3 ms·
"It seems like a poorly constructed argument to suppose that creativity is a required element to be the party responsible for creating a copy." It was. I elide
by jerf 9y ago
"It seems like a poorly constructed argument to suppose that creativity is a required element to be the party responsible for creating a copy."
It was. I elided, either deliberately or otherwise (I'm honestly not sure myself), a discussion on the idea that creativity is the standard in the ability to have copyright on something, and thus if you use that as a sort of guideline by choice, then you can make an argument that somebody who isn't bringing any creativity to the party can't be said to be the one who has produced any useful work. Therefore, the question is, if the end-user can't be said to have had any hand in creating the work, who did? Well, the only people left are the developers of the merging code. If it's not legal for said developers to simply distribute the result of the merge, how can it be legal for the result of the merge to appear on someone else's desktop anyhow, if the user didn't really do anything to produce it?
Basically, this asks the question "What is distribution in a world of computing devices, anyhow?" And I reiterate I'm not trying to take a position here per se, but simply pointing out that there is a question here. The ideas of distribution were created before we were all equipped with multiple powerful media engines of our own.
So the copy machine metaphor is not relevant, because copy machines fit into the old paradigm handily. We're not talking about simple copying or we'd already know the answer as to whether or not it is legal, give or take a bit of EULA.
Fair use is unlikely to be even slightly relevant here, for all kinds of reasons. The internet conception of "fair use" does not legally exist, and the legal one seems irrelevant anyhow, since we're stipulating that the end-user has a license to at least the original manifestation of the copyrighted work anyhow. This is the sort of thing I was referring to when I said that step one is understanding there is a problem at all; in my experience most people grappling with these questions get so hung up on the things they want to be able to do that they can't see past those to the underlying issues. The simple truth is that just like pretty much everything else in life, a fair, equitable, and coherent legal answer to these questions may result in you being told you can't do something you want to do, but you can take some comfort in the fact that you won't be the only one, and the result is fair and equitable. (Of course the odds of us getting a fair and equitable legal answer approach zero, especially in light of the fact that virtually nobody has even thought about these issues coherently in the first place.)
- michaelmrose 9y agoI don't think that because creativity is a guideline for creating a work worthy of protection implies that the act of creativity is required in order to be responsible for copying. This not only doesn't follow its a complete non sequitur. It is unrelated to any law or precedent or even a common sense reading of the law. The person who actuates the creation of a copy including by just pressing copy on a copier is guilty of copyright infringement. If the party that produces the recipe to create a derivative work is guilty they are guilty because they acted to enable that actual act of infringement or not at all not by some magical transference of responsibility based on a creativity test that you literally made up from whole cloth. If combining 2 works you paid for in a way not foreseen by the authors on your own computer is within the boundaries of copyright, which it is, then then the challenging to prove tangential responsibility for enabling infringement poofs like the morning dew under the bright summer sun. In your magical transference of responsibility theory the mod creator would have had to prove that creating a derivative work out of someone else's work was legally acceptable a hard task. In reality it is incredibly obvious whom is making a copy and any perceived ambiguity is merely you failing to understand copyright. Its also reasonable to suppose that copying the files you paid for access to to a different folder is either a) no different recording a program to view at a different time or b) no different than the copy that is created in ram to run the software. The first is fair use the latter is explicitly protected by law. https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/117 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/117 (a)Making of Additional Copy or Adaptation by Owner of Copy.—Notwithstanding the provisions of section 106, it is not an infringement for the owner of a copy of a computer program to make or authorize the making of another copy or adaptation of that computer program provided: (1) that such a new copy or adaptation is created as an essential step in the utilization of the computer program in conjunction with a machine and that it is used in no other manner,... Nowhere is it stated that this ought to be limited to using the sofware in a manner approved of by the author. Such restrictions would have to fall on the EULA and we would have to suppose that it was acceptable to toss on additional restrictions AFTER money had already changed hands and with no recourse for the user other than to eat the loss of money AND value. Basically its not just that your argument is flawed. It is creatively flawed in multiple ways which would be harmful to user freedom. Personally I don't look forward to your world where shovels come with contracts of adhesion that describe what kind of tasks they can be used for consulting a lawyer before I dig a hole more than n inches deep and paying an addition fee per day where I used it beyond approved use cases. I have no idea why ideas which would be wildly stupid applied to real things somehow sound tenable to some people when applied to software. Selling software should afford you no greater control than selling shovels and the people that want to argue otherwise need to push off.