3 ms·
The way to get more feedback is to reduce the load of the individual in community moderation. Try going to a tag... lets say Java. https://stackoverflow.com/qu
by shagie 9y ago
The way to get more feedback is to reduce the load of the individual in community moderation.
Try going to a tag... lets say Java. https://stackoverflow.com/questions/tagged/java https://stackoverflow.com/questions/tagged/java Now, on each post on that page read it, edit it if it needs editing (this includes things like "i am trying to use a path..." - fix all the grammar (the post I'm looking at is tagged java, c#, android, .net and google maps - https://stackoverflow.com/q/49349444 https://stackoverflow.com/q/49349444 ). Give a comment if additional clarification is needed.
Then go back to the tag page and see how many more there are. Repeat.
To help the most people possible, and help the people who are answering questions know which are the posts that they can help the most - vote on the questions. Up and down.
If you know it is a good question that you can decode - fix it first. People casting close votes don't see that you're trying to answer - they see an unclear post. Whats more, an unclear question (that might be clear to you) isn't clear to everyone else. You've spent a minute or so decoding it - contribute that time back to community by fixing the post. Don't leave it in a comment - fix the question before writing an answer.
Consider that if a post is getting close votes there and down votes even with the fix, it might not be a good question for Stack Overflow. Not all good questions are good questions for a particular site. One doesn't ask coding questions on Hacker News even though it may be a good question.
That a post is too easy to down vote - by percentage, down votes are a small, small fraction of the total votes cast. Up votes are 8x more common than down votes.
Improved questions many still not be a good fit for Stack Overflow. A recommendation question or opinion poll, or something that is "how do you design Amazon" is still a poor fit, even if it has been improved.
Close votes expire as it is. If its good enough, it will not get any more and there's no issue.
Down votes are a signal to people answering questions that this isn't a good question. Look at a page with 50 questions on it. Decide which one you're going to spend time on - that is likely based partly on which questions have gotten up votes.
Rewritten questions don't necessarily mean that the question is good now.
In the past, when I've down voted and left a comment I've gotten a dozen angry pings from comments from the person and sometimes half a dozen down votes on my other posts (that then got removed for serial voting). I decided not to leave comments any more at that point. I'm not there to argue with a person about if their question is good or not.
The person asking the question has all the time in the world to perfect it before posting. They can see the preview and how it will look. They can run it through a grammar checker. They can notice even things like the red squiggles under misspelled words on any modern browser.
There is no reason why they can't post a good question the first time - or at least one that shows that they have put in at least as much time as they're expecting of the person answering.
- alkonaut 9y agoBut I can’t choose among 100 questions to answer. It’s on the rare occasion that the question I can answer shows up that a do it. That’s the situation for a lot of us. We answer a few niche questions. And when that question happens to be poorly written - I can’t pick another. I can ignore it or I can answer it. Some times I’m almost inclined to commenting “give me your email and I’ll sort you out because your Q will be closed even though I see your problem and had the exact same problem”. I think a great feature would be “protection”. If I adopt a question I can take responsibility for both my answer and fixing the question. If I’m say 5k rep and the asker is low rep I should be trusted to be able to be a “mentor”. The question can even be hidden until I and the asker have worked on both question and answer together. So the context is - asker: can’t write a good Q without help - answerer: wants to help make better asker perhaps MORE than I want to make a better Q/A site, can’t use time to answer another Q instead This is very common in my experience
- shagie 9y agoStack Overflow had a mentoring experiment a few months ago - https://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/357198/mentorship-research-project-results-wrap-up https://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/357198/mentorship-r... and while it worked in providing people who were interested in asking good questions, it really didn't scale well. "Protecting" a question in the way you described would likely result in people claiming a question and then preventing others from answering it in a timely manner when it doesn't need any help (there's a lot driven by gamification). Just picture the fastest gun in the west problem and the "now I can click and prevent everyone else from answering?" If its poorly written - you can do something. You can edit it. You can close vote it. You can down vote it. Those are signals to the author that it needs to be worked on. Look at https://meta.stackexchange.com/q/216683 https://meta.stackexchange.com/q/216683 - and that the best way to drive away a user is to do noting. To ignore them. Closing their questions, down voting their questions, commenting, editing... and yes, up voting and answering - those all help. Editing a question is much better for new users than voting on their question.
- alkonaut 9y ago