12 ms·
Long Live Mister Rogers' Quiet Revolution
- madengr 9y agoMr. Rogers was nice and calming. So were the early Sesame Streets. Now children’s shows are hyper and frantic, refining that 3 second attention span. There is a congressional testimony video in that link. He was still nice and calming speaking to an asshat politician. He is like a kid’s Carl Sagan. If you need to de-stress, bring up Mr. Rogers.
- jjeaff 9y agoI completely agree. I can't stand the hyperactive, high pitched activity and voices in most kids shows now. I wonder how much effect it has on behaviour.
- gadders 9y agoHe always reminded me of the James Stewart character in Harvey: Years ago my mother used to say to me, she'd say, "In this world, Elwood, you must be" – she always called me Elwood – "In this world, Elwood, you must be oh so smart or oh so pleasant." Well, for years I was smart. I recommend pleasant. You may quote me.
- dsr_ 9y agoSesame Street took a few years to figure out what they wanted to be, though: http://theweek.com/articles/454359/10-classic-sesame-street-moments-wouldnt-show-todays-kids http://theweek.com/articles/454359/10-classic-sesame-street-... I think the best years were 1973 through 1994 or so, but that's very subjective.
- beenBoutIT 9y agoSesame Street's best years are definitely behind it.
- peatmoss 9y agoSesame Street is like a fossil record or tree cross section for attention span in television. Some of the older Sesame Street clips like the one about milk, are trippy long format art pieces. Very very different than the quick cuts / short segments that happen today. Whether that’s good or bad is up to you. I suspect the old style simply wouldn’t compete for viewers today. A bonus: Stevie Wonder playing Superstition on Sesame Street might be my favorite “music video” of all time. https://youtu.be/_ul7X5js1vE https://youtu.be/_ul7X5js1vE
- AdmiralAsshat 9y agoHere's a recurring segment about counting, with vocals by Grace Slick no less: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-WSHvbGM6oE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-WSHvbGM6oE
- jpm_sd 9y agoThe new animated show "Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood" is a rare example of a successor that is true to the spirit of the original. My kids love it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniel_Tiger%27s_Neighborhood https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniel_Tiger%27s_Neighborhood
- faitswulff 9y agoI think it does miss out on some aspects of Mr. Rogers's humanity, though. I think it's harder to learn from abstract characters.
- ghostbrainalpha 9y agoThe show isn't entirely animated. Each show intersperses live action cuts, although with rotating characters relevant to the episode, not a star character like Mr. Rogers. But too be honest...these parts are terrible. It's what inspired by 2.5 yr old to learn how to use the fast forward button on the remote control.
- classichasclass 9y agoI agree. There's a lot to be said for a kindly human figure explaining these (to a child) weighty topics. An anthropomorphic tiger seems to undercut the message. (Mind you, this is not intended to be a heavy slam on the show, which in my limited experience is head and shoulders above what passes for children's TV now.)
- hexane360 9y agoI think most of PBS's offerings are all really good on this front.
- ssharp 9y agoWe've been able to work through issues where a related Daniel Tiger episode helped. A few months ago, one of them was having difficulty with us leaving them with a babysitter and we put the episode about Daniel being left with a babysitter on, talked about it, and it really made an impact. I think it's helped much more so than other PBS shows, but that might be because they're at the right age to be able to relate to some of the content.
- mfer 9y agoI have to admit that I have trouble following stories with holes in basic details. Conclusions drawn or stitched together end up missing something or being wrong. Early on the story notes: > the former Presbyterian minister Except his biography notes: > He graduated from the Seminary and was ordained as a Presbyterian minister in 1963 with a charge to continue his work with children and families through the mass media. https://www.fredrogers.org/fred-rogers/bio/ https://www.fredrogers.org/fred-rogers/bio/ When telling the story of someone it's important to get core characteristics right (or try to). His belief and faith, no matter how any of us feel about it, was part of that.
- kajecounterhack 9y ago1. Article was not a biography but a rumination over the values and impact of his show (with historical commentary). 2. "Former minister" refers to an occupation. It's accurate.
- dpeck 9y agoon 2 I think you're slightly off though it may be coming down to semantics. His ministry was in the media with a focus on children and families so it was in no way former. To my understanding that "charge" was given as part of ordination after he was into his professional career and throughout it he remained an ordained minister within the presbyterian church.
- hprotagonist 9y agoYou don't become un-ordained, generally, unless you do something Extraordinarily Naughty. "He ceased to serve in parish ministry" would be a better phrasing.
- dpeck 9y agoThat’s the thing, he never was a parish minister
- classichasclass 9y agoI grew up on Mr. Rogers' Neighborhood; it was still in production when I was a child. I still occasionally hear criticism of the show as being unrealistic, that it papered over things or was shallow or ungrounded. As if children's perception, compared to adults, is particularly realistic, deep or stable! What adult worries about going down the drain after a bath? Who understands the deep, existential angst a child feels looking over the precipice as the two most important people in their lives "suddenly" aren't together anymore? Rogers' genius was to take what was meaningful to a child and speak frankly about that. He never belittled those anxieties; he merely explained them and what they could do. And if there wasn't anything they could actually do, he could at least convince them the world would not end. The show represented an idealism that you just don't see anymore. I was too young to have seen the episodes first-run where black community members were simply introduced, without fanfare, but that's exactly how he would have done it. Of course black people live in our city. Lots of people live in our city. They're just like you and me. They have the same jobs and live in the same houses because why shouldn't they? It wasn't polarized or political, it wasn't beating people over the head for not believing what he believed. It was simply matter-of-fact. When he did the Emmys in 1997, you saw that idealism in practice. Of course there are special people in your lives who brought you to where you are today. Why wouldn't you honour them? And people obeyed, for he was right. (If you don't know this story, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fred_Rogers#Emmys_for_programming https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fred_Rogers#Emmys_for_programm... .) I have a DVD of some of the episodes with a little toy cardigan wrapped around them. I was quite upset when he passed away, even with a graduate degree by then. As a moral authority, there couldn't have been one much better in the United States.
- neaden 9y agoI agree. In terms of being unrealistic I think it is important that we have to be able to picture a better world if we are going to obtain it. You want kids to know that certain things don't have to be the way they are, that the world can be a different place.
- gerbilly 9y agoExactly. Another notable show that tried to represent the future 'as it should be' was Star Trek. It had a Russian and a black woman as officers an 'alien' as 2nd in command etc...
- hprotagonist 9y agoBesides the senate testimony linked in this article, my favorite Mr. Rogers fact is this: He would help move freshman into CMU and Pitt dorms every year, because he lived only a few miles away and he wanted to welcome them to his actual neighborhood. How cool would it have been to look up from figuring out where to put your bag of clothes to see Fred Rogers holding a box of your books...
- overcast 9y agoI would have died right there. He impacted the lives of so many children, that it was a guarantee many of them grew up watching him.
- davidrupp 9y agoNot quite as cool, but I got to meet David Newell ("Mr. McFeely") at an appearance when I was a student at the University of Florida; got his autograph for my Mister-Rogers-age baby sister. Dude was every bit as gracious as he and Mister Rogers appeared to be on television. They don't hardly make 'em any more.
- overcast 9y agoSpeedy Delivery!
- mcgrath_sh 9y agoThis story [1] from Anthony Breznican stuck with me after he shared it on twitter. I firmly believe that the actions Mister Rodgers took would come across as insincere and self-serving if it were basically any other “celebrity”. However, that was the power of Mister Rodgers. He could connect with anyone and made everyone feel like they genuinely mattered to him. I grew up in Pittsburgh and was in a Catholic Grade School when he died. We held a special memorial mass for him because of the impact he had on both our city and kids generally. I can’t think of anyone else that would be done for, not even Dan Rooney or Mario Lemieux. Mister Rodgers was one of a kind. [1] https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation-now/2017/05/23/mr-rogers-story-probably-make-you-cry/340111001/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation-now/2017/05/23/mr...
- bitwize 9y agoWere he a Catholic, Fred Rogers would have by this point been beatified if not fully canonized. Few people within living memory exemplified the values Christianity purports to teach as thoroughly as he. If his approach was unrealistic, it was supposed to be. He applied a sort of extreme version of the Kantian categorical imperative: always acting as if he were at the same time willing that the real world be as peaceful, gentle, and tolerant as the Neighborhood of Make-Believe.
- ECrownofFire 9y agoHe was actually a Presbyterian minister, and the mission that the church gave him was to do his show. He approached everything in a way that was incredibly kind and caring for everyone, without being preachy in the slightest. He was even part of an LGBT outreach program at his local church! I'm not Christian (though I did grow up with a very religious mom and nana) nor am I a particularly religious woman, but I'm sure Fred Rogers would be chilling with the most holy people up in heaven lol. Like I honestly think that he was one of the most "Christ-like" people in a long time.
- troymc 9y agoMister Rogers' Neighborhood first aired in 1968. Star Trek (the original series) first aired two years later and it's often cited as "the first" for many things. But... Mr. Rogers often did it first. He really was a pioneer.
- Jtsummers 9y agoStar Trek debuted in 1966, not 1970.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoObligatory XKCD: https://xkcd.com/767/ https://xkcd.com/767/ Be sure to read the alt-text.
- exolymph 9y agoWhen I feel sad and frustrated, I watch the melodysheep remix of Mr. Rogers: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OFzXaFbxDcM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OFzXaFbxDcM Definitely read the Esquire profile of him: https://www.esquire.com/entertainment/tv/a27134/can-you-say-hero-esq1198/ https://www.esquire.com/entertainment/tv/a27134/can-you-say-... Honestly, I recommend reading everything you possibly can about Mr. Rogers. I never watched his show as a kid, but I still idolize him. Stories of his life and doings are good for the heart.
- dwighttk 9y agoI recently listened to the audiobook of The Simple Faith of Mr. Rogers. It's good: https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/the-simple-faith-of-mister-rogers-amy-hollingsworth/1111012865#/ https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/the-simple-faith-of-mister-...
- fixermark 9y agoI moved to Pittsburgh for school, and became interested in the 'mythology' that had grown up around Fred Rogers. In particular, there's an anecdote that gets shared around that his car once got stolen, but it ended up parked back in the spot a few days later with a note on the dash that said "If I'd known whose it was, I wouldn't have taken it!" As best I can tell, that one's just an urban legend. But what I discovered most surprisingly poring over the newspaper clippings and books is that almost everything else I'd heard isn't. Of every childhood hero I had, Fred Rogers is the only one who turned out to be exactly who that child thought he was. And more than that: his work was driven from both his education in theology as a Presbyterian minister and his tutelage under Dr. Margaret McFarland, child psychologist and associate professor at University of Pittsburgh. His show's content and structure was grounded in those philosophical and scientific foundations. My favorite anecdote I can source (http://www.neighborhoodarchive.com/misc/mr_rodney/index.html http://www.neighborhoodarchive.com/misc/mr_rodney/index.html): Burger King ran an ad campaign for a bit in '84 that featured a 'Mr Rodney' parody taking shots at McDonald's for inferior quality. Fred Rogers contacted Burger King's SVP, Don Dempsey, and simply asked the ad be pulled, because he was concerned it'd be confusing to children. BK yanked the ad. As news sources quoted Mr. Dempsey, "Mister Rogers is one guy you don't want to mess with."
- majos 9y ago> Of every childhood hero I had, Fred Rogers is the only one who turned out to be exactly who that child thought he was. Same. I like to think I'm not so wrapped up in the characters of celebrities, but a scandal around Mr. Rogers would be a serious bummer.
- artur_makly 9y agoI grew up with MrR. However when I try to show it to my 5yr old, he can only sit through the factory-on-site visits ( which are very cool ) the rest he doesnt have the patience for as those interactions can't compare to all the hyper activity of NetFlix Kid's shows. He prefers to watch a marathon of Power Rangers kicking ass all day long. Is there a moder-day Mr. Rogers out there ?? If not someone please invent him.
- hateful 9y agoI grew up with him also, but Mr. Rogers isn't something we'd put on and sit and watch and do nothing else. It's something that's on while you're playing with other things. For example, building a Lego castle while the TV is on. The non-factory scenes are more about listening and occasionally looking up rather than staring at. At least that's my experience. Years ago we'd leave on the TV in the background and watch sparingly sometimes. But now, my TV is always on-demand and if I'm not watching a series or movie, I'm on my computer in the other room.
- kolpa 9y agoA big part of Mr. Rogers appeal was back in the pre-Internet less-connected world, he and his cast were people you could see and who talked to you when you were home alone.
- Spooky23 9y agoDaniel Tiger is a sort of modern cartoon spin of the Mr Rogers universe.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- derptron 9y agoThats pretty sad and telling about youth these days. Rabid 12 year olds playing Fortnite.
- jstarfish 9y agoWorth noting is that in the spectrum and history of children's programming, MRN is the only show that didn't use jump cuts (for the in-house scenes, at least, I don't remember the external stuff). The camera just pans and fades, and there's never those jarring transitions from one shot to the next. Rogers' personality aside, even the presentation of the show itself was meant to be gentle.
- pc2g4d 9y agoI literally lived in Mr. Rogers' Neighborhood. As a Mormon missionary I lived in Latrobe, PA in a house just neighboring a house Fred Rogers had lived in growing up. Latrobe was a quaint town with the sort of mailman and library and cute little streets that I remembered from "Mr. Rogers' Neighborhood". It was a well-ordered place in many ways (though obviously with its own intrigues and local politics---people are people.) But I could see that the show in many ways portrayed a not-that-idealized version of a real place. To those who call it "unrealistic" I say that there actually are lovely places and people in this world, and especially in the eyes of a compassionate and loving person like Fred Rogers we can make our communities and countries better and more beautiful. I was living in Latrobe at the time of Rogers' death. We attended a memorial service his Latrobe connections held in his honor, and the esteem he was held in there was substantial. The article is a good reminder of the power of a positive vision and of consistency and compassion to make islands of love in this divisive human existence. A very timely message indeed.
- harleypig 9y agoI served in the Pitt Mission from 89-91. He had the missionaries for dinner every few months. I had the honor of being one of those missionaries, though at the time I thought he was condescending. I've come to realize he was, but not the negative kind. He was a genuinely kind and compassionate man. The only thing I remember about that dinner was his opinion on our missionary service, which was that even though we were misguided, our hearts were good and God counted that. He sincerely prayed for our success as well as our conversion. I left a very humbled young man.
- 8bitsrule 9y agoErrata: that should read: WQED and 'The Children's Corner'. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0250142/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0250142/ ... the show for which Rogers created many of the later famous characters. In between (beginning in 1961) he did over over 300 'MisteRogers' shows for CBC.
- aklemm 9y agoI think of Mister Rogers as a towering moral authority; he is basically my Jesus. That said, the entirety of his goodness is boiled down to his simple commitment to taking others exactly as they are. It seems simple, but it's magic.