4 ms·
I do not claim that that did not happen; rather, what I claim is that there is nothing uniquely Russian about saying "what right do you have to criticize us by
by emodendroket 9y ago
I do not claim that that did not happen; rather, what I claim is that there is nothing uniquely Russian about saying "what right do you have to criticize us by a standard which you yourself do not uphold?"
- simonh 9y agoIt’s not uniquely Russian, it’s just that it was systematically used by Russia far back into Soviet days making them a very strong example of using it to change the subject and avoid dealing with an issue.
- jimmywanger 9y agoWell, there sort of is. The term you're speaking of "whataboutism" is not refuting the argument on logical priciples, it's an ad hominem attack. Just because the person accusing you of doing something wrong is doing the same thing does not make it right for you to do it. What is the argument here to justify your behaviours or the judgment of others for your sins, even if they're guilty of the same? If I kill somebody, am I wrong for calling out somebody else out for killing somebody? The Russians raised this into an art form. They justified Afghanistan by using Vietnam.