3 ms·
And that's exactly why I agree with the author: science is about finding what's true not about finding what's exciting. It's not like the choice about what to
by onion2k 9y ago
And that's exactly why I agree with the author: science is about finding what's true not about finding what's exciting.
It's not like the choice about what to spend money on is between "true" and "exciting". The choice is between "true and exciting" and "true and not exciting". We have to use something to choose what to invest in, so why not choose based on how exciting the potential discoveries are?
- jamesrcole 9y agoBecause, historically, many important discoveries (I would guess the majority) came from things people thought weren't terribly important. Often things that most thought had no value at all. I think of it like central planning vs free markets. It can sound good to plan things out and direct things towards the outcomes you want, but it's less efficient.
- Avshalom 9y agoWell investing in the exciting thing is what the free market does so...?
- jamesrcole 9y agoIt's the difference between central planning and a free market -- thinking your can plan out the overall system vs a more decentralised system -- that I'm focusing on with that analogy, and not making any other particular points about the relationship between science funding and business.
- digi_owl 9y ago> Because, historically, many important discoveries (I would guess the majority) came from things people thought weren't terribly important. Often things that most thought had no value at all. Or a massive case of "hmm, that's odd". Like Fleming noticing that bacteria were not growing near certain molds.
- Naritai 9y agoBecause there is a third category, 'exciting but not true', which is at high risk of distorting the decision making process and getting funding that is badly needed elsewhere (see, for example, Scott Kelley's DNA, anything to do with homeopathy, etc).
- onion2k 9y agoThe article is about funding the Large Hadron Collider. If someone was to suggest spending that amount on researching homeopathy I don't think they'd get very far.
- fourthark 9y agoYou could also choose to do experiments which teach you nothing at all, and I think that's the worry here.