5 ms·
That’s not true and if you can believe that after taking several economics courses it speaks poorly of your teachers. The main benefits of free trade are in sp
by barry-cotter 9y ago
That’s not true and if you can believe that after taking several economics courses it speaks poorly of your teachers.
The main benefits of free trade are in specialisation. People specialise in what they’re good in and trade for other goods and services. Specialisation leads to greater efficiency, meaning you can do the same with less, or more with the same amount. Notice the complete lack of the words domestic production or intellectual property.
The case for free trade is that in the long run specialisation makes us richer. Units have nothing to do with it. Metric or imperial, services and goods are what they are.
- cgag 9y agoI notice that domestic production seems to be implicitly valued at zero which seems likely to be wrong to me.
- barry-cotter 9y agoThe case for free trade does not care about borders. It cares about consumption, which there will be more of if things can be produced most efficiently. Things can be produced most efficiently with maximum specialisation, which is likeliest with free trade. Domestic production can be consumed more easily than foreign production so it is more valued because transport costs are lower. The border between San Francisco is as relevant as that between California and Nevada, or the US and Mexico. There are certainly things where it’s good to have domestic production, vaccines for one. But the argument is grossly overused. The wool of angora goats is protected in the US as of military value. Trading for what you need has worked out well for plenty of countries. Switzerland, Luxembourg, Costa Rica, Bahrain, Singapore, Hong Kong, my native Ireland. Domestic production is overrated.
- andosa 9y agoOverrating domestic value creation is how you end up being a third world country. I think you are oversimplifying free market dynamics. Free market doesn't magically create optimal results for consumers (see monopolies and the resulting lack of competition and suboptimal results for consumers as one example). Similarly it doesn't magically create optimal results for maximising the well being of a country.
- TheAdamAndChe 9y ago> It cares about consumption, which there will be more of if things can be produced most efficiently. This is part of the problem. Production doesn't occur in a vacuum, and the most efficient methods of production are often either terrible for the workers, terrible for the environment, or terrible for society. Pure, unfettered globalization would be ideal if the goal was production and wealth generation maximization because it maximizes the labor pool and capital allocation efficiency, but those shouldn't be the only things that governments and economists worry about.
- barry-cotter 9y agoIf you look at where most of the world’s wealth is produced and how your worries may be allayed. The US and the EU are almost half of the world economy by themselves. Add Canada and Japanand you’re comfortably above half. If there are problems caused by economic growth the products of said growth can buy solutions to them. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kuznets_curve#Environmental_Kuznets_curve https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kuznets_curve#Environmental_...
- asdfaoeu 9y agoHe is admitting those benefits. His point is that with different tax rates and regulations the market is distorted and if anything imposing tariffs / revenue taxes is just equalising the market. I don't think he's talking literally about units.
- barry-cotter 9y agoIf other people do stupid things you don’t have to do stupid things too. Market distortions, different tax rates and regulations do not change how returns to specialisation and gains from trade work. Anti-dumping tariffs are stupid because it not notnto your benefit to punish people for giving you cheap stuff that should be expensive. Being able to have different tax rates is part of the power to tax, which is part of being sovereign. Equalising the market is a fool’s game. The market is what it is. If you want to help some people or groups by all means do it, but tariffs are a very inefficient way to do it. Transfer payments ftw!
- danbruc 9y agoAnti-dumping tariffs are stupid because it not notnto your benefit to punish people for giving you cheap stuff that should be expensive. That is only true in a very simplistic model. If a country sells for example cheap subsidized steel you may lose your steel production capability because you are not able to compete with that price. But once you lost that capability it may become prohibitively expensive to regain it because the initial costs to rebuild the knowledge and infrastructure is going to be much higher than the marginal costs for an established industry and you would have to accept, at least to some extend, which ever price they ask for. The other country may also be able to offer a lower price due to externalities, for example exploitation of their workers or environmental destruction, and you may want to compensate for that.
- barry-cotter 9y agoIf you’re not able to compete with a price that’s the market saying you’d be better off doing something else with those resources. If you suspect that the price is due to subsidy, great, free money. If you want to maintain domestic production capacity subsidise it. If you want to reduce startup costs pay to mothball a plant. If you want to maintain expertise subsidise the salaries of citizens who go abroad to learn about or work in those industries. As far as externalities go you certainly have a point but if you feel you have a right to tell other people and countries what to do, go ahead. I don’t think there’s any reason to stop anywhere between sovereignty and colonialism. Those positions are coherent, the ones in between aren’t.