3 ms·
While I do agree that you should be able to do experiments for experiment's sake, and to just "see what happens" so to speak, projects like the LHC and the fusi
by Cthulhu_ 9y ago
While I do agree that you should be able to do experiments for experiment's sake, and to just "see what happens" so to speak, projects like the LHC and the fusion reactor projects are all multi-billion projects; that's a lot of money to be spending on something where people don't know what to expect.
But yeah, experiments, especially nowadays, are to prove theories, not to push breakthroughs - in fact, given the higgs boson was already theorized, science could already use it. Not sure what the LHC added to that besides proving it exists.
- sandworm101 9y agoBecause building future science upon unverified discoveries is dangerous. Better to prove and measure the higs now rather than have some later and even more monumental experiment to discover a super-higs fail because the underlying theory was off by a few percentage points.
- wolfgke 9y ago> But yeah, experiments, especially nowadays, are to prove theories, not to push breakthroughs - in fact, given the higgs boson was already theorized, science could already use it. Not sure what the LHC added to that besides proving it exists. Theory verification is a very important part of physics. For example lots of people who work in string theory write down lots of crazy theories of how physics looks beyond the standard model. Perhaps they are all wrong, but we currenly have nothing better. So we would really love to have any currently experimentally viable way with which we were able to check these theories. Thanks to LHC we could do this at least for the Higgs boson. Before this experiment the Higgs boson was also "just a crazy theory that was able to resolve a hole in the standard model".
- gmueckl 9y agoThat proof of existence alone is what now holds up decades of work that was done by theorists based on the (then) assumption that the Higgs mechanism is real. The observation is a major puzzle piece in that picture. Without the experiment, all that theory would be worthless.
- kerkeslager 9y ago> While I do agree that you should be able to do experiments for experiment's sake, and to just "see what happens" so to speak, projects like the LHC and the fusion reactor projects are all multi-billion projects; that's a lot of money to be spending on something where people don't know what to expect. On the contrary, not knowing what to expect is exactly why you should spend money on it. If you know what to expect, there's no reason to spend billions of dollars testing what you already know.
- neolefty 9y agoI think the author's argument is that we pretty much know what to expect--a negative result--and all the people arguing otherwise can't give good reasons beyond "I want my funding to continue".