3 ms·
Well, there are lumpers and splitters, and I tend to be a splitter. But anyway, should one judge China based on Western principles and values. If so, what woul
by mirimir 9y ago
Well, there are lumpers and splitters, and I tend to be a splitter.
But anyway, should one judge China based on Western principles and values. If so, what would be the basis for that?
And if not, should one judge China based on principles and values of <some other Asian nation>? I don't see the basis for that, either.
However, it is of course valid for Chinese to judge their own country, based on whatever principles and values they might hold. And to work for change. But that's a very different thing from random Westerners judging China.
Personally, I can't imagine living in China. I have a hard enough time tolerating the US. But it's for sure better than where I came from. Although, I must admit, far from what I had imagined. But so it goes.
- glenstein 9y ago>But anyway, should one judge China based on Western principles and values. If so, what would be the basis for that? I would say that justifying authoritarianism is a perfect example of how appeals to cultural relativism can be dangerous.
- mirimir 9y agoThere's a distinction that I've been failing horribly to make clearly. I don't like the current Chinese regime. I wouldn't want to live there. And I support projects to help Chinese dissidents. However, I do my best to avoid judging. Labeling. Appealing to illusory fundamental ideals and standards. Sure, but maybe "authoritarianism" is just an abstract concept, and there's a lot more to the current Chinese situation th
- emodendroket 9y agoWithout getting into the weeds of what exactly we should say they are, I would argue there is such a thing as a set of universal principles that anyone should be held to (to take the trite, obvious example, we shouldn't excuse the Holocaust on the basis of some distinct German values).
- mirimir 9y agoNo, there's no excusing the Holocaust. But it is useful to understand how the Nazis got to that point. Wars make people crazy. WWI was a horrorshow. And just a couple decades later, WWII. Germany felt beaten and cornered, and the Nazis offered hope. And then things got totally out of hand.
- emodendroket 9y agoBut if you want to understand it, I think appeals to German essentialism would be among the worst ways.
- woolvalley 9y agoAlso there are counter examples of singapore, hong kong, macau and taiwan to show, no, chinese people are not culturally prone to creating a '1984' dystopia. You can split hairs saying 'it used to be more authoritarian', 'one party has been in power for a long time', or 'it used to be under the nominal control of a western state' since no place is 1:1, but in the end it shows typical chinese people do not want it either.