3 ms·
Is it possible that smoking is bad for you, yet it most of the time doesn't cause cancer and that second-hand smoke risks are highly overrated? Also, if wheneve
by DanielBMarkham 16y ago
Is it possible that smoking is bad for you, yet it most of the time doesn't cause cancer and that second-hand smoke risks are highly overrated? Also, if whenever you take money from an outside source, the research is discredited, shouldn't we just stop taking any money from outside interest groups? It seems really silly to spend money researching X, if when you publish everybody comes out and says your research doesn't count because it was paid for by interest groups. And now it seems this is even enough to discredit the researcher himself.
I say that because it seems almost like an article of faith that smoking always causes cancer or that anything to do with smoking must be bad -- even being close to somebody that smokes. On the face of it, that seems a bit much. Or, put another way, it seems like popular opinion has gotten way ahead of reasonable discussion when it comes to smoking.
I drive through the city and see these huge multi-million-dollar office buildings. There's guys out back wearing thousand dollar suits, smoking cigarettes, in the rain, huddling next to the dumpster. Just seems like we've overreacted a bit. (Admittedly a gut feeling. And no, I am not a smoker and I do not like to be around people who do smoke, but that's a different topic)
- bbatsell 16y agoFor the record, I was in no way attempting to discredit this particular researcher (I'd be talking way above my level of knowledge in so attempting); I was just saying that the editorial seemed to be missing relevant information that seems like it might be significant for his colleagues and superiors.
- DanielBMarkham 16y agoNo problem. I think this story is very interesting. Just wish we had a better source to use for the discussion.