3 ms·
In that shootout link you post (Charles Cramer’s essay), the detail blowups of the 4x5 scan have clearly better resolution than the P45 blowups. (Though obvious
by jacobolus 16y ago
In that shootout link you post (Charles Cramer’s essay), the detail blowups of the 4x5 scan have clearly better resolution than the P45 blowups. (Though obviously the digital back has many other advantages, like turn-around time, marginal image cost, ease of handling, etc.)
> For any serious use, film is absolutely stone dead.
There are plenty of fabulous artists still shooting film with view cameras and getting great images.
For example, are you going to tell me that Burtynsky isn’t serious? (Note, he’s also taken some pictures w/ a Hasselblad w/ a digital back in the last few years, where setting up a view camera is not feasible. But as far as I know the bulk of his pictures are still taken on film.)
- jdietrich 16y agoFilm is an artistic eccentricity, like a writer using a manual typewriter or a guitarist using a beaten-up '58 Strat. It's an indulgence you can only afford if you don't have deadlines to meet or a client paying by the hour.
- jacobolus 16y agoOkay. You should have said something like “film is dead for ‘serious’ uses where serious is defined as ‘a client paying by the hour’” then, instead. But generally clients paying by the hour care about “bang for the buck” and “timely” and “good enough” more than they care about absolute quality, so that’s sort of a different use case than fine art photography. I really don’t see why there should be any problem with a writer or guitarist using whatever equipment they want. The product is what matters here, not the tools. Basically, your definition makes journalists serious but novelists not, and orchestra members serious, but rock band members not. Eh.