3 ms·
The Classical Roman Empire had a surprisingly ineffective and inefficient administrative system, even at its height. It was strongly centralized, and the Empire
by jcranmer 9y ago
The Classical Roman Empire had a surprisingly ineffective and inefficient administrative system, even at its height. It was strongly centralized, and the Empire, even by the second century, was simply too large to manage by one person. After the Crisis of the Third Century, Diocletian essentially solved the issue by installing multiple co-emperors to divvy up the work, although this did have massive issues (turns out that having two theoretically co-equal rulers in an absolute monarchy doesn't bode well for stability).
What essentially happened from the third century through the seventh century is that the internal instability caused more and more power to be (intentionally or not) devolved to more local elites. After Christianity became the state religion, the administrative backbone of Roman Europe became the Church and not the Empire itself, which also helped to hasten the devolution. At some point, the local rulers and population would realize that they're not getting anything from Rome and they owe nothing to Rome, so why call themselves Roman? The Western Roman Empire effectively dissolved itself into nothingness, and its passing went more or less unnoticed by contemporaneous observers.
Portraying this gradual process as a concrete "fall" is somewhat problematic. There is a striking continuity on many levels. Even the polities end up being fairly stable: the Frankish kingdom eventually ended up inheriting the Western Roman Empire de facto and arguably de jure following the crowning of Charlemagne as Holy Roman Empire, while the Eastern Roman Empire became the Byzantine Empire. In both cases, the administrative systems had been transformed dramatically from the traditional Roman model. That's not to say that there wasn't a severe shock, but the biggest shock would have been the loss of North Africa (the key granary supplying Rome) that created a vicious cycle of economic decline. The actual date commonly given for the fall (476) was more or less contemporaneously ignored by everybody as yet another change in the local ruler.
- Naritai 9y agoWhile my only source is the Fall of Rome podcast that others on this thread are raving about, one key point he makes is that whether or not it was a 'Fall' depends a lot on where you lived. Yes, there was lots of continuity in Aquitane and Gaul, but if you lived in much of Northern Africa, (what is now) northern France, or Britain, you saw a significant decline in your standard of living. Britain even stopped using currency altogether.
- jedharris 9y agoIANA historian, but do read contemporary scholarly history. Chris Wickham whom everyone seems to respect thinks that population in most regions of the Western Empire fell by 50% or more after 300 AD. Setting aside arguments about what the "fall of an empire" means, a 50% decline in population is much more serious than administrative devolution. I'm sure that anyone in that period who could see a large enough span of time would have felt something major was lost.