3 ms·
“This tool is trivial to get working and is a drop in replacement for the tool you are struggling with” seems like a completely valid answer. The point is that
by alkonaut 9y ago
“This tool is trivial to get working and is a drop in replacement for the tool you are struggling with” seems like a completely valid answer.
The point is that the site IS a problem/solution site, under the (imho mistaken) label of Q/A site. The answers should be solutions to the askers problem, not answers to the askers question.
Decoding the problem from the question is often the hard part. If this answer wasn’t valid (the asker had to use the tool mentioned) then the solution is invalid of course. But this is in my experience much less common than the opposite - that there is a problem buried in the question that can be solved without answering the question. It leads to a few “take the bus” answers to “my car has problem X” - but I think that’s acceptable. The asker can clarify that the problem wasn’t getting from A to B but was to fix the car. All this should usually take place in comments for initial clarification of course
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoReminds me of the "Just use jQuery" people. I really, vehemently, disagree that recommending a completely different tool is a good answer, except in the context of having already correctly answered the actual question. Since the actual question was already correctly answered, I think OP's problem was just how they phrased it. Simply prefacing the answer with something like "Anyone landing here in the future may be interested in this alternative..." might have prevented a negative reaction. OP's post sounds like they're completely ignoring the question and answering the one they wish was asked, which happens a whole hell of a lot when crowd sourcing like this.
- guilhas 9y agoExcept it is not a "completely different" tool, it is basically a open source clone that works the mostly the same. Except in the situation asked it works better. Also I explained why in the comments.
- alkonaut 9y agoJust use jquery is nothing like this though. It also sounds like an answer typically supplied by someone who is perhaps often not much of an expert. So I think there are good and bad “do X instead” answers, and the good ones are among the most important answers on the site and shouldn’t be categorized as unwanted because of the jquery-variant of the same.
- sosborn 9y ago> I really, vehemently, disagree that recommending a completely different tool is a good answer, except in the context of having already correctly answered the actual question. I think the trick is that sometimes this is true, and sometimes it isn't. I have seen people try to do things with tools that aren't equipped for the task at all, simply because that was all they knew. When all you have is a hammer ... It does take, however, some effort to figure out when this is the case. Problems arise when people make a suggestion for another tool without fully understanding what the OP is trying to achieve. Which brings me to my personal nitpick about StackOverflow: Many of the problems we are discussing right now would go away if people were better at articulating exactly what they are trying to accomplish when the draft their original questions.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoIn which case the appropriate thing to do is answer the question that was asked, then provide the recommendation for the alternative. Sometimes there are reasons you only have a hammer and really don't feel like getting into an argument on the internet about "how you should be doing it".
- jodrellblank 9y agoIt leads to a few “take the bus” answers to “my car has problem X” In this case paexec and psexec might be drop in replacements , but the web is rife with "how do I bold text in notepad?" "Lol m$ just use Linux". I already know I can take the bus for goodness sake! Except .. sometimes the asker does know they could try alternatives and sometimes they don't. Psexec is probably cobbled together in a pile of scripts that are owned by another company and work fine against fifty servers but not one new one and the owning team won't change to something unproven.. But here we can both make up situations where it is and/or isn't a good answer - at the point where you're saying "decide the problem" means "guess what they want" - can't we trust people to have asked what they want? No we can't and that leads to all the "what are you really doing?" clarifying comments. And those comments drive people away as hostile and interrogatory. The site just has no structure for different types of people and their levels of background knowledge of askers vs types of people answering. Is the range of skills and experiences much much bigger than easily assumed?