3 ms·
Certainly, but "God created it" is the ultimate wild-card explanation. It's identical to saying "because." In what way is that simpler? I can balance this eq
by Groxx 16y ago
Certainly, but "God created it" is the ultimate wild-card explanation. It's identical to saying "because." In what way is that simpler?
I can balance this equation: x = x + 1. The solution is to add God to both sides. Simple!
The quote is primarily meant to point out that we wouldn't likely exist in a location that isn't nigh-ideally suited for us, both because we require it to continue and because we adapt to match it. Using it to prove God exists strikes me as a greater misuse than using it to prove it's possible God doesn't, given any comprehension of large numbers and evolution.
- lotharbot 16y ago"God created it" and "large numbers and evolution" are both ultimate wildcard explanations, when used carelessly. Both can be equivalent to adding infinity to both sides of your equation. > "we wouldn't likely exist in a location that isn't nigh-ideally suited for us" Right, but that only answers a weak variant of the argument. The stronger variant is that the universe shouldn't have any locations suited for the evolution of any form of intelligent life. The fact that we're here indicates that there is a location suited for the evolution of intelligent life, which requires an explanation. There are lots of approaches you can take to provide an explanation. "We wouldn't be asking if we didn't exist" is a weak and unsatisfying approach.
- Groxx 16y ago>Both can be equivalent to adding infinity to both sides of your equation. Admittedly very accurate, but not quite the same. To pull from another oft-repeated quote, time + randomness will never create a pocket watch, because there is not a series of changes which leads to it within dumb evolution. God / intelligence can. What evolution+time describes is very much a strict, significantly-smaller subset of a God's capabilities.
- lotharbot 16y ago> What evolution+time describes is very much a strict, significantly-smaller subset of a God's capabilities. The rational numbers are a significantly-smaller subset of the real numbers. Yet adding a countable infinity to both sides of your equation is just as useless as adding an uncountable infinity. Similarly, "God did it", "there are a lot of universes", "we wouldn't be able to ask if we weren't here so it doesn't need explaining", and "evolution + time" can all be very unsatisfying answers to the stronger variant of the argument I described above. They're all essentially big wildcards, though some are bigger than others. Whichever argument you choose needs a LOT more detail before it becomes better than simply adding infinity to both sides of the equation.
- Dove 16y agoCertainly, but "God created it" is the ultimate wild-card explanation. It's identical to saying "because." Not at all. It could be used that way by lazy and irresponsible thinkers, but that is not an inherent property of the explanation. To return to my earlier analogy, "You know, just because John could have written that letter is no reason to suppose he did. John could have done just about anything to your computer; if you're willing to invoke him as an explanation for whatever you find, you'll never learn anything about how computers work." "Nonsense, I'm not saying John wrote the letter because I don't have any alternative explanation. I'm saying there's positive evidence he wrote it: Look, he signed it. Plus, he's my boyfriend, and this is how he writes, and this is the sort of thing he would do. Why make it complicated?" We constantly deal with intelligent agents who have great power -- roommates who could do arbitrary things to our living areas, other human beings who can create nearly arbitrary literary output on our computers. And we are able to intelligently distinguish between what these beings can do and what they did do based on the available evidence: what they claim to do, their habits and tendencies and methods, what we know about natural laws. Reasoning about what God did is no different. "God did it" is one of a number of competing explanations for any event, subject to evidence and revision just like any other explanation. There is no a priori reason attributing an event to divine intervention need be evidentially vacuous. The correct statement in the absence of evidence is not "God did it" but "I don't know." (Note even my line of reasoning above followed this trail -- a God I already believe in claims to have created the universe, he seems to be capable and credible, and the natural evidence seems to back up the claim: the universe begun, and it looks pretty clearly designed. It even looks like his handiwork. So from my perspective, why make it complicated?)