3 ms·
> leading to centralization Repeating this propaganda over and over and over doesn't make it true. No centralization will occur with an increase in block size
by colordrops 9y ago
> leading to centralization
Repeating this propaganda over and over and over doesn't make it true.
No centralization will occur with an increase in block size, as there will still be enough participants to prevent attacking the block chain.
If what is meant by centralization is the reduction of people who can run nodes, then keeping the block size small also increases centralization by this definition, as there is a reduction in people who can afford to transact on the main chain.
But when it comes to maintaining the core trustless network inherent in the bit coin algorithm, increasing block size does nothing to break its function.
Stop with the propaganda.
- eklitzke 9y agoI guess that's true based on your definition of "trustless". But I wouldn't consider a network where as a practical matter I have to rely on a small number of centralized servers for validation "trustless".
- __blockcipher__ 9y agolol, with lightning you have to rely on a small number of centralized payment hubs who will likely be strongarmed by the government into keeping tabs on transactions through KYC/AML laws. It completely breaks the fundamental and original usecase of bitcoin: peer to peer electronic cash. Now it's "first world speculator to first world speculator through intermediary financial institution electronic store-of-value". Doesn't roll of the tongue quite so well, does it? IMO, XMR and BCH are the current best options for transactions. BTC is being destroyed by people who hadn't even heard of it 5 years ago.
- hahainternet 9y ago> lol, with lightning you have to rely on a small number of centralized payment hubs There is no requirement for this. This is FUD.
- topranks 9y agoThat is true. I guess my definition is as long as new players / players with different motives and agendas can join the fray, it is ok. So like I don't mind if we end up that you need at least $1million to become a miner, hell we are half way there anyway on both chains, I just mind if nobody can join, or if it goes to $1billion to be able to mine. LN seems like the ultimate in centralisation so as an alternative (while it might work,) it's a far inferior solution on that score.
- colordrops 9y agoThat's just unfounded vague fear though. Do you have a concrete concern, or a specific technical scenario where having less mining nodes is a real problem?
- softawre 9y agoHow does reducing the number of people who can transact involve centralization? Aren't we discussing centralization of the mining/network power?
- colordrops 9y agoMy point is that neither reducing the people who can transact nor who can mine have any effect that can be called "centralization". It's propaganda. Centralization implies a single point of control. Having less people be able to transact or mine doesn't change the fundamental properties of bitcoin and "centralize" it. Centralization is not a gradient.