5 ms·
Sure, because they can't really compare; they've never been anybody else. ADHD is mainly talked about as the set of negatively-experienced differences. It's eas
by wpietri 9y ago
Sure, because they can't really compare; they've never been anybody else. ADHD is mainly talked about as the set of negatively-experienced differences. It's easy to see the good parts as just their personality.
But the notion that it has benefits is hardly new. In the classic book "Driven to Distraction," the author a psychiatrist who also has ADHD, wrote about discovering ADHD: "I knew I was a slow reader [...] but I never had understood why I came up with different ways of solving problems, why I had an intuitive approach to so much, why I tended to think outside the box, why I could be so impatient so often, why I was so quick to draw conclusions, why I had an oddball sense of humor, and so on."
He writes a longer article on the benefits of ADHD here, and makes clear that the negative traits are also often the positive traits: http://www.hallowellnyc.com/HallowellNYC/LivingwithADD/BenefitsYesBenefitsofHavingADDA/index.cfm http://www.hallowellnyc.com/HallowellNYC/LivingwithADD/Benef...
- falcolas 9y agoSo, being incapable of working in a modern corporation is a... good thing? I would have to disagree. Remember, we're not a hunter-gatherer society anymore; anyone optimized for that kind of society (not that I believe ADHD would have offered any real benefits in such a society either) would not work well in our current society. I'm sure many with split personality disorder are capable of deluding themselves into thinking its a good thing too.
- tzakrajs 9y agoWe are capable of succeeding in modern corporations. I have met plenty of other people with ADHD at Netflix, Google and now Apple. Edit: I was diagnosed with ADHD by neurologist and psychiatrist.
- falcolas 9y agoMe too (diagnosed ADHD, work in tech)! Prior to being medicated, however, I was frequently on the verge of being being disciplined or fired for being incapable of completing some projects. Medication made it possible to turn it into a reliable career with promotion paths. That said, "incapable" was a poor word choice. Not entirely inaccurate, however. I know of many people who end up shifting jobs a lot - smart but lazy is how the upper management sees them.
- tzakrajs 9y agoMy managers might want to fire me at times (and some have tried and failed) but ultimately I think I have enough value that it is worth keeping me around. I am glad to see medication is helpful for you! I have tried it, but I didn't feel like the benefits outweighed the risks (the irony).
- mistercow 9y ago>So, being incapable of working in a modern corporation is a... good thing? I'm not on the "ADHD is a good thing" side of this, but the argument you're implying has some serious problems. First of all, who says that people with ADHD are incapable of working in a modern corporation? Secondly, you're examining only one side of what is asserted to be a tradeoff. There are certainly other ways to be successful in life than working at a corporation, and if ADHD provides an advantage on those other paths, then it could clearly be considered a good thing.
- falcolas 9y ago> who says that people with ADHD are incapable of working in a modern corporation ADHD is a disorder whose primary feature is the inability to control concentration. It's a disorder because the feature is strong enough that a person has trouble interacting with society without help. So, someone who is diagnosed with ADHD has trouble interacting with society without help. There is no modern institution which supports an inability to control concentration as a money provider. Paintings need to be completed. Novels need to be completed. Abstract thoughts need to be written down. Any advantage experienced by those with ADHD is also experienced by those who have trouble directing their concentration, but not to a severe enough degree to require assistance interacting with society. I can bet a lot of folks with ADHD would rather live at that point on the spectrum.
- mistercow 9y agoThere is nothing in the definition of a mental disorder that implies that a person requires assistance to interact with society. You can certainly have ADHD while being capable of coping on your own.
- wgjordan 9y agoThe DSM-IV definition for ADHD requires "clinically significant impairment in social, academic or occupational environments". This was (somewhat controversially) softened to "clear evidence that the symptoms interfere with, or reduce the quality of, social, academic, or occupational functioning" in DSM-V (2013).
- rdiddly 9y agoIs it ADHD, or something else, that results in the widespread inability nowadays to keep two mutually-contradictory-yet-both-true viewpoints in your head at the same time? Or a set of pros and a set of cons? Almost everything in reality is of a mixed nature, so what makes people want to believe a false model of reality where everything is either good or bad, and must be sorted neatly into one or the other category immediately? Is it a need for certainty? For being right? You will find a shortage of both in life.
- wpietri 9y agoWho says they're incapable? I know plenty of people who do it. I have done it. Further, as I mention elsewhere, it's true that we're not a hunter-gatherer society anymore. But neither are we a farming society. As we automate more and more of the boring stuff, I think we are, cognitively, moving in a direction where hunter-gather cognition fits in much better: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16607911 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16607911
- InclinedPlane 9y ago"Incapable of working in a modern corporation." Holy hell man, this is some 1950s era able-ist nonsense. "Oh no, they have 'something wrong with them', it's sad that they'll spend the rest of their lives in a living hell they can't escape, unable to contribute or function in society." I can point you to a zillion people with ADHD who hold high positions in modern corporations, and a zillion more who do excellent work. ADHD is just a different way the brain works, there are many highly effective coping mechanisms to deal with it. And ADHD does have some real benefits as well, such as hyperfocus and creativity. Also, I should note that there are a ton of people who don't even know they have ADHD simply because they don't understand what it looks like, and they naturally developed coping mechanisms that allowed them to be highly productive. ADHD doesn't look like the cartoon pop-culture version its portrayed as. It's not like some uncontrollable child bouncing off the walls and unable to concentrate on anything. For myself, I didn't realize I had ADHD until I was 40. Why would I suspect? I graduated college at 20 (with a degree in Mathematics), I learned about turing machines in high school on my own time, I read textbooks for fun, I love science and math, I can get lost in good books or studying quite easily. But those are, actually, signs of ADHD, which is a horribly mis-named condition, it's not about a deficit of attention it's about interest-based attention. If I'm interested in something then I can immerse myself in it quite easily, dedicate hours to study, churn through dense written material, iterate through "boring" repetitive tasks, etc. But if I'm not interested in something then forcing myself to do it can be like pulling teeth.
- yesbabyyes 9y agoThis made me think about a verse from Auden's poem "Under Which Lyre--A Reactionary Tract for the Times": The sons of Hermes love to play And only do their best when they Are told they oughtn't; Apollo's children never shrink From boring jobs but have to think Their work important. http://members.wizzards.net/~mlworden/atyp/auden.htm http://members.wizzards.net/~mlworden/atyp/auden.htm
- cryoshon 9y agoi don't buy this argument by hallowell for a second, and here's why: jobs don't need creativity in the quantities that adhd people muster by default. they need, let's say, 5 units of creativity, not 50000 -- that many leads to being outside of the room when the job only requires you to be near the edge of a box in the room. thinking "outside the box" is a hindrance. most people can't get on your level, and you can't bring yourself to where your thoughts really make sense to them. the point is that with adhd, it isn't a choice to make. they can't control whether to be inside the box, outside the box, or even in the same building as the (conceptual) box. if it were a choice to make, it'd just be an advantage.
- wpietri 9y agoThis strikes me as an over-broad picture of both jobs and ADHD. In practice there's great variation in both the amount of creativity that jobs need and in the ability of people with ADHD to present as normal when needed. I'd be especially curious as to the data behind your sweeping statement that "they can't control whether to be inside the box, outside the box, or even in the same building as the (conceptual) box". That's not my experience, now how the people with ADHD I know behave, and it's not what the ADHD literature I'm familiar with says. I'm sure it's true about somebody, but I strongly doubt it's close to everybody.
- cryoshon 9y agoeasy: attentional control and mindset control are executive functions. ADHD is an extreme deficit of executive functions. http://psycnet.apa.org/record/2004-19094-002 http://psycnet.apa.org/record/2004-19094-002