7 ms·
A source emailed me his life’s work. Then, he ended his life
- craftyguy 9y agoAnd allegedly the lives of his sons too. That's fucked up.
- tyingq 9y agoOy. Odd that's missing from the headline since it changes the context from "passionate" to "psychopath". The story seems balanced, but the headline is too generous.
- ewrwerewr3234 9y agoin a few decades we're going to look back on terms like "psychopath" with the same disgust we look back on victorian labels for notions of inherent racial criminality
- tyingq 9y agoIn a wider view, I agree. But I'm not feeling terrible about using the term for someone that offs their own children. In what context is that not some serious and notable mental disorder? Is "sociopath" somehow kinder?
- nitrogen 9y agoIt depends on whether the connotations of "evil" remain attached to the word, vs. "seriously dangerously malfunctioning".
- jeanvaljean2463 9y agoDepending on how much you twist the logic, there IS a semblance of an ideal of "doing them a favor and sparing them the evils of the world". Not defending, but to the truly hopeless it probably provides some weighting for the decision making.
- emodendroket 9y agoPsychopathy is a specific kind of mental illness and I don't think it's self-evident that anyone who would kill their children is a psychopath rather than afflicted with some other form of mental illness.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tyingq 9y agoI'm open to that. Just not any rationale that it was justified. Or that it excuses the headline wording.
- emodendroket 9y agoWho's saying it was "justified"?
- tyingq 9y agoWhoever decided the headline should say "ended his life" with no mention he murdered his children.
- telchar 9y agoI disagree completely. Psychopaths are as psychopaths do. If anything I expect we'll get better at diagnosing/detecting them and perhaps discovering sub-classes of them, of which perhaps some are problematic and some are not. We'll most likely continue to call the problematic ones psychopaths since we'll need a label to discuss people lacking in empathy who commit terrible crimes or make people's lives hell for fun and profit. Maybe some of the people we now call psychopaths will be called something else and redeemed in the popular imagination. But as long as the worst people we now call psychopaths continue to exist I think there will be no strong drive to retire or sanitize the word.
- cooper12 9y agoAhh yes, nothing more respectful or justified than smugly calling a deceased person who had mental health issues a "psychopath" while you barely knew anything about them or their personal issues.
- tyingq 9y agoYou have any kids? Maybe recognize that killing your own kids is hard to rationalize for people that do? I do get your point, but my comment wasn't flippant. I mulled on it a bit, and tried to put myself in his shoes. I didn't find much there. I'm honestly not trying to be smug. I have close relatives with issues like schizophrenia, manic depression, etc. So, I'm not completely uninformed. But there is a line where things aren't fixable.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jstarfish 9y agoFair enough, but reducing the sum of a man's life to a single word describing his final few minutes maybe isn't the best system of taxonomy. He was a father and a husband for far longer than he was a murderer.
- tyingq 9y agoThanks. I'm trying to not be HN typical and reach for hyperbole. I'll think on that.
- cooper12 9y agoI don't think rationality is the top priority for suicidal people. And I don't care how much you mulled on it or how many black friends you have so you can't possibly be racist—flippantly calling someone with mental health issues a "psychopath" betrays a huge lack of empathy and only serves to further stigmatize mental health conversation.
- 9y ago
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- paulcole 9y ago>And if nothing else, it should help to debunk the conspiracy theories that would inevitably pop up, he said. I think this is the exact opposite of how conspiracy theories work.
- cobbzilla 9y agoI have a really hard time understanding suicidal people who kill their kids -- what are they thinking? In the article the author mentions that Ruckman posted a loving video of one of his sons playing guitar about a year before the murders. wtf indeed.
- deweller 9y agoI don't pretend to understand the mindset of a suicide-murderer, but I'll make a guess. Perhaps they are in pain due to mental illness and want to end their life. The guilt of their children living without them is preventing them from moving ahead with their plan. By ending their children's life, it allows them to be free of that guilt and commits them to a course of action where they will end their own life.
- senectus1 9y agoThat why Depression and suicide is classified as a mental illness. These people are sick, their comprehension of themselves and the world around them is broken. The reason you dont understand why or how someone could do such heinous actions is that YOU'RE NOT broken.
- horribleonetime 9y agoHaving been there I can say the reason I considered killing them and my wife was to spare them the pain. Things would have been thrown into disarray if I had gone through with it and what a terrible life it'd leave them. It was only out of great love that I'd do that. I'm better now.
- in_cahoots 9y agoI’m not sure how I feel about this piece. The last paragraph is a quote from [edit: a friend of] the professor’s ex-wife asking us not to glorify him, and instead to honor the children he’s murdered. And yet the first half of the piece is all about the value of the professor’s work; the children’s names aren’t even mentioned until the very end. I understand that the author only knew the professor in the context of his work, but to me the tone of this piece seems to go exactly against the wife’s wishes. Others may disagree of course.
- jachee 9y ago> A close friend of Ruckman’s ex-wife — the boys’ mother — reached out to me with a plea. Awkwardly worded, but it wasn't the ex-wife that was quoted, but her friend.
- in_cahoots 9y agoThanks for the clarification, that makes this a bit less distasteful.
- SolarNet 9y agoMy thoughts exactly, this article seems to be glorifying a murderer. I had to stop myself halfway through and do a double take of how after he had glorified this man's accomplishments, he brings out the murder bit ("surely he's going to rip into him now") and then goes onto glorify him some more. The closing quote makes it all the worse.
- fellellor 9y agoI myself can't help but sympathize a bit with the writer. Mainly because just like the writer, I don't really know what exactly happened here. This scholar, from their perspective seemed like a well adjusted individual doing good work, who suddenly decided to do this horrific thing. I can understand it's not really that easy to make up one's mind here.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoThis seems so odd. There isn't any information suggesting a history of mental health issues and the only personal drama seems to be a not dramatic sounding divorce.
- Erlangolem 9y agoFor a certain kind of person, it’s not the drama, but the loss of control or possession, or sense of failure. In the context of divorce, and a particularly sick personality, killing children is a way to maximally harm the mother. People can be very odd.
- nvahalik 9y agoWhoa. So I knew the name Peter Ruckman sounded familiar... this guy was the son of Peter Sturges Ruckman who founded the Pensacola Bible Baptist Institute and held some very hard line (and controversial) cult-like views about the Bible. Specifically he held that the King James Version was very special and let’s just say that he had many followers and that they are especially tough cats to deal with. That might provide some additional context...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- meko 9y ago30,000 presidential pardons and commutations??? How typical is that of a presidency? that sounds totally unheard of to me. A cursory glance on the internet suggests this is an order of magnitude above the sum of all other presidential pardons combined... I gather that these are all likely hucksters and whitecollar fraudsters. I wonder what legacy 45 will have on the United States.
- vit05 9y agoA source emailed me his life’s work. Then, he ended his life A pardon expert emailed me his life's work. Then he killed his two sons and himself. I'm not from USA. I had no idea about this story. When I started reading the article, I started with a feeling of sadness. It always makes me sad to know that someone was facing a problem so great that only saw end their own life as the only solution If I had started reading the second title, from USA Today, I would have started with the idea that it was the last moments of a monster. And a feeling of anger instead of sadness. It's unbelievable how titles, and photos, can mess with the way you'll face a story you're just beginning to read.