4 ms·
Really? The only time I'd have taken the additional weight is when I was playing rugby, and then mostly because I couldn't really afford much food. I was 20, 6
by nl 16y ago
Really?
The only time I'd have taken the additional weight is when I was playing rugby, and then mostly because I couldn't really afford much food. I was 20, 65kg and worked really hard to try and get to 70kg. Being hit hurt when I was that light (ok, it hurt at 70kg too, but at least then the other guy noticed me when he ran over me)
I think anyone into endurance sports would take the weight loss too (based on the running & cycling I've done).
- gaius 16y agoThe point I was making along the lines of, just because a heavy drinker might be quite slender, it doesn't imply that they're healthy. They've lost their muscle mass along with their fat. PS I am a Marathon runner and I'd take the muscle... And have you seen the quads on a serious cyclist?
- Retric 16y agoCyclist's and Marathoners have significantly different needs. A Cyclist is primarily limited by wind resistance and their ability to absorb oxygen, but they do not need to carry their own weight. A Marathoner has far less wind drag, and is mostly limited by their need to store energy and avoid injury both of which are hampered when they carry more weight.
- gaius 16y agoOn the contrary, we do need strength - without it your form will go to pieces as soon as you tire and your gait will become much less efficient, and increase your risk of injury. 10lbs of muscle on your back, core and hips could make a massive difference. Obviously a Marathon runner wouldn't be interested in adding 100lbs of muscle the way a bodybuilder would.
- Retric 16y agoI agree that core strenght tends to be undervalued, but you will not see a top marathoner with a leg that is quite this size: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Fabian_Cancellara_-_Tour_Of_California_Prologue_2008_(1).jpg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Fabian_Cancellara_-_Tour_O... Form, effecency, and power are important for both sports. However, cyclists focus more on power output.
- jdietrich 16y agoIt should be noted that at 80kg, Fabian Cancellara is considered much too heavy to ever win a grand tour. He is spectacularly fast on the flat because he is only slightly less aerodynamic than a much smaller and less powerful man, but he is quickly overpowered on a mountain stage by lighter riders.
- Retric 16y agoYou are correct that different courses favor different body styles, but comparing someone like Paula Radcliffe (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Paula_Brooklyn_NYCM_2007_cropped.jpg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Paula_Brooklyn_NYCM_2007_c...) with a top cyclist shows max power is less important in distance running. Relative to the average American they do have similar thin and muscular body types. And, I think it's easy to underestimate how strong these people are because they have so much less fat than the average person. But, as you say the relative cost of drag for increased body size helps support a more bulky cyclist.
- jules 16y agoJust FYI Paula Radcliffe weighs 54 kg the cyclist Leonardo Piepoli who is a man and the same height as Radcliffe weighs 52 kg. I do think that cyclists are on average heavier than marathon runners, but the top climber cyclists are not. The advantage Cancellara has on flat terrain is much smaller than the advantage a climber has in the mountains. In my personal experience with cycling and running I'd say that carrying 1kg of fat running is a smaller disadvantage than carrying 1kg of fat cycling in mountain terrain. This is reversed when you consider cycling on flat terrain.
- jules 16y agoA light cyclist has a huge advantage in non-flat terrain. He needs strong legs and light everything else. A runner needs core and back muscles to run in a way that does not waste a lot of energy and prevents injuries. In my experience running is harder on your entire body, cycling just on legs and lungs.
- nl 16y agoPS I am a Marathon runner and I'd take the muscle... And have you seen the quads on a serious cyclist? Quads, yes, but have you seen the rest of the body? WRT runnimg, generally speaking (elite) marathon runners have much higher ratios of slow-twitch muscle than average. That means they will have lean bodies, without the peak strength or muscle mass of a fast-twitch heavy athlete like a sprinter. Take a look at http://www.letsrun.com/2010/heightweight0504.php http://www.letsrun.com/2010/heightweight0504.php. The entire running world was shocked when Solinsky broke 27 minutes (for a 10 km). He's 6'1", and 160lbs - obviously still what most people would consider skinny, but way, way heavy compared to most distance runners. (You might have good reasons to want more muscle - I'm just pointing out that it's unusual for a distance athlete)
- jules 16y agoI'm into running & cycling and I'd definitely take the muscles. Why exactly makes you think that an endurance sporter would take the weight loss?
- nl 16y agoWell, most cyclists (except for track sprinters) aim to be as light as possible. Thus, at the elite level, one expects superior performance from smaller athletes in aerobic events where power requirements are approximately proportional to body mass--such as distance running and uphill cycling. (Technically, the power requirement scales more closely to mass, i.e. M0.76-M0.79 than does the power supply, M0.67; Swain, 1994). It is not surprising that the pre-eminent climber of the 1990s, Marco Pantani, is one of the smallest men in the peloton at only 55 kg. Anything that can be done to reduce the weight of a cyclist and bicycle, without compromising the cyclist's aerobic power, will improve hill-climbing performance. http://www.sportsci.org/jour/9804/dps.html http://www.sportsci.org/jour/9804/dps.html
- jules 16y agoYep, but most of us are nowhere near that level where we have so much that more muscle is a disadvantage ;) I guess it's highly dependent on how you currently are. Someone who does weightlifting in a gym could probably indeed improve his cycling performance just by removing muscle. And of course sports performance is not the only criterion for choosing +5lbs muscle vs -5lbs fat ;)