3 ms·
From the interview: Don’t come up with a view, find everybody who agrees with it, and then say, “Look at this, I must be right.” Start off by saying, “Who do I
by adolph 16y ago
From the interview: Don’t come up with a view, find everybody who agrees with it, and then say, “Look at this, I must be right.” Start off by saying, “Who do I trust?” On global warming, for example, I happen to trust climate experts, world academies of science, Nobel laureates, and certain science journalists. You have to decide who you trust before you decide what to believe.
It sounds like he is advocating a trust system based on titles, organization membership, etc. How is this different from trusting them based on authority?
- nanairo 16y agoWhat's wrong with that? I mean it's not like you get a noble prize by winning the lottery! You take random wacko on TV and noble laureate, each tells you their theory, and you (so far) don't know anything else. Who do you trust? Why? I think the title _does_ mean something: it was neither bestowed upon him randomly nor inherited by blood. Let me ask you another question: who do you think runs faster, a random guy I pick you see in the street, or a guy who won an olympic medal in athletic? Most people somehow feel winning an olympic medal is all about merit, but getting a Noble isn't!!!
- adolph 16y agoChill out. There is nothing in my comment to imply that there is anything wrong with title, or authority, or pink ponies. The author of the proceeding comment wrote "Trusting scientists because they use controlled experiment, peer review and other similar tools is quite a different thing than trusting them based on authority." The purpose of my comment is to say that the words attributed to Singh indicate trust based on authority indicated by title, membership, etc.
- nanairo 16y agoNo worries: I wasn't angry or shouting. Sorry for coming too strongly. :) I understand what you are saying, but my point is that those two are in science a lot closer than you seem to suggest. Titles (such as a noble prize) are won thanks to reputation gained from those experiments and peer reviews. If your karma system is based on what you published and that is subjected to peer review and scientific methodology, then your reputation (i.e. your karma) are a good hint that the person knows what they are talking about. In other words: trust scientist --> high authority --> gained by good experiments and subjected to peer review
- Tyrannosaurs 16y agoI agree that that sentence could give that impression but I think it's a little out of context. If you read Simon Singh's stuff (particularly Trick or Treatment, the book which lead to the article which lead to the libel case) it's really not what he advocates - he advocates having a robust evidence base for what you're saying. I think what he was trying to say in the sentence you quote is "I believe the overwhelming majority of the people who have looked at this subject, have a history of backing up their claims with robust, tested, reviewed evidence and are doing so in this instance".
- robryan 16y agoIt's a good way to filter out the crazy crackpot opinions, not to say these aren't of any value but when you don't have time to be an expert in a field you are much better off trusting those that have had their viewpoints put through rigorous peer review over those who haven't.
- praptak 16y agoThe titles, organization membership, scientific prizes are of course a kind of authority, but they are not assigned based on authority alone. It is a whole system built upon peer review, reproducible experiments, verifiable hypotheses and so on.