3 ms·
"Make enforcement of fines much more fast and certain, and you can solve speeding while lowering fines." If "solve" means legitimize it, yes, you've solved it.
by bryanlarsen 9y ago
"Make enforcement of fines much more fast and certain, and you can solve speeding while lowering fines."
If "solve" means legitimize it, yes, you've solved it.
Google for "daycare fine study" and notice that adding a small but significant fine to a behaviour you wish to discourage increased that behaviour rather than decreasing it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- cousin_it 9y agoThe fine shouldn't be that low. Here's the best formula I could figure out. Let's say R1 = actual risk of harm to yourself and others, M1 = magnitude of harm to yourself and others, R2 = your perceived risk of harm to yourself, M2 = magnitude of harm to yourself. Both M1 and M2 should be based on market price of QALY (about 50K dollars?) without overvaluing you specifically. Then the fine should be set at R1⋅M1-R2⋅M2. That's a generalization of Pigovian tax to a spectrum of behaviors: pollution (R1=R2, M1>M2), skipping medical checkups (R1>R2, M1=M2), speeding (R1>R2, M1>M2). Does that make sense?
- bryanlarsen 9y agoGiven that speeders more often harm themselves than others, your equation gives a negative answer.
- cousin_it 9y agoM1 includes harm to yourself.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]