5 ms·
Some accessibility/disability advocates are big on touting "the hidden benefits of x condition". I've seen a lot of this in the dyslexia community (see The Dysl
by gnicholas 9y ago
Some accessibility/disability advocates are big on touting "the hidden benefits of x condition". I've seen a lot of this in the dyslexia community (see The Dyslexic Advantage [1] for a full-throated example), and I understand why books/articles like this are popular. They especially appeal to parents, even if the underlying logic isn't the most sound—and often it isn't.
This is the first time I've seen the "hidden benefits" notion asserted in the ADHD context. Based on my conversations with people with ADHD (I work for an assistive tech startup [2], so run into lots of them), there is not much of a perception that ADHD provides them a net benefit.
1: https://www.amazon.com/Dyslexic-Advantage-Unlocking-Hidden-Potential/dp/0452297923 https://www.amazon.com/Dyslexic-Advantage-Unlocking-Hidden-P...
2: http://www.beelinereader.com http://www.beelinereader.com
- wpietri 9y agoSure, because they can't really compare; they've never been anybody else. ADHD is mainly talked about as the set of negatively-experienced differences. It's easy to see the good parts as just their personality. But the notion that it has benefits is hardly new. In the classic book "Driven to Distraction," the author a psychiatrist who also has ADHD, wrote about discovering ADHD: "I knew I was a slow reader [...] but I never had understood why I came up with different ways of solving problems, why I had an intuitive approach to so much, why I tended to think outside the box, why I could be so impatient so often, why I was so quick to draw conclusions, why I had an oddball sense of humor, and so on." He writes a longer article on the benefits of ADHD here, and makes clear that the negative traits are also often the positive traits: http://www.hallowellnyc.com/HallowellNYC/LivingwithADD/BenefitsYesBenefitsofHavingADDA/index.cfm http://www.hallowellnyc.com/HallowellNYC/LivingwithADD/Benef...
- falcolas 9y agoSo, being incapable of working in a modern corporation is a... good thing? I would have to disagree. Remember, we're not a hunter-gatherer society anymore; anyone optimized for that kind of society (not that I believe ADHD would have offered any real benefits in such a society either) would not work well in our current society. I'm sure many with split personality disorder are capable of deluding themselves into thinking its a good thing too.
- tzakrajs 9y agoWe are capable of succeeding in modern corporations. I have met plenty of other people with ADHD at Netflix, Google and now Apple. Edit: I was diagnosed with ADHD by neurologist and psychiatrist.
- falcolas 9y agoMe too (diagnosed ADHD, work in tech)! Prior to being medicated, however, I was frequently on the verge of being being disciplined or fired for being incapable of completing some projects. Medication made it possible to turn it into a reliable career with promotion paths. That said, "incapable" was a poor word choice. Not entirely inaccurate, however. I know of many people who end up shifting jobs a lot - smart but lazy is how the upper management sees them.
- tzakrajs 9y agoMy managers might want to fire me at times (and some have tried and failed) but ultimately I think I have enough value that it is worth keeping me around. I am glad to see medication is helpful for you! I have tried it, but I didn't feel like the benefits outweighed the risks (the irony).
- mistercow 9y ago>So, being incapable of working in a modern corporation is a... good thing? I'm not on the "ADHD is a good thing" side of this, but the argument you're implying has some serious problems. First of all, who says that people with ADHD are incapable of working in a modern corporation? Secondly, you're examining only one side of what is asserted to be a tradeoff. There are certainly other ways to be successful in life than working at a corporation, and if ADHD provides an advantage on those other paths, then it could clearly be considered a good thing.
- falcolas 9y ago> who says that people with ADHD are incapable of working in a modern corporation ADHD is a disorder whose primary feature is the inability to control concentration. It's a disorder because the feature is strong enough that a person has trouble interacting with society without help. So, someone who is diagnosed with ADHD has trouble interacting with society without help. There is no modern institution which supports an inability to control concentration as a money provider. Paintings need to be completed. Novels need to be completed. Abstract thoughts need to be written down. Any advantage experienced by those with ADHD is also experienced by those who have trouble directing their concentration, but not to a severe enough degree to require assistance interacting with society. I can bet a lot of folks with ADHD would rather live at that point on the spectrum.
- cryoshon 9y agoi don't buy this argument by hallowell for a second, and here's why: jobs don't need creativity in the quantities that adhd people muster by default. they need, let's say, 5 units of creativity, not 50000 -- that many leads to being outside of the room when the job only requires you to be near the edge of a box in the room. thinking "outside the box" is a hindrance. most people can't get on your level, and you can't bring yourself to where your thoughts really make sense to them. the point is that with adhd, it isn't a choice to make. they can't control whether to be inside the box, outside the box, or even in the same building as the (conceptual) box. if it were a choice to make, it'd just be an advantage.
- wpietri 9y agoThis strikes me as an over-broad picture of both jobs and ADHD. In practice there's great variation in both the amount of creativity that jobs need and in the ability of people with ADHD to present as normal when needed. I'd be especially curious as to the data behind your sweeping statement that "they can't control whether to be inside the box, outside the box, or even in the same building as the (conceptual) box". That's not my experience, now how the people with ADHD I know behave, and it's not what the ADHD literature I'm familiar with says. I'm sure it's true about somebody, but I strongly doubt it's close to everybody.
- cryoshon 9y agoeasy: attentional control and mindset control are executive functions. ADHD is an extreme deficit of executive functions. http://psycnet.apa.org/record/2004-19094-002 http://psycnet.apa.org/record/2004-19094-002
- Erlangolem 9y agoAs someone with ADHD, very much what you’re saying. The original name for ADHD was “minimal brain damage” and that’s what it’s always felt like to me. Mathematical concepts are something I manage well, but I’m laughably bad at mental arithmetic. I’ve more or less overcome my struggles with focus and attention, but I simply cannot do paired-word association, or directions. If I want to learn a new language, I need to be immersed in it, which is fun, but expensive and time consuming. Until GPS units, I couldn’t find my way out of a wet paper bag. These things do not benefit me, or empower me. I feel a part of what I could have been is just out of reach, and that’s ADHD in a nutshell for me. If I’m being perfectly honest only two real positives exist as a result of ADHD for me: First, I’ve always been able to utterly lose myself in a book, fiction or non-fiction. I’d be lying if I said that was always a good thing, but it can be useful. I tore my way through Gray’ Anatomy in a few days, while people I know took a month to do the same. Second, I was lucky in having patient, yet firm parents who helped me learn what was socially acceptable at a young age. I don’t compulsively interrupt people, I can sit through a whole opera without blinking, and I have a strong verbal filter. The downside was that all of this was very hard-won, and at times painful for everyone involved. All in all, I’d drop ADHD in a heartbeat if I could.
- ajaimk 9y agoThe article does clarify that this is with regards to moderate ADHD. In my personal opinion, most psychology disorders were named to differentiate from "normal". Who defines normal?
- falcolas 9y agoSociety, ultimately. Psychologists and psychiatrists just look at the population and identify the cliffs between "able to operate in society" and "not able to operate in society without assistance". Those diagnosed with ADHD are those who are in the "not able to operate without help" category.
- bmpafa 9y agoI underwent cognitive testing for ADHD,and it was more rigorous a process than I expected. They administered a battery of tests, among them a few controls to screen for malingerers. Each was narrow enough of a task to believably evaluate a specific aspect of cognitive ability. The results were evaluated against the broader population of people with similar levels of intelligence So, for example, in one test, the task is to sum a continuing stream of spoken digits. Apparently, the test includes a distribution of other' performance,and that distribution defines 'normal.' performing worse than the mean (or whatever measure) is therefore abnormal and, potentially, indicative of some disorder or another. Tl;Dr they use ostensibly reliable statistical methods to define 'normal'
- elcritch 9y agoAdditionally the difference needs to be a std deviation or two away from the normal population. ADHD in particular has effects on specific sub-tests in IQ exams. It’s quite a clear pattern which emerges as the ares of IQ dealing with multiple conflicting inputs tend to be standard deviation below the rest of the sub-tests norms for a person. Unfortunately I don’t know the appropriate literature to cite. Another test which is used is response times to an onscreen test.
- mistercow 9y agoI've heard this "ADHD could be an advantage" trope for decades. On net, I don't think it's usually the case for people with diagnosed ADHD, although I wouldn't be surprised if there's a lot of variance, especially in what I suspect is a pretty large undiagnosed population. I was on ADHD medication for many years, and on balance, I'd probably still choose to use it if it didn't make my anxiety so unmanageable. These days I manage it with nicotine, which is an imperfect but working solution. I find that hyperfocus has become predictable enough for me that I can benefit from it while reliably avoiding the behaviors that cause it (edit: confusing phrasing; I mean can avoid it when I don't want it). In that sense, ADHD may be a benefit to me, but I don't know if it's worth the drawbacks. But if I could open up my source code and do some tweaking, I'd fix the anxiety long before I worried about the ADHD.
- silencio 9y agoYou should ask your psych to look into something like Intuniv if you haven't already tried it. It seems to be a very promising medication - even if it's off label use for adult adhd - where you can even use it as an adjuvant to a low dose stimulant. I know a fair number of folks that have success tackling adhd and comorbid anxiety with certain nonstimulants.
- sj4nz 9y agoIs there an explanation of what a "beelinereader" is? Their website is heavy on the selling and lacking on the details and I'm not installing something blindly.
- walterbell 9y agoIt rotates font color among successive sentences.
- gnicholas 9y agoThe website describes it and demonstrates it in the text itself. It is the use of color gradients in text that wrap from the end of one line to the beginning of the next. This technique is popular as a speed reading tool and as an accommodation for people with ADHD and dyslexia.
- sj4nz 9y agoThe website doesn't demonstrate it on the "front" page. But the effect is so subtle I didn't even notice it on the "individual"'s page, probably due to a color display limitation of a laptop screen. I would have put a "side-by-side" comparison of the same text on pages like this to make it more prominent--one with the beeline effect and one without.
- philwelch 9y agoADD has certain strengths and weaknesses. The weaknesses can be counteracted with a well-titrated dose of CNS stimulants without fully cancelling out the strengths. The strengths include (paradoxically) the ability to hyperfocus to a greater degree than non-ADDers and the ability to achieve peak performance in short-term crisis situations instead of freaking out.