3 ms·
If I'm being blunt, its our own fault. We encourage people to upload and share content they don't own under the guise of "information wants to be free". We en
by falcolas 9y ago
If I'm being blunt, its our own fault.
We encourage people to upload and share content they don't own under the guise of "information wants to be free".
We encourage the transformation of employees into contractors and operate in locations where the business is explicitly against the law, because "disrupt all the things".
We work behind the scenes with our competitors to suppress worker wages, fix prices, and avoid taxes, because profit is more important than anything else.
We do ICOs with imaginary money or IPOs with only private shares to get around the SEC and little nuisances like public disclosure.
WTF did we expect to have happen? The government is a slow elephant to SV's sleek mouse, but when we don't run fast enough we're going to be completely flattened. This isn't new behavior on the part of the government - it's not like we can claim ignorance.
- kodablah 9y agoYou shouldn't blame deluge of new laws on the users. It's kinda like victim blaming as though they made the laws themselves. Instead of asking "what caused governments to make new regulations" instead ask "what caused governments to use regulations instead of alternatives (including doing nothing)". You point out problems, but that's not fair to say that they caused the specific solutions more than the solution presenters themselves.
- falcolas 9y agoI'm not blaming the users, I'm blaming the entrepreneurs. Sorry if that wasn't clear. > what caused governments to use regulations instead of alternatives (including doing nothing) It's the same as it always has been - why are any rules made up? Because someone cheats. Why do rulebooks get bigger and bigger and not smaller and smaller? Because someone sees the rule "do not steal", and threatens the victim into "giving" him the stuff, cause "it's not stealing if he gives it to me, right?" Now you need rules about coercion. More directly, people flouting the spirit of the law is the cause of this legislation. People ignoring the verbal and written warnings put out there by governments to play nice. Ultimately, the government has two forces of authority. The law (regulation) and force (police, army, etc). The first is empowered by the second. If the warning signs leading up to regulation are ignored, what else can we expect the government to do?
- kodablah 9y agoOn the internet, I consider entrepreneurs users as well. Just because the rulebooks do grow doesn't mean they should. That the law is ignored should be a reason for enforcement, not law creation. As law counts grow and percentage of enforcement seemingly declines you should expect users to ignore them. I expect governments to give warnings about enforcement, not just creating laws as though all other solutions have been tried. It should be the absolute last resort, but so many of these are perceived problems not really harming anyone.
- CaptSpify 9y ago> We encourage people to upload and share content they don't own under the guise of "information wants to be free". I would say it's the opposite problem: We pretend that publicly accessible information can be owned.
- falcolas 9y agoWe've been "pretending" that since well before any of us were alive. This is not something new or novel. Hell, we've been "pretending" it long enough that the concept of ownership of ideas is included in the US constitution. Know what else we "pretend"? That someone bigger than you can't just come along and take your lunch. We as a society agree to "pretend" that the lunch is yours, and that someone who does take it from you should be punished. I think we're well past the point where we're "pretending".
- CaptSpify 9y agoI don't understand your argument. Just because we've been doing things ass-backwards for a long time, means we should just keep doing it, and trying to patch reality to adjust? > That someone bigger than you can't just come along and take your lunch. No we don't, and I don't think we ever have. In fact, we openly admit that someone can come and take your lunch. What we do is say that, while someone can come and take your lunch, that person also has an incentive to avoid punishment.
- falcolas 9y ago> Just because we've been doing things ass-backwards for a long time, means we should just keep doing it, and trying to patch reality to adjust? Or perhaps not everybody agrees with you on the point that all information wants to be free. I, for example, don't agree. I'm quite happy that you can't legally take a photo I create and use it for your own gain. As to the other point, replace 'can't' with 'shouldn't'. Sorry.
- emh68 9y agoWay to twist what “information wants to be free” means. Since when is copyrighted entertainment “information”? The phrase is obviously about real information, which is an innate fact about the universe which can’t be copyrighted. Like 09F9 et al
- nybble41 9y agoThe sequence of letters which make up a certain book is "an innate fact about the universe". A detailed description of a picture (or sequence of pictures, i.e. a video), or an audio waveform, is no different. Information remains information even if the subject is copyrighted. Copyright enforcement in practice consists almost entirely in controlling the distribution of factual information about copyrighted works.
- emh68 9y agoThe sequence of letters which makes up the book is an innate fact about itself. Although we’re in philosophy territory now and that usually goes nowhere.