4 ms·
>The relationship between the fundamental forces (strong, weak, gravity, etc.) and certain other constants in physics that, were they slightly different, would
by Groxx 16y ago
>The relationship between the fundamental forces (strong, weak, gravity, etc.) and certain other constants in physics that, were they slightly different, would rending the whole of existence something entirely different.
As we know it, and are you sure it's possible for them to be different? Given that evidence grows that they're all related, they may simply be a single force, which is why they all seem to be "finely tuned".
I've heard the first-mover argument, and I think it's the best anti-atheist argument. It neatly turns the whole argument into "God just exists" or "the Universe just exists", and as we have no conclusive proof for either, it comes down to your choice / belief.
- eavc 16y agoIf someone could show that there is no way for those forces/laws to have been otherwise, that would mean that every possible universe would be conducive to life, and that would remove the need for infinite universes and for god in explaining how this universe is conducive to life. It still leaves an existential question, of course, but it changes the metaphysics conversation in the same way that the discovery of other suns and worlds did for the initial argument. Well, it's more like, "something eternal exists outside of the universe," or "there are infinite universes," but in general, yeah. Of course, that argument doesn't happen in a vacuum. There are relevant arguments about ethics, evil, personhood, etc. that come to bear on the discussion as well.