5 ms·
Early-stage startups with just a couple of founders who are too overworked to give a good answer about data protection are probably too overworked to actually p
by geofft 9y ago
Early-stage startups with just a couple of founders who are too overworked to give a good answer about data protection are probably too overworked to actually protect the data itself, law or no law. We generally don't think it's reasonable for an early-stage startup to be too overworked to get their security right - you still have to write secure code, patch your servers, set up HTTPS, etc. Why is this different?
- gingerlime 9y ago> you still have to write secure code, patch your servers, set up HTTPS, etc. Why is this different? It's very different. Here you're requested to answer fairly detailed and potentially tripping questions with potential legal implications on your business. This has little with how you secure things technically. It's all about jumping through some bureaucratic hoops, and wasting your time doing it. Answering those questions won't in any way, shape or form improve the security of your business. It's pure distraction.
- rdiddly 9y agoIt's not designed to help you. Improving the security is your job. It's designed to reveal, through your answers, whether you're doing it right or not.
- avianlyric 9y agoI think the legal implications people talk about are overwrought. Regulators are more interested in chasing down people who open flaunt the law, rather than repressing startups that can’t cross and dot their legal t and i’s. My personal experience with the ICO has shown their quite lenient to mistakes, if you can show that you’re your honest best, and getting better. No point crushing companies that are trying, better of getting the ones that just don’t care.
- gingerlime 9y agoI certainly hope so. I'm not sure about Germany though. I have a feeling they're much more sticking to the rules (My company is based in Germany, but I'm not German, so it's kind of an outsider's observation). But it's not even just about getting to a point of getting fined or under some kind of investigation or audit. It can be all those clever customers who would use some automated service or a template, just to waste your time ... At least that's what the original post is about, but I hope it won't be too common.
- vsl 9y agoIf the law relies on the regulator being in a good mood and be sensible, it is a badly written law. The law should give the regulator strict mantinels, not be subject to broad leeway in interpretation. Around here, regulators are prone to scoring easy points by going after the small, naive fish. All it takes is the wrong incentives: the department needs to show results, so it gives bonuses, or establishes quotas for successfully handled cases. Bam, your small business is now investigated because a government employee needs to meet a quota and correctly guesses you can’t afford competent legal defense.
- amptorn 9y ago> Answering those questions won't in any way, shape or form improve the security of your business. It's pure distraction. Answering the questions is not intended to improve the security of your business, it's a form of serving your customers.
- amptorn 9y ago> It's very different. Here you're requested to answer fairly detailed and potentially tripping questions with potential legal implications on your business. This has little with how you secure things technically. The difference is that you know offhand how to do one of these things but not the other.
- Silhouette 9y agoEarly-stage startups with just a couple of founders who are too overworked to give a good answer about data protection are probably too overworked to actually protect the data itself, law or no law. People keep making this kind of argument, but it makes no sense. Personal data isn't protected from leaks and privacy intrusions by documents or emails. It's protected by encryption, or only being processed by software with a clear purpose, or simply not being stored in the first place. I suggest that it is not only possible but also quite likely that a reasonably diligent startup will be taking reasonable practical steps to secure personal data but will not have formal documentation or automated processes in place of the kind that would deal with a SAR like this.
- geofft 9y agoI agree that it is likely that a reasonably diligent startup is generally doing the right things just out of general competence. But I disagree that they are reliably doing the right things. We expect programmers to write working code out of general competence (and we even make sure they know how to write working code in the interview process), but we still write tests and insist that they pass. We expect finance folks to handle money correctly out of general competence, but we still have written policies about how money should be handled. The reason we do these is that good, well-intended people occasionally make mistakes, and in both of these cases, the mistakes have real consequences. A written policy about how you handle data isn't going to save you if you're messing up in general. But it should be easy to write, and it will save you from "Wait, why did one of our interns add a library that sends stack traces and local variables to a third party? How did this code review even get approved?" The documents don't protect your users' data. Your general technical practices protect your users' data. The documents protect your general technical practices.
- Silhouette 9y agoThat seems like a reasonable argument, but I can't help observing that when we write code, documentation is generally viewed sceptically because it so easily gets out of sync with the actual behaviour of the system. Automated tests have become a more trusted check on whether code is doing the correct thing, because they aren't vulnerable to that same effect, but there doesn't seem to be any direct equivalent in this context. So I think I would still argue that the security benefits of this law in terms of any documentation and processes it requires are at best unproven, and that a startup could be doing the practically useful things needed to protect personal data regardless of how compliant or otherwise they might be with any documentation requirements.