2 ms·
Does anybody do any fact checking anymore? The claim is that the 1950's and 1960's success was due to a immigration system that "welcomed promising minds from
by refurb 9y ago
Does anybody do any fact checking anymore? The claim is that the 1950's and 1960's success was due to a immigration system that "welcomed promising minds from every corner of the planet".
Bullshit.
Look at the percentage of Americans who were immigrants in the 1950-60's - 5-6%. What is it now? 12-14%?[1]
So in fact, there are more immigrants in the US than back in the utopia of the '50-60's.
Once again, a nice theory, but absolutely false.
[1]https://www.capsweb.org/todays-news/record-51-million-immigrants-8-years-will-account-82-us-growth https://www.capsweb.org/todays-news/record-51-million-immigr...
- graeme 9y agoYou actually didn’t address the theory. The claim was about welcoming “promising minds”. Presumably that means top acientists, engineers, etc The current systme in America is renowned for being very difficult to get in to on a merit basis. Was this different in the 1950s? Perhaps. Also note thatbwhen considering america in the 1950’s, you’d need to look at immigration levels in prior decades. There’s a lag time for kids to grow up. I don’t know if the theory is right or not. And you,ve certainly provided some data to show it *mayg be wrong. But it’s far from conclusive.
- refurb 9y agoI would point you towards the "Immigration Act of 1990", which created a number of ways for highly skilled workers to immigrate to the US. Before that, a lot of the US immigration was based on family reunification.
- shadowtree 9y agoPercentages work in all kinds of directions: https://www.migrationpolicy.org/programs/data-hub/charts/immigrant-population-over-time?width=1000&height=850&iframe=true https://www.migrationpolicy.org/programs/data-hub/charts/imm... Qualified immigration vs. illegal vs. unqualified would be a very separate discussion. The claim is worded correctly though, even from your viewpoint, no? "welcomed promising minds" vs. indiscriminate immigration and its current backlash that hits "promising minds".