3 ms·
The article is completely and utterly obsolete. 35mm digital would out-resolve medium format film circa 2002, with the Canon 1Ds[1]. A 39 megapixel medium forma
by jdietrich 16y ago
The article is completely and utterly obsolete. 35mm digital would out-resolve medium format film circa 2002, with the Canon 1Ds[1]. A 39 megapixel medium format digital back will come within spitting distance of 4x5 film[2]. Hasselblad now have a 60 megapixel medium format camera.
Being able to use a smaller sensor format at the same or better quality is of critical importance, because it allows the photographer to use smaller, lighter, brighter lenses. A digital MF system can happily be used handheld, whereas a 4x5 camera demands a very large and heavy tripod to work at all. Large format lenses are so slow and the cameras so bulky that a mere gust of wind can ruin an image.
That's at low ISO. Start cranking up the sensitivity and digital is in a world of it's own. A Nikon D3s will produce useful images at 12800 ISO and very clean images at 6400 ISO[3].
For any serious use, film is absolutely stone dead. It still has a place for hobbyists and students, for whom the much cheaper equipment makes up for the inconvenience and poorer quality. For any serious use, digital is vastly, incomparably better than film.
[1] http://www.luminous-landscape.com/reviews/shootout.shtml http://www.luminous-landscape.com/reviews/shootout.shtml
[2] http://www.luminous-landscape.com/essays/Cramer.shtml http://www.luminous-landscape.com/essays/Cramer.shtml
[3] http://imaging.nikon.com/products/imaging/lineup/digitalcamera/slr/d3s/sample.htm http://imaging.nikon.com/products/imaging/lineup/digitalcame...
- jacobolus 16y agoIn that shootout link you post (Charles Cramer’s essay), the detail blowups of the 4x5 scan have clearly better resolution than the P45 blowups. (Though obviously the digital back has many other advantages, like turn-around time, marginal image cost, ease of handling, etc.) > For any serious use, film is absolutely stone dead. There are plenty of fabulous artists still shooting film with view cameras and getting great images. For example, are you going to tell me that Burtynsky isn’t serious? (Note, he’s also taken some pictures w/ a Hasselblad w/ a digital back in the last few years, where setting up a view camera is not feasible. But as far as I know the bulk of his pictures are still taken on film.)
- jdietrich 16y agoFilm is an artistic eccentricity, like a writer using a manual typewriter or a guitarist using a beaten-up '58 Strat. It's an indulgence you can only afford if you don't have deadlines to meet or a client paying by the hour.
- jacobolus 16y agoOkay. You should have said something like “film is dead for ‘serious’ uses where serious is defined as ‘a client paying by the hour’” then, instead. But generally clients paying by the hour care about “bang for the buck” and “timely” and “good enough” more than they care about absolute quality, so that’s sort of a different use case than fine art photography. I really don’t see why there should be any problem with a writer or guitarist using whatever equipment they want. The product is what matters here, not the tools. Basically, your definition makes journalists serious but novelists not, and orchestra members serious, but rock band members not. Eh.
- Tamerlin 16y agoNot even remotely. The luminous landscape comparisons were complete rubbish. The best prints that I've seen from digital imagers, including modern full-frame 35mm digital cameras, look miserably blurry if you approach the print closely enough to read the caption. From 15 feet away, they look nice and sharp... my prints from 4x5 look every bit as sharp from 15 feet away until you stick your nose on the print -- and all you keep finding is more detail. The other thing that the digital fanputzes ignore is that with the exception of the Foveon, DIGITAL SENSORS ARE MONOCRHOMATIC. They invent most of their color information through interpolation because THEY CANNOT RECORD COLOR. If you want high ISO ability, digital rules the roost. If you want fast turnaround, you go with digital. If you want the best color and maximal detail, you use film -- the bigger the better. Even Jack Dykinga, who switched to using multiple exposures stitched together for his commercial work, says that for fine art images, he still uses 4x5 film, because not even stitching 15-20 full 35mm frame digital images together can match an image from a 4x5 sheet film, especially if you use a drum scanner.
- jdietrich 16y agoIf my comparisons are rubbish, post better ones. This is HN, not Reddit. Cite your sources.
- Tamerlin 16y agoSigh... typical response. I suppose I should have known better than to expect an intelligent response, eh? (Then again, people actually believed Apple in spite of their equally transparent gaming of their SPEC tests.) The best way to see the comparison in person would be either to see my prints (easy if you're in Seattle) or order one or two large prints and see for yourself. However, there are still some examples online done by people who are skilled photographers, and who know a thing or two about scanning... plus, unlike the folks who did the comparison for the luminous landscape, this guy uses a GOOD scanner. (He's also the person who got me started with large format photography, so I had a chance to spend a week photographing with him in the Smokies, and got a lot of instruction from him.) http://www.dannyburk.com/drum_scan_resolution.htm http://www.dannyburk.com/drum_scan_resolution.htm