3 ms·
> Is it not always the case? We vote for a goal a leave the experts to implement it. No, lawmaking in a representative democracy consists of the wording of a b
by notahacker 9y ago
> Is it not always the case? We vote for a goal a leave the experts to implement it.
No, lawmaking in a representative democracy consists of the wording of a bill being amended as many times as necessary to secure agreement from a majority of representatives - all able to propose amendments themselves - and then being put to the vote before becoming law. This is also the case for some policies put to referenda: the AV referendum was one where the referendum was on a previously agreed text to become law, with no further legislative change implied.
And what is being objected to here is not the government attempting to implement the result, it is the government proposing a raft of policy objectives loosely related to some interpretations of the result and trying to curtail further debate and votes over them.
If, as you say, part of the result is because people wished to express their discomfort with the feeling of being in an oligarchy, it is even less attractive a method of decision making to assume that the executive's interpretation of the vote must prevail and that criticisms of it from those who voted the other way lack any legitimacy.