3 ms·
I would argue that Hacker News does support hashtags, just not officially, and not user-defined: Ask HN -> #ask Show HN -> #show Tell HN -> #tell
by krapp 9y ago
I would argue that Hacker News does support hashtags, just not officially, and not user-defined:
Ask HN -> #ask
Show HN -> #show
Tell HN -> #tell
Launch HN -> #launch
Who's hiring -> #hiring
Comments here seem to assume that hashtags would have to be implemented exactly as they are on Twitter, where anyone can tag their comments with any tags, which wind up appended to the text of the comment itself.
Obviously, that wouldn't work with HN's culture, but those are implementation details, not requirements. And as far as search goes, the purpose of hashtags (when used properly) is to basically make searches more efficient by providing a set of common keywords directly related to the context of a comment.
Hashtags could be added to Hacker News without much disruption - lobste.rs uses them and I don't think anyone would accuse that site of having descended into lulzy random chaos as a result of them. It's just a matter of having the implementation fit the culture.
The ability to add tags, like the ability to flag or vouch, could be conditional, based on karma and revocable if abused. Tags could begin in a hidden state similar to dead comments, needing to be vouched by the community and to pass a certain threshold of votes to become visible. Tags could only apply to threads (not comments) and could be limited to, perhaps two tags for a thread.
Also, tags could be hidden by the user if desired (this should probably be the default.)
It is possible to enhance user experience without degrading the quality of the site, or being intrusive. The list of new features people assumed would destroy HN, but haven't, includes thread folding, show HN, mobile styles, vouching for dead comments, and even fixing a bug that would cause comment links not to work after a few minutes.