4 ms·
If you are selling things to people in country X, you have to be very careful if you decide to ignore X's laws for such sales. You and your company may be beyon
by tzs 9y ago
If you are selling things to people in country X, you have to be very careful if you decide to ignore X's laws for such sales. You and your company may be beyond the legal reach of X, but your suppliers and service providers might not be.
For example, if you decide to ignore tax laws in X, X might put pressure on your credit card processors to stop aiding your tax evasion. If the credit card processors respond by cutting off your ability to processes card, they might not bother just cutting you off from accepting payments from country X. They might cut you off completely. That would be pretty annoying.
- jakeogh 9y agoThat's a feature. I want to know if the people I do business with are applying laws to me that do not apply. Too "bad" about the US dropping the TPP, I assume that was the backdoor planned for "compliance".
- ascorbic 9y agoIf you have users in the EU then the laws do apply to you, even if you insist they do not. If you don't then you have nothing to worry about.
- jakeogh 9y agoBy your logic, any country can make up a law, go to my US website, and demand I follow it. Demand all you want, this is the point of national sovereignty.
- ascorbic 9y agoBy your logic, you should be allowed to go to Ladbrokes.com and put some cash on tonight's NBA games. I could if I wanted to, and I'm sure Ladbrokes would love to take your bets if they could. But you can't, because countries can make laws about selling to their residents. Ladbrokes blocks you, because US law says they must. I'm sure you can rely on your site being too small for EU regulators to bother with, and I'm sure it would be hard for them to enforce if you have no operations in the EU, but the fact you ignore the laws doesn't mean they lack jurisdiction.
- jakeogh 9y agoIrrelevant. Ladbrokes is not a US firm, I don't know, need to know, or care what their legal system is. It's entirely possible their laws require them to comply with US law, or that they have assets in the US. A website hosted in the US, owned by a US citizen, residing in the US, is not subject to laws written in other countries.
- ascorbic 9y agoThe reason I used the example of a gambling website is precisely because the US has history of prosecuting the operators of non-US websites for allowing US residents to join. There's nothing in UK law that says they can't let Americans bet. Didn't stop US authorities arresting several bosses of EU gambling websites. If you do a bit more research you'll learn that the US uses extra-territorial jurisdiction more than anyone. http://www.nytimes.com/2006/07/18/technology/18gamble.html http://www.nytimes.com/2006/07/18/technology/18gamble.html
- jakeogh 9y agoSure, that's true. It's a different subject. If one's country allows a foreign system to operate outside of it's own legal system, it's about as strong of a sign as I can think of that the people do not actually control their government. As a US citizen, I am strongly against our interference in other countries, but even if/when we fix that, it wont matter if the root problem is not fixed, since another outside power could do the same thing.
- ascorbic 9y agoI'm sorry but no, it's the exact same subject. It's country A prosecuting a website in country B because they did something that's illegal in country A but legal in country B. The US does the same for copyright laws. Or is it OK if it's team America thats acting as world police?
- jakeogh 9y ago