcy. During his tenure as CEO, Apple made consistently excellent products, and it entered the right new markets. Its market cap rose to $350 billion. It has since doubled that, and is now the largest and most profitable company in the world. The value that CEOs bring to their companies is exclusively in the decisions they make. That's why Jobs deserved to be paid well over 1000X a "regular" employee!
- pmoriarty 9y agoWas it really Steve Jobs or the people that worked for him that deserve the credit for Apple's success?
- maxharris 9y agoWho chose the people that worked for him? Or do you think that the management team at Apple also does nothing? Much of the board and many of the execs at Apple changed when they bought NeXT. So much so that many people at the time called it a "reverse acquisition." Jobs was great at finding the best talent. Jony Ive was at Apple long before the NeXT acquisition, and Jobs put him in the right position very, very rapidly. Would the average person have done the same thing? Would the average person have cared nearly so much about design?
- maxharris 9y agoAlso, what about the decision to stop licensing the MacOS to cloners in 1997? A decision this big has to be made by the CEO. At the time, Apple was dying, and Jobs was the one that made that call. It was quite unpopular at the time. But it was also absolutely the right thing to do! You might find this hard to believe, but Gil Amelio (Apple's CEO before Jobs) floated the idea of splitting Apple into two disintegrated companies - "Apple Hard" and "Apple Soft." Can you guess how that would have turned out? (You can't build an iPod, an iPhone, an iPad or a Mac that way, because the entire point is to make the product better by integration.)
- aphextron 9y agoWhy? This article explains that inequality does exist, but doesn't say why that's a problem.
- jbronn 9y agoBecause research has shown there’s an inverse correlation between CEO pay and company performance.¹ ¹ https://online.wsj.com/public/resources/documents/CEOperformance122509.pdf https://online.wsj.com/public/resources/documents/CEOperform...
- LyndsySimon 9y agoThat doesn't seem surprising at all - a CEO's reputation is tied to the reputation of their company, so it makes sense that a poorly-performing company would have to pay more to attract the same level of expertise as a well-performing one. If the poorly-performing company fails, then the CEO's market value will decrease. Higher compensation offsets that.
- downrightmike 9y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ik1y4ZNSjek https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ik1y4ZNSjek
- nkkollaw 9y agoIt's not easy to find somebody who has the brain, knowledge, and experience to run a big company. It's extremely easy to find somebody that can serve food. Evidently, it's 1000 easier to serve food (or whatever other job). What is the problem with that?
- jazzyk 9y agoI think the title is imprecise. I know exactly two people who deserve that kind of money: Jobs and Musk (there may be a couple more) with a track of repeat success and world-changing impact. Most big-corp CEOs don't deserve the money they get. People who got lucky and complete failures in particular (like Gil Amelio, or Carly Fiorina).
- whack 9y agoI agree that inequality is a problem, but I think the article is on the wrong track. The richest people in society aren't business executives. They are overwhelmingly entrepreneurs and finance-traders. Ie, Bill Gates and Warren Buffet. Koch brothers and George Soros. Compared to them, CEOs and C-level executives are mere pawns. To give a sense of scale, Tim Cook, leading the most valuable company in the world, earned $13M in 2017, working what is likely 60-80 hour weeks. In comparison, Bill Gates with his $82B assets can sit on his couch all day, and make $13M in investment returns in a couple days. If anything, CEOs have more in common with regular workers, than with the truly wealthy. This focus on CEOs as the bogeyman, causes us to overlook some more important causes of inequality, such as the ultra-low tax rates on capital-gains, the numerous deductions available to the 0.1%, and the preservation of wealth across multiple generations via estate inheritances.
- jazzyk 9y ago>Tim Cook, leading the most valuable company in the world, earned $13M in 2017 Not so fast, comrade :-) You just showed his salary, but forgot the stock ownership which is part of the total compensation package. In 2017, he cashed in at least 43 million from this sale. https://www.bloomberg.com/gadfly/articles/2017-08-30/tim-cook-apple-stock-sale-weirdly-timed https://www.bloomberg.com/gadfly/articles/2017-08-30/tim-coo...
- nso95 9y agoWhich is still a small fraction of the wealth of Bill Gates and Buffet
- jazzyk 9y agoHe has been CEO for only 6 years. His net worth is about 800M, increasing by about 100M every year, so he will be a billionaire in a couple of years. He did not invent anything, he did not start a world-changing company (like Gates). He is a competent manager, but nothing more than that. https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-net-worth-of-Tim-Cook https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-net-worth-of-Tim-Cook
- makecheck 9y agoIt would be a lot easier for executives to defend massive salaries if they weren’t also making money hand over fist when they fail spectacularly. What’s worse is that it seems like there are an awful lot of executives that don’t execute perfectly. While I don’t personally believe there is any job in the world worth one hundred million or more per year (I mean, these people aren’t even physically in harm’s way!!!), why on earth aren’t companies making sure that money swings far in the other direction too? If you want a chance at $100M a year, the company should be able to FINE you millions and millions of dollars when you make costly mistakes, for example.
- natecavanaugh 9y agoThat all sounds great, in theory, and sounds super fair. But how do you attract executive talent without large salaries and golden parachutes? When one person's choices can make the difference between bankruptcy and having surging profits, how should we compensate them? I do think our distribution is a bit top heavy, but I think of it ethically, not pragmatically or fiscally. Short of executives collectively deciding against their own financial interests, or regulators choosing for everyone (and the economy being exposed to regulatory capture), I don't see what you're proposing. And physical danger is like physical labor. It's not intrinsically tied to the value society places on that work. Personally I don't think skydiving instructors should be paid more than high school teachers.
- jazzyk 9y agoThe "large salaries and golden parachutes are necessary to attract top-notch talent" is just typical b.s to justify awarding even more compensation within the boys (and girls) club. In reality, you could easily find at least several equally qualified executives to fill the position.
- natecavanaugh 9y agoHow many have you been able to find and attract? Anyone who says "you could easily", wrt business, obviously is either a business genius unlike the rest of us, or has never tried. Trust me, finding top notch talent that you're willing to trust with the direction of your company is probably harder than finding a spouse.
- stmfreak 9y agoThis is a very misguided metric. A CEO Of a small company with 100 employees and $20MM annual revenue is going to be compensated very differently from a CEO of a giant company with 200,000 employees and $40B+ in annual revenue. Although their line workers may have similar skills, jobs, and compensation. A 1000x ratio may be too much for the small company CEO and way too little for the giant company's CEO. Fortunately, shareholders can dedcide and influence each company's Board. There is no need for the government to get involved unless politicians are trying to raise another witch hunt for distracting peasants.