5 ms·
That headline is misleading. I read it as them controlling it for 1 hour which wasn't the case. I am a little surprised that the brakes didn't work. Are brakes
by maxxxxx 9y ago
That headline is misleading. I read it as them controlling it for 1 hour which wasn't the case.
I am a little surprised that the brakes didn't work. Are brakes "fly-by-wire" now? Otherwise you should be able to slam the brakes even if the car is full throttle. I have tried this with several cars and the brakes we always stronger than the engine.
- kirillseva 9y agoBrakes are fly-by-wire on new cars because slamming the brake is not the most optimal strategy for stopping the car as fast as you can. And it can also damage the car.
- antris 9y agoI'd choose damaging the car over this scenario any day.
- CyberDildonics 9y agoNo one is trying to make that argument
- maxxxxx 9y agoI also don't know how braking hard would damage the car.
- djrogers 9y agoNo - ABS works without drive-by-wire, and was available in cars for decades before DBW systems were.
- ataturk 9y agoEvery car needs a mechanical engine kill switch just like a motorcycle. Needs to be done now.
- wallace_f 9y ago>because Would government getting control over our cars be that much more unbelievable than of our phones?
- dannyw 9y agoThe handbrake / e-brake are all electronic and “break-by-wire” on many new vehicles. Many hybrids also use break by wire for their main breaks. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brake-by-wire https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brake-by-wire
- jandrese 9y agoI agree, I'd like to see the incident report on this. According to the subtitles both the brakes and the shifter failed. The shifter could be one of those flappy paddle deals where it's entirely plausible that a computer crash would disable it. Brake-by-wire seems like a bad idea. I really want to have those physical lines in there as a final redundancy, like the physical control lines on a 737. These kinds of stories are only going to get more common as we put more and more automation (and complexity!) into our vehicles. This would require way too many improbable events to happen at once on an old manual transmission car. Clutch lines fail, shifter somehow gets stuck in gear, brake lines snap, ignition has an electrical fault that prevents the car from being turned off, cruise control somehow short circuits...all at once. Impossible without an elaborate sabotage.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoKinda. It's a manual system with electronic controls in parallel. If a piece of code decides it doesn't want you pushing the brake you're not gonna push the brake. On a new car basically all vehicle systems are this way where the car can ignore or override your input if a piece of code tells it to do that.
- taneq 9y ago> Are brakes "fly-by-wire" now? Absolutely not. Cars have dual redundant hydraulic systems which are operated mechanically by the brake pedal. Other systems affect this (such as vacuum assist, ABS, AEB etc.) but the foot brakes should still work (poorly) even if the car is totally unpowered.