3 ms·
> This is why we tax profit and not revenue. Different industries have radically different cost structures. That is completely irrelevant as long as the tax is
by AnthonyMouse 9y ago
> This is why we tax profit and not revenue. Different industries have radically different cost structures.
That is completely irrelevant as long as the tax is only collected once at final sale and not every time the goods change hands within a supply chain.
If Walmart has 97 cents of cost per dollar in revenue then the sum total profit within their supply chain is 97 cents. Somebody is getting every penny in the dollar.
If the government says that for every dollar in revenue you have to pay 20 cents in taxes then Walmart will either raise prices by ~20% or require their suppliers to lower prices by ~20%. In no event do they go out of business, because their customers still need what their suppliers produce.
It's possible for a tax to destroy a market, but it has nothing to do with margins of the final retailer and everything to do with how much total surplus exists. If the government demands a certain number of dollars in taxes and either the manufacturers or customers can eat that and still be willing to engage in the transaction, that's what happens. But if there isn't that much surplus in the transaction, it no longer happens. Because before somebody was spending an hour to make a certain amount of money and after they have to spend an hour to make only 80% that much money, which can cross over the threshold where they say screw it and fold up shop. That has nothing to do with whether you call it sales tax or income tax.
It's true of any tax on any product. There are products with high margins that a small tax could nonetheless destroy because the industry is high risk, so investors won't invest without high returns. If the tax makes the risk-adjusted returns fall below what it is for other investments, the product ceases to exist despite high margins, because the high margins may be entirely necessary to compensate for the risk.
- conanbatt 9y ago> If the government says that for every dollar in revenue you have to pay 20 cents in taxes then Walmart will either raise prices by ~20% or require their suppliers to lower prices by ~20%. In no event do they go out of business, because their customers still need what their suppliers produce. You are assuming there is no elasticity here. People would stop working for walmart and go work for google, in this example, so yes, the tax would destroy walmart.
- discodave 9y agoThis is nonsense. Unless Google opens thousands of "walk-in-distribution centers" close to consumers, or 100% of commerce moves online, then there will still be demand for what Walmart sells. Walmart sells essentials like food, clothes, and medicine. In what world does a consumer need an Android, or the internet, but not food.
- conanbatt 9y agoSome abstract thought here: the OP mentioned only 2 companies and I responded within that limitations, but in reality walmart competes with amazon. So if amazon has higher margins than Walmart because of the business model then walmart is disproportionately hit by the tax.
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> So if amazon has higher margins than Walmart because of the business model then walmart is disproportionately hit by the tax. Still not how that works. Suppose a knickknack costs $1 at Walmart. They pay their supplier $.50, $.47 is the cost of operating the store (rent, utilities, staff, etc.) and $.03 is profit. Amazon sells the same knickknack for the same $1 and buys it for the same $.50 but the cost of operating their store is only $.10 so they make $.40 profit. Now the government says they must both pay $.20. Suppose both the manufacturer and the customer are completely inelastic. They won't change their prices at all. Which store is at a disadvantage? You still don't know. It could be that Amazon needs higher returns to generate investment because online stores are higher risk. They have more competition and lower barriers to entry, their assets are heavily skewed toward goodwill and branding which are more susceptible to damage by scandal than e.g. real estate holdings, etc. It could be that if you cut their profits in half like that, they get no investors. Meanwhile Walmart has to come up with the $.20 out of their store operating costs, but those costs are an opportunity to cut something that Amazon doesn't have. They could improve the energy efficiency of their stores. They could lay off some greeters. They could renegotiate the lease on their stores against the fact that all other retailers will have to pay the same new tax, which reduces the market value of commercial rental property. There is no guarantee that Amazon is the one that comes out ahead.
- WillReplyfFood 9y agoThe point you made is routinely abused though, by having internal sales and allowing for profits to be laundered off towards countrys with low tax rules. Im Googles german division, i made a profit. I buy a server rack from the irish-division for 10.000.000 $. This server rack will be shipped, and i reduced my profit. They do pay nearly no taxes. Now, the usual neo-liberal vector here is to blame the states for getting there tax buisness not synced, which they cant because they compete among one another- which the NeoLibs ususally know. Taxing for customer access would be fairer. If my citizens engage in a buisness relationship with a company for x minutes or y % of there total economic activity per day- then you pay a tax on that- no matter where on the planet you are. Sorry Imgur.