4 ms·
Rethinking Approaches to Diversity And Inclusion
- Erik816 9y agoOr maybe actually rethink it, and question whether diversity is a universal good or one value among many that comes with trade offs.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mlloyd 9y agoProbably wouldn't say this if you were underrepresented.
- DoofusOfDeath 9y agoYeah, people seem to be more sympathetic to plights they've experienced themselves. Regardless of whether or not such a plight is the biggest problem the overall society needs to solve.
- mcphage 9y ago> Regardless of whether or not such a plight is the biggest problem the overall society needs to solve. What if societies could work on solving multiple problems at once?
- ipsocannibal 9y agoSure, but how do you prioritize which ones to solve? The capacity for a society to solve problems is not infinite. Furthermore, how do you define what a "problem" is for a society? It seems "because it happened to me" is a relatively weak definition.
- mcphage 9y ago> Sure, but how do you prioritize which ones to solve? The capacity for a society to solve problems is not infinite. Thankfully, neither are the problems that society is faced with. > Furthermore, how do you define what a "problem" is for a society? It seems "because it happened to me" is a relatively weak definition. It turns out, you don't actually need to! Some problems are faced by a subset of a society, and often that subset are most interested in solving them.
- ipsocannibal 9y ago> Thankfully, neither are the problems that society is faced with. True, yet I think we can agree that some problems are more easily solvable than others. Likewise, solving some problems will have greater positive impact on society as a whole than others. Therefore, it's probably a good idea to have some type of estimation strategy for determining the above stated properties of societal problems. > It turns out, you don't actually need to! Some problems are faced by a subset of a society, and often that subset are most interested in solving them. Then what you are describing is not a societial problem. I can define any individual as a subset of a society. That does not make that individual's problems societal. Expand your subset to include 0.05% of the population, their problems still are not societal. I would say there is some critical mass of people that must experience a problem before it becomes a societal problem. What that proportion is I do not know. Furthermore, there are ways to solve problems for one subset of people by damaging another subset of people. Example, slavery. In these cases I don't think you have actually solved a societal problem. You've caused one. I would claim this is the case for the "diversity" issue. A small set of "experts" have determined based on little to no evidence that for a certain set of job roles the proportions of people in said roles must reflect some vagued idealized ratios based upon superficial biological characteristics. In order to address the "problem" that the current propotionality of members in these job roles do not reflect their ideal a public smear campaign is unleashed in order to threaten non-compliant organizations into instituting exclusionary hiring policies and moralistic internal propaganda campaigns.
- mcphage 9y ago
- tdb7893 9y agoFrom a practical standpoint it's good for teams to be diverse and inclusive (it raises effectiveness, increases the talent pool, etc...) but also from a more philosophical point of view diversity and inclusion are necessary for an actual meritocracy as it's hard to say you have a true meritocracy when some people are hampered unnecessarily by cultural differences. The problem is that some people take "diversity initiatives" too far and it ends up being counterproductive (like agile and TDD and all that).
- DoofusOfDeath 9y agoSeems to me that requiring, rather than simply allowing, a team to be diverse actually restricts the talent pool. That is, it reduces the number of viable teams one can form from a population. And if you have an existing team you need to grow, it can rule out some candidates.
- pooya13 9y agoTrue. But if we want to break a feedback loop and exit a local minimum in hopes of reaching a global minimum it might be needed to force diversity out of the local minimum for a period before letting it to naturally settle.
- Hnrobert42 9y agoI understand your position I agree with it in theory. In practice, that’s not how things work. If it was, we wouldn’t be having this conversation. In practice, simply “allowing” for diversity doesn’t work. The only way to reach diversity goals is to actively include people. So long as those people are qualified, I am okay if the cost is missing out on a slightly more qualified candidate. Not least of which because horing isn’t an exact science in which qualifications are completely measurable and all possible candidates are always considered. Again, reality is messy. So a few white dudes (such as myself) might not get a job because of a quota. Big deal. If I am such hot shit that I definitely should have gotten the job, then I won’t have a problem getting a job elsewhere.
- 9y ago
- norikki 9y agoMaybe you should rethink hiring people on their skin color instead of their merits.
- ashleyn 9y ago"Diversity" is a problem that can only be solved supply-side. If you want particular demographics in your field, the solution begins in early childhood, it begins in the home and the school. This preserves the still-essential meritocratic aspect of hiring while making an effort to diversify your culture.
- Kequc 9y agoHire the most skilled people available to fill any role. These are companies, businesses, they have a duty to investors and stock holders. If you're worried about giving jobs to anyone other than the most skilled applicants, please redirect your attention to the schools and educational institutions.
- jacknews 9y agoI find the link "Pssst…the real reason why we should #MentorHer" to be rather angry and prescriptive. There appears to me to be an increase in the number of propagandic articles dictating how men should have.
- jacknews 9y agoThe article details steps to be taken, obviously in pursuit of a diversity goal state, but the goal is never stated. What is the actual objective? To me, it should be a simple case of eradicating, or compensating for, bias. No more, no less.
- TheAdamAndChe 9y agoWhat do you mean by bias? This claim assumes that bias against certain cultures is necessary for growth, but why is bias always bad? For example, if I hire an experienced senior dev over a junior, that's biased against the younger worker because of their lack of experience. Yet I end up with a more productive workforce. How is that bad? How do we determine which kind of biases are bad and which are good?
- killjoywashere 9y agoYou want a lighter, more resilient bridge, you put the concrete under tension. You want a lighter, more resilient bicycle wheel, you put the spokes under tension. You want a lighter, more resilient company, adding a little tension to the teams because you know the company will have to weather diversity-related issues.
- TheAdamAndChe 9y agoIntentionally causing conflict and lowering the quality of life of your workers just so some diversity quota can be met seems kind of sociopathic to me. I really don't see how intentional conflict would benefit a company.
- killjoywashere 9y agoI'm pretty sure the US's better nature is to be a melting pot of the world. I'm sure if you've gotten this far, you can get along with other people and realize it is beneficial to all when you do.
- ipsocannibal 9y agoI fear the current "Diversity" zeitgeist has become a shakedown scam by so called experts to line their pockets based on the threat of bad PR. In my experience these "experts" and "founders" advice on attaining "diversity" boils down to excluding technically competent but "over-representitive" groups in favor of other "under-represented" groups within the hiring process. The members of these "over-represented" groups, i.e. Caucasian and North Asian males of American origin, become the hires of last resort. In effect a quota system is established in order demonstrate the desired proportions of "under-represented" groups within a role are being achieved thus preventing negative PR. Parallel with exclusionary hiring policies a propaganda campaign within a organization must be waged in order to brow beat members of the "over-represented" groups into accepting that such exclusionary policies are necessary and just in order to achieve some nebulous moralistic goal as defined by the "diversity" "experts" and "founders". From said propaganda the members of the "over-represented" groups must learn to accept and fulfill the role "ally" toward all members of the designated "under-represented" groups. This role can be simplified into "supporter of exclusionary policies of which I'm the target". Mind you the "experts" and "founders" advocate for "diversity" and "inclusion" only within job roles that are typically male dominated and techincally oriented. The exclusionary hiring policies and propaganda campaigns never include increasing "diversity" within female dominated roles, e.g. HR, Recruiting, etc., or non-techincal roles, e.g. Custodial, Facilities, Security, Transportation, etc. This is so because the threat of bad PR doesn't hold much weight when certain target groups are not members of the "over-represented" group within the role. Ultimately, I fear the current methods of addressing the "diversity" issue are counterproductive, hypocritical, and morally prescriptive in the same ways that other zeitgeist initiated crusades have been in recent history, e.g. "War on Drugs".
- tomohawk 9y agoThinking there is more diversity between defined groups than within such groups - that is the definition of racism. And why do we listen to these people who define the groups a certain way anyway? This is no way for us to pull together and work together. We shouldn't be suckers for the divide and conquer approach.