4 ms·
I certainly think a much better defense of "real" books can (and perhaps should) be made. I was a bit disappointed to notice that this article didn't mention w
by otakucode 9y ago
I certainly think a much better defense of "real" books can (and perhaps should) be made. I was a bit disappointed to notice that this article didn't mention what I personally find an important difference: You own a book. You can never own an ebook. They're not for sale. The best you can ever do is throw some money in the direction of a publisher and wish really hard that they honor the utterly non-binding vapid 'license agreement' which extends literally no rights to you as a consumer and places literally no obligation on them as a seller.
Sure eventually the courts will step in and declare digital property to be as real as any other form of property, and we'll see actual ownership rights return... but that might take a long time. Until then, you can give a book to a friend either as a loan or a present. You can buy used books. You can sell your books. You can always pick them up and read them. With ebooks, you cannot sell or even give them away. You can't loan them. You can't even be assured that you'll be able to pick them up and read them. You "agreed" to license that can be revoked at any time for any or no reason.
Ebooks are a vague wish and an act of faith in the publishers and nothing more. Someone will eventually push it too far. And only then will consumer rights be restored by the courts, but that could take ages and isn't even guaranteed. Sure that's the way it worked with every single other industry that has tried this exactly identical "licenses not ownership" game, but things change...
- kwhitefoot 9y agoOf course you can 'own' an ebook. Unfortunately this means that you often have to commit an act of 'piracy' by defeating the DRM to extract the file from your reader. As for the courts stepping in, be careful what you wish for because the only way to have 'owning' an ebook work the same way as owning a physical book is for there to be unbreakable DRM and/or draconian penalties for breaking it together with a register of who has the right to read it at any given moment and a list of legally allowed devices that it can be read on. No thanks.
- otakucode 9y agoI don't understand how you make that leap. Physical books can be copied or stolen. We are still allowed to own and buy and sell them without any unbreakable system to track their ownership, or a register of who has the right to read the book at any given time, or anything of the sort.
- kwhitefoot 9y agoOwnership in that sense is contingent on there being a physical object that is expensive to reproduce. The only way of mimicking that for ebooks is DRM.