17 ms·
In Praise of ADHD
- _RPM 9y agomy therapist tells me ADHD is a real thing. But, it's hard for me not see through the lines that a psychiatrist is only prescribing medicine because they can bill the insurance a ton of money and make bank.
- ganoushoreilly 9y agoIt's definitely a real thing. You don't have to take medications, but they can certainly help some.
- roflc0ptic 9y agoIt's real in that there are a set of behaviors which correlate reliably with each other that are described as ADHD. It's not "real" in the sense that there's a single mechanism underlying ADHD. It's not real in the sense that "people with ADHD are affected differently by amphetamines, so it's okay for them to take them." The way I think about it is that attention is a bell curve, and that at some point on the left of that curve, symptoms interfere with happy, economically productive lives. Psychiatrists try to help those people with stimulant drugs, whose efficacy have been proven in the short term, but are basically unproven in the long term. There are companies making bank on this arrangement. In summary, I guess it's complicated. You're right, but maybe your therapist is, too. Por que no los dos?
- falcolas 9y agoDifferently, perhaps not. But the benefits for relatively small doses (5-15mg) are tremendous for those with ADHD. ADHD is, ultimately, as real as climate change. The experts say it's real; have been saying it's real for many years. The people who disagree don't trust those experts.
- roflc0ptic 9y agoOh, to be sure I’m not saying people shouldn’t take amphetamines. They improve my life substantially. There’s just an artificial line drawn between “ok to take performance enhancing drug” and “not okay to take performance enhancing drug.”
- smittywerben 9y agoNon-stimulants work too! The performance enhancers sometimes work a little better though. These drugs aren't perfect. Just don't fight genetics, they're much older than you :-)
- jjeaff 9y agoTell that to someone with adhd who went from unproductive and basically a poor student to highly productive and studious after receiving medical treatment for adhd. As for the psychiatrist, they don't make any extra money from prescribing. They could make more money if they kept you coming in each month or week for behavioural therapy (which doesn't have great results for adhd anyway, but it's something).
- jeffmould 9y agoI had almost this exact conversation a couple weeks ago with a friend of mine who is a highly recognized psychologist. We got talking about medicating for ADHD and anxiety (I have a friend who is struggling with her son in this department). Basically, you are right, psychiatrists could make more money doing therapy, but therapy is more for psychologists and not psychiatrists. Most psychiatrists make money off of volume of patients. So it is in their best interest to prescribe more and consult less. The more patients that come through their office and they prescribe meds to the more money they make. He used the example of the psychiatry department at the public hospital next door to his office. On average, one doctor in that office can see upwards of 30 patients a day. With my friend, he can see at most 6 patients a day. For my friend though, as a psychologist doing one-on-one therapy he can charge more and see less patients. In regards to medicating versus therapy, like many other things, people react differently to different things. Some individuals may do better with therapy over meds and vice-versa. The downside of meds is that typically becomes a lifetime treatment. Therapy on the other hand, when it works, is easier to reduce over time (although most people will continue, even at a significantly reduced interval).
- falcolas 9y agoMost people I know with moderate to severe ADHD require meds to even concentrate enough to enact any behaviour modification. That said, medication alone will not resolve all issues that crop up as part of having ADHD - many will need both.
- John_KZ 9y agoI had to reach the bottom of the page to find the only 2 commentors that understand that ADHD is an umbrella diagnosis and medication is often a crime. And of course both are downvoted to hell and about to be flagged and deleted. Who the fuck would medicate a 5 or 10 year old child for being "too active"? This is like the 50s shock therapy for unruly teenagers, but done with chemistry instead. Less blood and morbidity, more mental castration. Many people who take up Ritalin and Adderal, especially from a young age, have issues with mental development and end up addicts for life. If/when they finally take off their meds, they find themselves 10x worse because of the long-term withdrawal. This thread is filled with reddit-tier pseudoscience about ADHD being some kind of evolutionary trait relating to hunter gatherer communities. What a load of bullshit, I don't know if I should be laughing or not. It's worrisome that even serious people and many psychologists believe that shit.
- smittywerben 9y ago> end up addicts for life This is an archaic idea, you sound like an older individual. Am I right on that? > reddit-tier pseudoscience... downvoted to hell We can test for ADHD just like we do breast cancer. > medication is often a crime... ADHD [is an] evolutionary trait... What a load of bullshit Impulsivity is a sin, right? I'm not some puppet for your chuch, pal.
- gnicholas 9y agoSome accessibility/disability advocates are big on touting "the hidden benefits of x condition". I've seen a lot of this in the dyslexia community (see The Dyslexic Advantage [1] for a full-throated example), and I understand why books/articles like this are popular. They especially appeal to parents, even if the underlying logic isn't the most sound—and often it isn't. This is the first time I've seen the "hidden benefits" notion asserted in the ADHD context. Based on my conversations with people with ADHD (I work for an assistive tech startup [2], so run into lots of them), there is not much of a perception that ADHD provides them a net benefit. 1: https://www.amazon.com/Dyslexic-Advantage-Unlocking-Hidden-Potential/dp/0452297923 https://www.amazon.com/Dyslexic-Advantage-Unlocking-Hidden-P... 2: http://www.beelinereader.com http://www.beelinereader.com
- wpietri 9y agoSure, because they can't really compare; they've never been anybody else. ADHD is mainly talked about as the set of negatively-experienced differences. It's easy to see the good parts as just their personality. But the notion that it has benefits is hardly new. In the classic book "Driven to Distraction," the author a psychiatrist who also has ADHD, wrote about discovering ADHD: "I knew I was a slow reader [...] but I never had understood why I came up with different ways of solving problems, why I had an intuitive approach to so much, why I tended to think outside the box, why I could be so impatient so often, why I was so quick to draw conclusions, why I had an oddball sense of humor, and so on." He writes a longer article on the benefits of ADHD here, and makes clear that the negative traits are also often the positive traits: http://www.hallowellnyc.com/HallowellNYC/LivingwithADD/BenefitsYesBenefitsofHavingADDA/index.cfm http://www.hallowellnyc.com/HallowellNYC/LivingwithADD/Benef...
- falcolas 9y agoSo, being incapable of working in a modern corporation is a... good thing? I would have to disagree. Remember, we're not a hunter-gatherer society anymore; anyone optimized for that kind of society (not that I believe ADHD would have offered any real benefits in such a society either) would not work well in our current society. I'm sure many with split personality disorder are capable of deluding themselves into thinking its a good thing too.
- julianpye 9y agoPeople with ADHD think less in silos and can form quicker parallels between different verticals. That's the formula for much of creativity, problem-solving and stand-up comedy. The main challenge in daily life is a hard time with taking decisions and prioritizing. I have been working for three years on a ADHD friendly Taskmanager as an obsessive side-project to solve exactly that daily life problem. In 6 weeks I will open it up for internal trial testing - volunteers welcome - just send me an email if you wanna join the trial (first version is Android only).
- falcolas 9y agoHow is your task manager different from the thousands of others, including the bullet journal (which tends to work well for those with ADHD)? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5hLnY9L1c-M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5hLnY9L1c-M
- julianpye 9y agoBasically we have created a system that is very visual and which breaks tasks, projects and aspirations into workable, visual structure. Key is the UX.
- sinnoh 9y agoI'll volunteer (will email later). I don't have an android phone but will happily pick one up if this ends up being something I can/should use (been meaning to switch anyways).
- ynonym00s 9y agoHello, I'm interested in your taskmanager app. Is your email [redacted]?
- dang 9y agoProbably best not to leave someone else's email address here, so we redacted that bit.
- falcolas 9y agoOK, let's assume I buy this argument, that being creative is much more important than being able to concentrate. Let's say, for a moment, that someone with ADHD would make an excellent hunter-gatherer. Point one: This is not a hunter gatherer society. A highly successful hunter gatherer will do very poorly in today's office-bound society. If you want someone who can only be a hunter gatherer to be successful in today's society, you can't just tell them to "calm down" or "concentrate harder", you have to make accommodations. Point two: All the creativity in the world won't help when you get bored of a painting, a story, a novel halfway through and can't finish it. Note - I didn't say "don't want to finish it", I said "can't finish it". Just like someone with clinical depression can't just snap out of it and be happy, someone with moderate to severe ADHD can't force themselves to concentrate. Point three: ADHD does not just affect concentration. Another big impact that ADHD has is on the ability to connect an action and its consequences if those two are separated by more than a few minutes. Funny image -> immediate dopamine response -> fantastic feedback loop. Doing your homework -> discomfort and frustration -> very negative feedback loop. Now imagine trying to live in a world where doing work and getting paid have no correlation in your brain. You have to intellectualize that doing work leads to getting paid, except you can't concentrate on it long enough to care.
- wpietri 9y agoI'm not getting your broader point here. His point is that ADHD is not purely negative, that it has benefits. You seem to be saying, "But it also has costs!" Sure, but nobody said otherwise. It's true we aren't a hunter-gatherer society. But neither are we a farming society anymore. Circa 1% of the population works in agriculture. Yes, you can look at the Industrial Revolution as applying farming culture to machines; instead of tilling rows, we do piecework. And 1950s-era white-collar organization is basically applying the industrial model to paperwork. But automation is ending that era. With the rise of the computer, we are getting machines to do all the boring stuff. We are passing out of the farming/industrial era. It's my belief that we're entering an era where the ability to do repetitive, boring work is becoming obsolete. If we technologists do our job well, the only work left is exploratory, creative, social. So yes, having ADHD in a farmer's world isn't easy. But as the author says, the world's changing away from that.
- allthenews 9y agoSo, are we witnessing a modern form of selection pressure? Are genes related to ADHD favorable for not only coping with, but taking advantage of increasing availability of information in our modern age?
- falcolas 9y agoI would have to say whole heartedly "fuck no". Sorry for the language, but I needed a touch more emphasis. Rabbit holing (which is how ADHD brains tend to act with a lot of available stimulation/information) is pretty much the exact opposite of coping and being productive.
- tzakrajs 9y agoAt the same time, people purposely dwell on stinker ideas and strategies where an ADHD person might be pushed by their condition out of that box. I agree that rabbit holing is pretty frustrating otherwise because it is unplanned.
- mmmrtl 9y agoIt's possible that the traits that in some combination lead to ADHD are adaptive on their own, or in some people, or in lower doses (like having 1 copy of a gene instead of 2). If that's the case, your non-ADHD relatives might be more fit, and the burden of some family members having ADHD isn't enough to outweigh the benefits to the rest of the family. Kind of like having one copy of the sickle cell anemia gene gives you resistance to malaria, but two makes you likely to die from sickle-cell disease.
- rdlecler1 9y agoOnly if it leads to differential reproductive success. One could argue that people with ADHD may in fact have more sexual partners and provide a positive selective advantage.
- ajaimk 9y agoMy ADHD isn't a disorder. It's my super power. I would gladly admit this to anyone; I mean it's not like they don't notice it within a few minutes. I have been on meds for the past 2 years and started at 26. I don't think this is "fixing" as I'm on probably the lowest dosage. Since day 1 I felt the same way I did after coffee. Vyvanse to me is extended release caffeine which kicks in as my morning coffee wears off and carries me through the day.
- tzakrajs 9y agoADHD and testosterone have helped shape me into a successful and peculiar person because of the sheer amount of risk I have been willing to accept (versus my peers). I moved away from home at 17, have lived all around the country and I made out it out of my small Ohio suburb where most people stay until death. I feel like ADHD necessitates intuitive responses to problems and highly deprioritizes rote memorization and recall. I have a distinct feeling that my ADHD brain doesn't have the ability to remember details with the same fidelity as my peers. I am constantly forgetting all but the most critical details, but I have a ability to intuit solutions from the details I have forgotten.
- gnicholas 9y agoCurious to know the ways in which your ADHD is your superpower. It sounds like you benefit from Vyvanse (which you get because of and ADHD diagnosis, presumably), but you don’t mention any other benefits. And plenty of neurotypical people take ADHD meds and benefit from them also. Perhaps you also have other direct benefits from ADHD, like increased creativity?
- jacques_chester 9y agoI put it this way: it's easier to connect dots if your head is full of dots wiggling, bouncing and singing.
- ajaimk 9y agoOutside the box thinking for one. The ability to hyperfocus on the task at hand. The trick for me was finding a job I found interesting enough to work hard on. Do note that I had been working for 4 years before I started Vyvanse.
- nothrows 9y agoman fuck articles like this. I was diagnosed with ADHD in elementary. school was extremely difficult for me and I even flunked grade 2, but was pushed onto the next grade after my parents complained. My parents didn't believe in giving me the meds. I graduated high school with honors, but it took hours and hours of study because I was never able to focus. Then I started university... I was completely overwhelmed and dropped out. We've built a society where its a detriment not to be able to focus, denying your children a level playing field is absolutely cruel.
- hnuser1234 9y agoThe pills don't magically give you the ability to focus. They make you nervous and neurotic. You focus on things not because you have improved self control, but because your brain is closer to a panic and more anxious. Now I'm ultra neurotic and overall brainfucked. You didn't miss out. Oh also, they kill your appetite you so hardly eat and you'd end up inches shorter than you are now.
- jbenner-radham 9y agoMaybe it was the medication you were on but my medication most definitely greatly improved my ability to focus and actually reduced my anxiety. But like I said we could have been on different medication, have different body chemistries, etc.
- smittywerben 9y agoYou're supposed to tell stop taking them if they make you anxious. Maybe try a non-stimulant? I'm curious if you did other drugs?
- McPepper 9y agoAs a person with ADD, I don't like taking the medications. It makes me feel like a zombie and emotionally dead inside. I hated it. It stripped everything of me but made me "productive" (as in acing school work - which did brilliantly). However, I feel it wasn't worth it. It took months just to feel normal again. For those who were wondering, I took a mix of short and long releasing stimulants. Although, I mainly blame the short releasing ones for most of my troubles.
- zengid 9y agoFrankly, just my opinion, but I think ADHD is an invented condition that tries make it seem like a child who can't sit still and work on boring stuff for 8 hours a day has a problem. I think the problem is that our public education education system isn't able to tailor content and engage the kids who are smart and bored.
- pentagonpapers 9y agoI also think the drugs are given to trouble kids to make them comply in school, the they never develop the discipline to succeed. At least, after 5 years on ritalin and 5 years off that's where I'm at. My mind is all fd up and it's a struggle to work. I'm lucky in the I've been very successful in the corporate world but I know I'm lucky.
- MattRix 9y agoAs someone who had ADHD as a child and now still has it as an adult, I don't think you have a clue what you're talking about. Yes, of course some (many?) kids are misdiagnosed, but it is a real disorder with often awful consequences. It's not about "kids who can't sit still".
- zengid 9y agoI'm sorry that you've had negative consequences from ADHD. I'm just saying, along with the author of the article 'In Praise of ADHD', that we shouldn't just label it a disorder if there are positive aspects of it as well. Our society needs to learn how to value creative individuals, and not try to get them to submit to authority. Please understand that I didn't mean to insult you; I didn't mean to say that your struggle is not real. I just don't think its right to administer amphetamine to kids in order to 'fix' them.
- DanBC 9y agoWhy the scare quotes around "fix"? People have clearly described the severe life limiting impairment caused by ADHD, and these have fuck all to do with "submitting to authority". People with ADHD are more likely to have a drug or alcohol addiction; less likely to complete education; less likely to have a job; more likely to die in accidents; more likely to die by suicide. Taking medication is a small price to pay to fix that.
- hsljekskfh 9y agoi have adhd and a good number of friends and coworkers with it too (people with adhd tend to attract one another). i can mostly speak for their social life because that's what i've seen, and also they're not obsessed with intelligence like some hn readers. the no filter thing is the most noticeable part. it can lead to extremely unprofessional management at worst (along with problems organizing). the upside is that it creates people who naturally come off as relateable and funny; because any conversation with them immediately feels casual and fun, they happen to be great at hosting podcasts and doing standup comedy (i believe most successful comedians have adhd, and many admit it). in a business setting they can be very convincing without you noticing it. it's more like a personality type than a disorder, and really it's considered a disorder because it's a personality that hates sitting still in class and listening to a teacher for the first 22 years of life. most successful people i know with adhd had some weird career path where they didn't do great in school, switched focus many times and then careers during their 20s.
- echlebek 9y agoI'm lugging around an ADD diagnosis from my teenage years, complete with years of taking stimulants, followed by years of rejecting stimulants, and embracing self-therapy, so I have plenty of opinions, as one could imagine. But I'd like to describe my own experience of what having ADD is like. Imagine a scheduler that has many tasks to schedule, and more incoming work than it can schedule in a timely fashion. The scheduler is designed to consider all tasks, but will give a higher priority to tasks that provide immediate feedback. A consequence of this design is that tasks which require a lot of time to complete, but provide little to no feedback until after the task is completed, are typically starved for resources. Often, they will never complete, or even start running. Well, that's basically how my brain worked before I started exerting control over it. I would flip from thought to thought, lingering on things that provided immediate feedback, like playing musical instruments or video games. Planning is a difficult task when your brain works that way. I had to consciously focus attention away from things that I was seemingly wired to fixate on. Even determined concentration was hampered by constant context switching, which I felt I had little control over. ADD is a chronic condition, and I still have to deal with this on a daily basis. But it has gotten easier. Luckily, I've been able to develop enough coping techniques to at least take care of myself. Most people who know me assume that I am very high functioning. As a software developer, I am pretty successful, and people equate that with intense concentration and process-oriented thinking. My own, inner world is far more chaotic than others could imagine!
- farresito 9y agoThis really resonates with me, especially the constant context switching and only being able to do tasks that provide immediate reward. That said, I've always gotten the impression that this is something that a lot of people, with or without ADD, suffer from, probably exacerbated by the constant amount of information we are exposed to.
- mercer 9y agoLike most mental health 'disorders', it's often a matter of degree more than some clearly defined difference. That said, it's quite possible that 'we' as a society are becoming less capable of sustained focus and delayed gratification, and our constant mobile phone use, among other things, might play a role in that. It truly fascinates me how much phones in particular have changed our day to day behavior. I don't know if this is true, but I recall reading that many people check their phone, on average, every five minutes. While I hesitate to call that unhealthy, it's bound to have some kind of noticeable effect.
- jonex 9y agoThe problem with the concept of psychiatric diagnoses having advantages is that they generally are defined by their disadvantages. So if having ADHD has advantages, it must be directly caused by the disadvantages, because you can't have ADHD without the latter. Saying that "ADHD is good because it makes you restless which makes you more adaptable to change" is therefore questionable. You could be restless and adaptable to change without having enough issues that it would warrant an ADHD diagnosis. A correct argument would have to include the properties separating people with ADHD with those with similar traits, but aren't hampered in their daily function because of it: It could for example go like: "Having ADHD is good, because if you are too unfocused to keep a job, you get a lot of free time".
- tzakrajs 9y agoThe biggest challenge with my ADHD symptoms has to be relationships and giving sustained attention to my partners in a way that makes them feel valued.
- emit_time 9y ago:( Do you care to elaborate?
- tzakrajs 9y agoSometimes I will be so hyper focused that I miss things that are said and other times I am so easily distracted (and rabbit holed) by the happenings around me that people have a hard time believing that I am enjoying myself. Instead, they tell me that I appear to be trying to break free of their company.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoAt age 5, testing concluded my oldest did not have ADHD. At age 8 in a different school, a teacher suggested we "put him on Ritalin" so he would sit still in her class. Yeah, let's skip diagnosing the kid and go straight to drugging him for your convenience. Nothing wrong in the slightest with that thought process. I ultimately homeschooled and I spent a lot of time on various parenting lists. Nutritional supplements actually have a good track record of calming down wild kids, but that isn't a standard recommendation and gets dismissed as woo if you talk about it. If you are interested in that angle, there's interesting research and discussion related to nutrition and prison populations here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16140867 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16140867 Over the years, I have seen other articles that suggest that ADHD makes one a better soldier or whatever. I'm not really surprised by the research cited here concerning ADHD genes and things like migration and occupational outcomes. Once upon a time, we talked about personality differences, saying some people were shy and others gregarious. Now, we diagnose shy people with conditions like selective mutism and we say gregarious people have no filter and diagnose them with conditions like ADHD. I realize some people really suffer. But I think it makes vastly more sense to take a nutritional approach and also consider what people are well suited for and help them find their niche instead of medicalizing and medicating everything under the sun.
- jacques_chester 9y agoI think it's important to distinguish between the existence of a diagnosis, the time at which the diagnosis became possible to record and the prevalence of overdiagnosis. Because if you blur these together, you can hurt people who genuinely need help.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoMental models for the problem determine how we address it. A good demonstration of that idea is in an old joke about a doctor who castrated a guy when larger underwear would have been an equally valid way to cure his headaches.* If people with ADHD need, for example, better nutrition and are being given drugs instead, they may currently be getting harmed. * http://jokes4us.com/dirtyjokes/castrationjoke.html http://jokes4us.com/dirtyjokes/castrationjoke.html
- djyaz1200 9y agoIn the book Deliver from Distraction the authors (at least one of whom has ADHD and is a psychologist) describe everyone else as having "Attention Surplus Disorder". They go into some detail describing how odd it is for someone to be able to sit still for 8 hours a day doing something really boring. It was an interesting counterpoint to the idea that ADHD is even a disorder... but rather a set of traits that have always been useful in some areas. Similar point to this article. I recommend the book btw, it was helpful to me in embracing the unique gifts that come with the challenges of ADHD.
- mamon 9y agoWasn't there a study in Denmark that basically proved that ADHD is caused by sending children to school too early and then forcing the usual classroom rigor on them? Delaying primary school until the age of 7 decreased ADHD rate by 73%
- sinnoh 9y agotoo
- lazyasciiart 9y agoWas there?
- burntrelish1273 9y agoWTH? ADHD is a neurogenetic disorder of executive function, it's not contagious, not acquired, not caused by video games, screens or the age at which schooling starts.
- chris_wot 9y agoThis sounds like the claims about being given autism by vaccines - irresponsible and inaccurate.
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoI seem to remember that study showed that delaying school reduced ADHD like behaviour, not ADHD itself.
- chrisbrandow 9y agoAll I can say is I feel like adhd meds saved my life. If you’re struggling, at least talk to a doctor to find out options. Don’t run away from learning more. But there is no blanket treatment for everyone.
- kmfrk 9y agoI have ADHD and I hate it and it sucks. But I think 85% of the issue with my ADHD is the social stigma and people who will never understand nor accept it. I don’t think the right response is some kind of eye-rolling “ADHD-positivity”; people need help, treatment, and acceptance. ADHD is what you might consider one of the more “telegenic” disabilities, which is all the more reason to advocate for an inclusive, understanding approach to disabilities in general. Otherwise, people won’t get the help they need, and dumbasses will continue to revert to their tropes of “laziness”, “lack of willpower”, “bad parenting”, and “just need to put in more effort”. There’s a lot of confusion about what ADHD is and whether it exists at all. Here’s what, you don’t really need irrefutable evidence about someone’s predicament to care about other people who are different from you. Regardless of what you think is the case wrt ADHD, there’s an opportunity for you to grapple with the fact that there are people dealing with struggles invisible to you every waking day of their lives, and that you need to take that into account when judging them as children, students, co-workers and human beings, and where they got or didn’t get to in life.
- lsc 9y ago>But I think 85% of the issue with my ADHD is the social stigma and people who will never understand nor accept it. You... sound like you participate in a lot of online discussion groups where the general public talks about ADHD. I don't think this is healthy, for all the reasons you list. I mean, support groups are useful for some people, and you can have online support groups, but just like in person support groups, you need to filter so that the people who just want to insult you are not participating. I think this is something that needs to be taught in high school; once you are out of high school? you get to pick your peers. If your peers make you feel bad about who you are, pick new peers.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoonce you are out of high school? you get to pick your peers. If your peers make you feel bad about who you are, pick new peers. That's nice in theory, but it is a little like telling black people to only befriend nice white people or women to ignore all the sexist pigs. If essentially the entire world is the problem and there is a relatively small number of people that really get your issues (are really on the same page as you), acting like they just need to be choosier about their friends amounts to victim blaming.
- danieltillett 9y agoIs there a name for the opposite of ADHD?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- smittywerben 9y agoNo, time matters.
- ojhughes 9y agoThe hardest part of ADHD for me is the impulsivity, or lack of filter and inability to regulate emotions . So often I have blurted things out only to regret them seconds later. During my younger, undiagnosed years, reckless behaviour, drinking and smoking pot were the norm. Thankfully getting a diagnosis and medication has helped a great deal in sorting my life out! I am immensely grateful for my girlfriend who somehow manages to understand my sometimes difficult and frustrating behaviour.
- InclinedPlane 9y agoI came across this description of the actual core features of ADD some time ago and found it to be very resonant for me: https://www.additudemag.com/symptoms-of-add-hyperarousal-rejection-sensitivity/ https://www.additudemag.com/symptoms-of-add-hyperarousal-rej... They are: interest based attention, emotional hyperarousal, and rejection sensitivity. It's amazing how many other symptoms of ADD these features cover, and how important they are in describing how ADD affects daily life.
- limeblack 9y agoMy brother was diagnosed with ADHD and subsequently formed an addiction to the medication at a young age. It is uncertain how he would have done with out it, but he dreamed of joining the military and was denied entry being unable to come off the medication. Between bad grades and ADHD medication doing it over he would have chosen bad grades.
- trisimix 9y agoI'm ADHD and ODD(oppositional defiance disorder) with maybe tourettes(pretty serious tick though its diagnosed as tick disorder) fortunately I was lucky enough to fall in love with computers. I fond the easiest way to keep rrack is to juggle many things I view as entertaining or important. I definitely wouldnt reccomend this to anyone though. Whenever I try to go with the status quo though I pretty much lose my mind and end up playing video games.
- avenoir 9y agoThere is a hypothesis that ADHD is a condition caused due to humans still evolving out of hunter-gatherer societies and those folks living with the condition retained the hunter characteristics/genetics. More on this here [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hunter_vs._farmer_hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hunter_vs._farmer_hypothesis
- burntrelish1273 9y agoPraise? :/ Just diagnosed as an adult partially due to parents not "believing in it," refused testing then and I was blind to it until now. Currently friendless, jobless, broke, homeless and a bazillion unfinished projects not exactly the picture of praiseworthy. ADHD is a misnomer, it's an executive function disorder, but the name will never change because it's embedded in disability laws. Medicating for emotional regulation, continuity of thought, completing tasks and not coming-off as weird are lifesaving... don't avoid medication out of some antivaxx nonsense. Worth watching: - ADHD Child vs. Non-ADHD Child Interview https://youtu.be/-IO6zqIm88s https://youtu.be/-IO6zqIm88s - How To Know If You Have ADHD https://youtu.be/5GBMS7WPFSs https://youtu.be/5GBMS7WPFSs - This is how you treat ADHD based off science, Dr Russell Barkley part of 2012 Burnett Lecture https://youtu.be/_tpB-B8BXk0 https://youtu.be/_tpB-B8BXk0 - Dr Russell Barkley on ADHD Meds and how they all work differently from each other https://youtu.be/LnS0PfNyj4U https://youtu.be/LnS0PfNyj4U - The Neuroanatomy of ADHD and thus how to treat ADHD - CADDAC - Dr Russel Barkley part 1c https://youtu.be/wccW-KB2OsI https://youtu.be/wccW-KB2OsI
- ghotli 9y agoI would consider my personal life and career a success both because of my ADHD and in spite of my ADHD. Notebooks, lists, and routines are a constant struggle, but are how I cope. My current and most effective solution to date is an Android Wear 2.0 watchface that does the following things. 1. Has a list of granular routines I can select. "Work - Start", "Work - Priority", "Home - End", "Let's get started" are all examples of such. 2. I can "load" a list such that I can iterate through tasks one by one _linearly_ and I don't tap my wrist to denote "done" until the task is done. 3. While a list is loaded, my wrist vibrates every thirty seconds to keep me on task. 4. I can "Clear" a list at any time to stop my wrist from buzzing and to return to a "select a routine / priority list" mode, it also stops when I complete a list. This keeps me on task, reminds me that I've decided to work towards a singular goal, and keeps my current "cursor" at a glance. A part of me wishes I didn't have to live this way, but it's a coping mechanism that keeps me more effective than I've ever been and I will likely use it and improve upon it for the rest of my days. So, ama if you're curious about any other details. I am interested to know if a system like this would work for others. Right now it's literally an APK I load onto my watch that hits an API running on kubernetes. Simple, but effective.
- let_it_be 9y agoI'd really be interested in trying this. Sticking to a routine has always been one of the hardest parts of all this.
- smittywerben 9y agoI doubt this person would submit to genomic testing for ADHD. Failing everything (socially, school, and work) as a child and in adulthood isn't some fucking joke. This opinion piece is wrong. Might as well throw out the sunscreen and pray away skin-cancer.
- discussedbefore 9y agoInside the adult ADHD brain | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7882729 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7882729 (2014)
- andyt73 9y agoThe NYT article is just wrong. First of all, most people do not have ADHD, yet this "hyperactive" society was built primarily by them. Second, people with ADHD still struggle in this world, arguably more than ever. A century ago, there wasn't even a recognized disorder -- some people just needed more time and effort for certain tasks. Jobs were not as mentally demanding, at lest not on the surface level (many jobs did require more "hyperfocus", in that they were narrower but "deeper"). ADHD became a problematic condition because society sped up, and people with the disorder couldn't keep up with it. As a 44 year old who has taken medication for ADHD my entire adult life, I know that it is slowness and serenity, not rapid-fire multitasking, that enables me to work better. Medication does not rob me of any creativity -- proper dosage enables creativity because it enables patience, and hence structure and planning. I get tired of people telling me my disability is a gift.
- gleventhal 9y agoI know that some facets of my thinking are exceptional, but I am not always aware of what I am good at until I do it. This often leads to people being surprised by my abilities after they have written me off already. Its a novelty, but I'd rather be consistent. I am very successful in my career, but I failed my way through school and struggled with addiction when I was younger. It's not easy to live with ADHD. I have a lot of anger, people frustrate me so much. They are too slow and don't take enough risks.