3 ms·
I have a serious medical condition. I found that a particular brand of salt was very beneficial. I became an affiliate and had ads on my health blog for that br
by DoreenMichele 9y ago
I have a serious medical condition. I found that a particular brand of salt was very beneficial. I became an affiliate and had ads on my health blog for that brand of salt. People accused me of having a conflict of interest and just trying to make money off of sick people.
I am very leery of medical advice where I know doctors are basically there to prescribe drugs and surgeries when I know from experience I can get better results from diet and lifestyle. But talking about that is a huge shitshow. Most people don't want to hear that.
I don't know how to solve this. The money needs to come from somewhere, but the minute money is involved, no one trusts what you say and it seems to not matter the order in which that association happens. Being a believer in the product because it worked for you and trying to make money on something you believe in makes you one of those MLM people in the minds of a lot of people.
- empath75 9y agoBecause unless you can back it up with double blind studies showing effectiveness, you are selling snake oil. You simply don’t know if it worked for you. You used it and got better, but you have no idea if it caused the improvement or not.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Spooky23 9y agoIf you don't want to be accused of being a shill, don't shill.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoWhat I want is to share useful information with people who have largely been failed by conventional medicine and also somehow pay my bills. I have literally given away information for free for years. I have also been very poor for years. These two facts are not unrelated. Doctors are not somehow above having a conflict of interest. One cancer doctor* went to prison for his heinous treatment of patients for personal profit, some of whom never actually had cancer. This isn't some problem unique to me or unique to people who aren't medical professionals. The entire health industry has a problem here. Also, that's a personal attack and violates HN guidelines. * https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2015/07/10/cancer-doctor-sentenced-years-horrific-fraud/29996107/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2015/07/10/cancer...
- Spooky23 9y agoI’m sorry you feel attacked. After watching a friend suffer, I feel a visceral negative reaction to peddling dietary supplements alongside medicalish advice.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoI wasn't peddling dietary supplements. I was recommending a particular brand of sea salt. Salt is not a supplement. It's a normal part of the diet. There is research showing people with my condition who surf have a better prognosis. This research is respected enough it led to the creation of a prescription treatment where people inhale nebulized salt water. I think that's a silly conclusion and a more logical one is that sea salt is beneficial. I also recommend people like me simply go to the beach whenever possible and/or live near the coast because this is known to help. I'm sorry for your suffering, but the problem here is that people are suffering horribly and dying from my condition and there is no path forward for helping them. Meanwhile, drugs are being developed that cost $300k annually and help only 5 percent of the population but I am evil incarnate and viciously attacked on a regular basis for a. Saying "I did X and it helped me" and b. Trying to find some means -- any means -- to monetize my writing on any subject, whether health related or not, so I can take better care of myself and stop being desperately poor. I blog. The information is free. It isn't framed as medical advice. And when I criticize conventional medicine and how it gets monetized, I also get attacked for that, a thing that happened just today in a different discussion in HN. There is zero logical consistency here. The thing that is consistent boils down to prejudice. I have thought a great deal about this problem space and how to monetize it. And I cannot think of a good path forward. Trying to make money off of helping people with their health is just inherently problematic. Period. Whether you decide to become a medical professional or not.
- dang 9y agoThis breaks the HN guidelines. Could you please read them and abide by the rules when commenting here? https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- jonnybgood 9y ago> I am very leery of medical advice where I know doctors are basically there to prescribe drugs and surgeries when I know from experience I can get better results from diet and lifestyle. That sounds almost like a false dichotomy. I don’t think any decent doctor would exclude diet and lifestyle in regards to health. And neither should the patient. But I can’t help but wonder how often a patient gives up that kind of information. Does a person suffering from obesity and related symptoms disclose the fact they drink a 2-liter of carbonated sugar water a day? And since diet and lifestyle is not in the doctor’s control, what else can a doctor do? Best to get a referral to a dietician I guess.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoDietitians are routinely included on the medical team for my condition and their advice is "high fat, high salt, high calorie diet." They literally prescribe junk food. I have found that this is not in my best interest. I found that it is surprisingly effective to pay attention to nutrition and food quality. And when I began getting better, my doctor was in no way curious. He just scheduled me fewer appointments because I wasn't sick enough to need his time.
- rsync 9y ago"I have a serious medical condition. I found that a particular brand of salt was very beneficial." Can you elaborate ? What did they add to the salt that gave it health benefits ? (genuinely curious)
- DoreenMichele 9y agoIt is a brand of sea salt. Table salt is almost entirely sodium chloride, plus things like additives that help it not clump so it pours easier. If I recall correctly, the salt in question is 84 percent sodium chloride and 16 percent micronutrients and other minerals found naturally in ocean water. My body misprocesses salt. A high salt diet is standard medical prescription. I concluded that the additives in table salt are problematic for me, in part because I misprocess some molecules and in part because I consume more salt than average, which means I consume more of the additives as well. I also concluded that misprocessing salt has various knock on effects. When the body sweats out sodium chloride at high rates, it drags other minerals with it. Those micronutrients made a big difference to me. I no longer need that brand of salt, in part because I live near the coast and get it in the air, in part because I spent years remedying my various deficiencies and I am no longer severely deficient. There is research that people with my condition who surf have a better prognosis. So my conclusions aren't entirely unsupported by existing research. The medical world used that research to develop a nebulized treatment. Their theory is that surfing helps because you breath salty sea air and it helps the lungs. I used it to conclude that sea salt with a variety of micronutrients made sense for me. I think it is rather silly to conclude that surfing is solely or primarily beneficial because of the air you are breathing. The condition is famous for negatively impacting lung function, but it is genetic and there is a lot more going on than lung issues. In a nutshell, the medical world recognizes that salt is significant for my condition, but they only think quantity matters. I decided quality mattered more.
- bdcravens 9y agoCF I presume? (none of my business of course, but me too)
- 9y ago