4 ms·
You might want to read some introductory anthropology textbooks. For as long as there have been humans it has been us against them. Them/the others/the stranger
by irrational 9y ago
You might want to read some introductory anthropology textbooks. For as long as there have been humans it has been us against them. Them/the others/the strangers/the not us are dangerous and cannot be trusted. There are specific rituals that an other must go through to become a part of the community - the means by which one of the others can become one of us. What separates us from them? It might be skin color, it might be language, it might be religion, it might be you live in the mountains and we live in the valley, you are a herder and we are farmers, you are rural and we are urban, you have curly hair and we have straight hair, etc. ad naseum.
- roywiggins 9y agoYou're not wrong, but it's worth saying that contemporary racism is qualitatively quite different from, say, Greek ideas about their own superiority or tribal conflicts generally. It's very nearly a caste system- you can be born next door, speak the same language, eat the same food, think the same way, and you will be treated differently based on racial judgements. That's quite different from "we Hill People hate the River Folk and always will!" The modern notions of race come from a specific historical moment: the invention of the African slave trade by Western European powers. If the slave trade had not happened, ideas about race would probably be radically different. Chattel slavery on an industrial scale was a new idea and its echoes will probably always be with us.
- Mediterraneo10 9y ago"It's very nearly a caste system- you can be born next door, speak the same language, eat the same food, think the same way, and you will be treated differently based on racial judgements." Caste systems are nearly as much an anthropological universal (at least for civilizations) as the suspicion of outsiders that the OP mentions. Across the world you can find examples of two neighbours brought up in virtually identical conditions, but with restrictions on one due to ancestry.
- roywiggins 9y agoOne difference from a caste system- foreigners are assigned the same racial categories as locals, whereas if I visited a society with a caste system, I simply wouldn't have a caste, at least not by default. Black Africans in America are considered the same race as black Americans, regardless of sharing absolutely no recent ancestry whatsoever, and white Africans are the same race as white Americans, again without sharing any meaningful recent ancestry. A white Hispanic person will be treated as white (see: Ted Cruz) but a black one will be treated as black, even if they're literally siblings. Racial categories mean that a white American can feel more common ground with a white Russian than his black American neighbor. American white nationalist fellow-feeling toward Russian nationalists suggests to me that it's not really about suspicion of outsiders. Racial categories cut across borders, ancestry, language, and culture. Feeling confident that one can judge what category someone is in on sight without seeing their clothes, hearing them speak, learning their name, or knowing their ancestry is maybe not quite unique to modern racial ideas, but it certainly makes it stand out.
- golemiprague 9y agoWhat do you mean by "speak the same language, eat the same food, think the same way"? It is pretty evident that this is not the case, there are a lot of variations between different groups of people and in many time it is divided by racial lines. Cast systems on the other hand is exactly the opposite, it is a system that divide people on family lineage even though all else is similiar.
- WillReplyfFood 9y agoI wonder - why the suprise? We strip humanity of the old caste system- which was beeing defined by there jobs- and they go and search for new definitions, and we - the shivas, the destroyers of worlds, stand in the ruins and wrench our hands? The priest beeing shocked on the existance of untoucheables.. We crafted this moment, this is what we worked for all along. If you can not accomplish anything in life as a commoner, you will draw meaning from what as who you where born and who your ancestors where.. You can not shake a world in its foundations and expect for good things to magically appear. Also, the africa situation debunked a lot of left myths. All that aid, all those campaigns and ralleys, and in the end, some cultures rise and shine (china, korea, japan) from the ashes, while others just stagnate and decay, often with a painfully strong contrast existing nearby (israel). If one does not discuss culture, and does not offer a powerfull alternative explenation, just leaving a discourse hole- people will find a answer for themselves. The islamic worlds decay and the african mess, spilling out in all directions- sometimes the world produces the racism by just show and tell. And yes, i know the usual explenations- africa is exploited, the islamic world has one huge conspiracy against it- but honestly they are as hollow as a bell. South korea had a conspiracy against it, china was exploited. Yet there they are. India is independent as long as china. At the same time, the western culture has proofen itself to be unsubstainable, with a giant economic footprint demographically dwindling away, another fact conveniently never discussed to avoid unsettling the holy cows of the sun god. It would be a miracle if with all those holes in the narrative, the old working defaults wouldnt rear there ugly heads.
- asveikau 9y agoThe people replying this to me don't get what I was saying. It's not worth it to apply a 21st century us or them when the particular us-es and thems in reference have not yet evolved. I would further say that if you look that far back and rather than add perspective you can only see current tensions frozen in time you are petty.
- forapurpose 9y ago> For as long as there have been humans it has been us against them. Them/the others/the strangers/the not us are dangerous and cannot be trusted. It's important to add that the definition of 'other' changes. In the U.S., Protestants and Catholics, Italians and Irish used to riot against each other. 'No Irish Need Apply' was appended to job postings. Jews faced significant discrimination. Sometime around the 1930s, it shifted so that all Protestants became 'white'. Since then, all white-skinned people, including Jews, Mormons, Catholics, became 'white', generally one ethnic group. Nobody seemed to care that Mitt Romney was Mormon; none seem to care or even notice that the US Supreme Court has no Protestants (unless Gorsuch is one).
- maxerickson 9y agoThe protestant Anglo-Saxons were the original "white" group. Irish Catholics and such were additions. (I'm responding to it shifted so that all Protestants became 'white'. which could just be an accidental misphrasing)
- asveikau 9y agoNot only that but we are talking about a timeframe in which any of our present divisions are totally not fathomable let alone in existence. I take exception even with your examples. How long has there been an "Italy"? In one sense, since the current state emerged in 1861. In another, Italia would only have meant land south of the Rubicon, excluding northern Italy. In another still, it's probably some Etruscan word with some completely different meaning. (Just a guess, I have not looked it up.) So when you go all the way back to when Europeans adapted for lighter skin and before... There is no "Italy". Maybe even there isn't any "Europe". I think the people answering my comment with "but it's always been us vs them" are really grasping for some cynicism to make themselves feel superior, because I would ask, who exactly is the us or the them they are talking about? Because no current group existed. It is constantly changing. That is the whole point.
- vixen99 9y agoIf someone's wrong, saying so and why, is preferable to patronizing them.