5 ms·
>Kids, don't be a snitch. Simplistic. Kids, please be a snitch sometimes, like Manning.
by andrepd 9y ago
>Kids, don't be a snitch.
Simplistic. Kids, please be a snitch sometimes, like Manning.
- jakear 9y agoBut when you're being a snitch, don't snitch out the people that were snitches for you. Manning released the identities of Afghan nationals who helped the counterinsurgency, leading to their deaths at the hands of the Taliban.
- notthemessiah 9y ago[citation needed]
- jakear 9y agohttp://www.newsweek.com/taliban-says-it-will-target-names-exposed-wikileaks-74257 http://www.newsweek.com/taliban-says-it-will-target-names-ex...
- tzs 9y agoI don't think it is possible to specifically name anyone who actually died because of the leaks. It's similar to lung cancer deaths caused by smoking cigarettes. No one has ever been able to specifically name someone who died from lung cancer caused by smoking. In every single case, it is possible that the named person is one of the many people each year who die from lung cancers caused by things such radon exposure, asbestos, an unlucky mutation, or air pollution. We do know that when the Taliban would find out that someone was aiding those who opposed the Taliban, they would go after that person (and often their family, too). So we know that the leaks would have made some people targets who would not have otherwise been targets at the time. The best we can do is, as with lung cancer, is think about it statistically. Compare the people exposed in the leaks to similarly situated people who were not mentioned, and see if the former had a statistically significant higher death rate from Taliban attacks for themselves or their families. I don't know if the data is available to carry out that analysis.
- benchaney 9y agoThat's awfully convenient. I supposed we should just trust anyone whenever they claim that their abuses being uncovered hurts American interests. Particularly when their claims are completely unverifiable. I wonder if people will eventually stop falling for such a completely transparent attempt to muddy the waters.
- tzs 9y agoAre you suggesting that it is OK to put numerous third parties in danger (the people whose names being exposed would make them Taliban targets were generally Afghan civilians, not Americans) if the circumstances are such that no one will ever be able to prove that any specific one of them actually comes to harm from that danger? Even when releasing those names does nothing whatsoever to help expose any abuses?
- benchaney 9y agoNo. I'm not saying that at all. You seem to have forgotten that you wrote this. > The best we can do is, as with lung cancer, is think about it statistically. Compare the people exposed in the leaks to similarly situated people who were not mentioned, and see if the former had a statistically significant higher death rate from Taliban attacks for themselves or their families. > I don't know if the data is available to carry out that analysis.
- ScottBurson 9y agoWell, the data not being available doesn't necessarily mean that people weren't killed, either. I think you're both making valid points and the truth is somewhere in the middle. Yes, with certain kinds of leaks, there are potential risks to people that should be taken into account, by carefully selecting, and redacting when appropriate, the material to be leaked (which Manning didn't begin to do, nor allow anyone else to do). And on the other hand, with any leak of information about the military, one can count on people who object to the leak raising concerns about such risks, making it difficult to tell exactly how valid these concerns are in any particular case. That's not necessarily a good argument against leaking at all, in my opinion, though many consider it so.
- danso 9y agoNothing seems to have been revealed so far. - https://www.buzzfeed.com/jasonleopold/secret-government-report-chelsea-manning-leaks-caused-no https://www.buzzfeed.com/jasonleopold/secret-government-repo... > Regarding the hundreds of thousands of Iraq-related military documents and State Department cables provided by the Army private Chelsea Manning, the report assessed “with high confidence that disclosure of the Iraq data set will have no direct personal impact on current and former U.S. leadership in Iraq.” - http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2017/feb/01/john-mccain/mccain-says-taliban-murdered-people-because-chelse/ http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2017/feb/... > In the several years since WikiLeaks released hundreds of thousands of government documents leaked by Manning, the government has not publicly identified a single example of the Taliban killing someone because that person was named in the leaks. If someone had died as a result, it seems logical that the incident would have become public knowledge, either through Manning's trial or in media reports.
- djrogers 9y agoIt's not really fair to claim that Lamo was wrong to turn Manning in based on retrospection like this. It would have been entirely reasonable at the time to assume that some of the 260k+ cables might have endangered US soldiers, allies, and others. The fact that we can't prove it did now does not change the reasonableness of that conclusion nearly a decade ago, and given the stakes at play it seems unfair to vilify someone for doing what he did.
- danso 9y agoI don't disagree with you, just pointing out that there don't appear to be known incidents, as a previous commenter seemed to assert as fact.
- Alex3917 9y ago> don't snitch out the people that were snitches for you If by 'for you' you mean Halliburton and Monsanto.
- auntienomen 9y agoSimplistic again. Most of Manning's snitching didn't help anyone but the Taliban.