3 ms·
> The fact that comments cannot be deleted is increasingly unethical ... Just assume that a few seconds after you post a comment Google, Bing, Facebook and a f
by gus_massa 9y ago
> The fact that comments cannot be deleted is increasingly unethical ...
Just assume that a few seconds after you post a comment Google, Bing, Facebook and a few other major Internet sites have scrapped your comment and are analyzing it.
And there a few aggregators that repeat the HN content and alternative UI for HN.
And some users make a local copy to run some statistics or detect dupes or just for curiosity. Some moron even made a Chrome extension to show the deleted and edited comments in HN.
And assume that the spy agencies of the major countries are making a nice backup of all your comments.
So after pressing the send button, just assume that there are 30 copies of your comment floating around.
A delete button only deletes one of them. The idea of Tweeter that you can delete a tweet and everybody really delete it is hilarious. Just assume the there is no "delete" button, it's just a "hide" button.
"Deleting" a comment is useful against a clueless neighbor that hates you because your dog barks too much. If a country with nukes hates you, they probably have the technology to save a copy of the "deleted" comment.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sizzle 9y agoWhat if someone pretends to be you and posts incriminating posts?
- im3w1l 9y ago"Deleting" a comment is useful against a clueless neighbor that hates you because your dog barks too much. Probably a more common problem than spy agencies, just saying.
- whatyoucantsay 9y agoWhat you write is a reasonable precaution in 2018. Many, many HN posts and accounts were created before the Snowden revelations, before Xi came to power and before the Charlie Hebdo attack. Many comments will be and have been mined years after their original posting. It's truly doubtful any country was logging every HN comment in the year you opened your account, for example.