3 ms·
The average voter isn't going to read the bill text for most legislation, never mind thousands of pages of internet arguments with those best at brigading or as
by notahacker 9y ago
The average voter isn't going to read the bill text for most legislation, never mind thousands of pages of internet arguments with those best at brigading or astroturfing (often well-funded lobbyist concerns) at the top.
The draft text is going to be written by the same politician speaking to the same lobbyists adopting the same strategy of tying it to something really desirable like preventing crime or promoting financial freedom, it's just that members of the public supporting crime prevention or financial freedom don't have the opportunity to broker an alternative wording, and once they've voted for it any objections to its provisions is going to be met with the full rhetorical force of accusations of defying "the will of the people". And people not in the pocket of the lobbyists who support parts of the policy for other reasons aren't going to muddy the waters and risk a public defeat for their ideals by arguing to fix the dodgy earmark if it's a big public vote rather than a series of rapid votes on amendments. It might work for vetoing stuff the public really didn't expect and really do care a lot about like tax rises, but in practice, referenda significantly lower the tone of debate, increase partisanship and decrease the effect policy detail has on the outcome of the decision.
- crdoconnor 9y ago>The average voter isn't going to read the bill text for most legislation, never mind thousands of pages of internet arguments That's exactly why I described how you could build a system that accounts for that. >thousands of pages of internet arguments with those best at brigading or astroturfing Brigading on a platform for direct democracy is a feature, not a bug. Astroturfing and most other forms of uncivil discourse can be pretty much eliminated by tying your account to your identity and with a few fairly basic moderation rules.