3 ms·
> use the type system to have the compiler statically check the pointers are live It doesn't explain how it would statically ensure that a moved-from unique_pt
by masklinn 9y ago
> use the type system to have the compiler statically check the pointers are live
It doesn't explain how it would statically ensure that a moved-from unique_ptr (or equivalent) can not be used. In fact the only mentions of moves are that owning pointers can only be moved and soft pointers can be moved or copied, but C++'s move does not remove any access, it just moves the content leaving the moved-from object in a "valid but unspecified state".
Note that valid != safe. Dereferencing a moved-from unique_ptr is unsafe for instance.
Rust's affine types solve this issue, a moved-from type (Box included) simply can't be used, its scope ends when it's moved.
> Looking online, I see that people implement all the same primitives in rust, with exactly the same safety caveats.
Rust's (safe) pointers and references don't throw exceptions on explicit use after free because such code doesn't compile at all, and its equivalent to dynamic_cast has to be very specifically opted in: https://doc.rust-lang.org/1.19.0/std/any/trait.Any.html#method.downcast_mut https://doc.rust-lang.org/1.19.0/std/any/trait.Any.html#meth...
- nobugs 9y ago> Rust's (safe) pointers and references don't throw exceptions on explicit use Which essentially goes at the cost of having Java-style semantic memory leaks (very generally, _any_ kind of keeping-an-object-as-long-as-at-least-one-reference-exists suffers from it) => we still have to pick our poison (personally, I _strongly_ prefer to avoid refcounting, and it does work like a charm in a few very serious million-LoC/billions-transactions projects, but I do agree that opinions may differ).
- masklinn 9y ago> Which essentially goes at the cost of having Java-style semantic memory leaks (very generally, _any_ kind of keeping-an-object-as-long-as-at-least-one-reference-exists suffers from it) Rust references work the opposite way. References don't extend the lifetime of their source, and a reference outliving its referent is a compile-time error. > we still have to pick our poison (personally, I _strongly_ prefer to avoid refcounting, and it does work like a charm in a few very serious million-LoC/billions-transactions projects, but I do agree that opinions may differ). I have no idea what the hell you're talking about, but you seem to suffer from pretty significant misunderstandings.
- nobugs 9y agoI'm still speaking about reference-counted RC<T>, which inevitably suffers from memory leaks. And moreover - _any_ implementation which avoids throwing an exception, in quite a few use cases has no other choice than to resort to keeping the stuff until the last reference to it is killed, inevitably causing Java-style semantic memory leaks. P.S. FWIW, Rust's references ~= OP's "naked pointers" (NOT 'soft pointers'), and SaferCPP's 'scoped pointers'. A useful tool, but is not sufficient in quite a few real-world use cases.