3 ms·
I'm not getting your broader point here. His point is that ADHD is not purely negative, that it has benefits. You seem to be saying, "But it also has costs!" Su
by wpietri 9y ago
I'm not getting your broader point here. His point is that ADHD is not purely negative, that it has benefits. You seem to be saying, "But it also has costs!" Sure, but nobody said otherwise.
It's true we aren't a hunter-gatherer society. But neither are we a farming society anymore. Circa 1% of the population works in agriculture. Yes, you can look at the Industrial Revolution as applying farming culture to machines; instead of tilling rows, we do piecework. And 1950s-era white-collar organization is basically applying the industrial model to paperwork.
But automation is ending that era. With the rise of the computer, we are getting machines to do all the boring stuff. We are passing out of the farming/industrial era. It's my belief that we're entering an era where the ability to do repetitive, boring work is becoming obsolete. If we technologists do our job well, the only work left is exploratory, creative, social.
So yes, having ADHD in a farmer's world isn't easy. But as the author says, the world's changing away from that.
- falcolas 9y ago> Sure, but nobody said otherwise. What's happening is what I read awhile back - calling ADHD an advantage in society is presenting a weak man argument. Sure, it seems reasonable since they're adding the caveats... but the point that's coming across is that ADHD is not a real disorder since it's an advantage to have, and people who are on meds who have no real reason to be on them. Just see how many people in these threads come to say that it's not a real problem, that behavioral therapy is sufficient, that we're overmedicating children, that everybody is "a little ADHD". Whatever era we may be hypothetically entering; it's not the era we're in now. Being unable to direct your concentration is hinderance, not a help. And I don't think it will help in this hypothetical era, either. Not when finishing works of creativity requires a certain amount of "grit" - concentration on a task that provides no immediately positive feedback.
- wpietri 9y agoI'm not sure what you mean by "real disorder" here. If you read the literature on "medicalization of deviance" it's pretty clear that "real disorder" is a very fuzzy and socially determined bucket. If you personally need medication, great, you should use it. But I don't think that justifies dumping on the people who don't. Or the people who do, but also see benefits in their different cognitive style. My ADHD has been a pain in the ass for me, but I'd never trade it away, as I like the benefits.