3 ms·
> 17 years. 179 victims. 260 total deaths from all car crashes in 2016 alone. If street racing is out of control, just plain driving is off the charts. Who is
by paulcole 9y ago
> 17 years. 179 victims.
260 total deaths from all car crashes in 2016 alone. If street racing is out of control, just plain driving is off the charts.
Who is downvoting this and why?
- jandrese 9y agoI think if you compare crash-per-mile-driven or crash-per-hour those figures won't even be in the same universe.
- jessaustin 9y agoTransportation is not the point of street racing, so of what possible significance would that comparison be?
- jandrese 9y agoThey both involve the same activity--operating a motor vehicle in a city environment. Besides, the original comparison was between transportation and street racing!
- cryptoz 9y ago> They both involve the same activity--operating a motor vehicle in a city environment That is not the same activity. You have generalized so far beyond the original point it no longer makes sense. Is a speed eating competition where you eat as many hotdogs as possible in a NY hot dog establishment the same activity as making homemade salad with your family at home? They're both "eating food in a city" right? They are not the same activity, and street racing is not the same activity as commuting home or going to the store for toilet paper.
- jessaustin 9y agoThe original comparison was between two dangerous activities, not between two dangerous modes of transportation the danger of which might be informatively amortized across the quantity of transportation provided.
- paulcole 9y ago"Vision Zero is working in partnership with the City of Los Angeles to end all traffic deaths and serious injuries by 2025." http://visionzero.lacity.org/ http://visionzero.lacity.org/ The goal isn't to minimize deaths per mile driven or per hour, it's to eliminate deaths period.
- jandrese 9y agoThat's a lofty goal, and probably impossible with the improvements they are suggesting. Just reducing speed (increasing congestion) and installing more traffic lights/crosswalks won't eliminate all traffic deaths. To actually accomplish something like that you would need to radically redesign the city. Eliminate non-autonomous cars, build a really first class subway system (bus accidents are a thing!), go all-in on elevated walkways, invent some kind of really effective suicide counseling, etc... That said, even if they "fail" and only eliminate 90% of the traffic fatalities/major injuries that's still a big win IMHO.
- francisofascii 9y agoI think speed reduction is the biggest. Yes, zero does sound almost impossible. US commercial air travel had zero deaths in 2017, so that should give some confidence.
- jandrese 9y agoCommercial air travel doesn't have to deal with pedestrians. That's basically my option B from above. Ban all surface transportation and massively expand the subway system. Also redesign the subway system so it can deliver packages now. Absolutely no chance in hell of getting that done by 2025. Oh, and also redesign all subway platforms so people can't use them to commit suicide. Or maybe they're trying the London option and making gridlock so bad that no car ever gets enough speed to seriously injure a pedestrian.
- Libturd 9y agobecause people are retards
- nxc18 9y agoYou're getting downvoted because driving and street racing are totally incomparable. Street racing is a distinct, illegal, reckless behavior with no possible upside (for society) whatsoever. Even worse, many of the victims are not involved in the driving - those victims were slaughtered randomly. Their lives were risked with no possible benefit for anyone. The fatalities for street racing should be zero, because it shouldn't be happening. It's really fucking annoying that I put my life at risk every time I drive on the 10 (or anywhere else) and there are other drivers who are deliberately increasing that risk. Reckless driving with fatalities is murder. That should be your comparison.
- BigChiefSmokem 9y agoI've been noticing a lot of "down vote wars" on HN lately. I can't tell if it's the increase in users (popularity) or the posts/climate that are becoming more unreasonable. Chicken and egg problem.