6 ms·
> It could be that the results were built into the model’s design. Every true mathematical proposition is a tautology. I don't find this point particularly con
by naasking 9y ago
> It could be that the results were built into the model’s design.
Every true mathematical proposition is a tautology. I don't find this point particularly convincing. As long as the model's predictions match reality in interesting ways, it can lend possible insights on why reality might have certain characteristics.
> Like getting an improbable series of heads when flipping a coin long enough, improbable clusters of events are bound to occur for at least some agents in a large enough set.
Yes, but what's alarming is how most agents' capital fell from bad luck alone, and how good luck only seemed to benefit a very small subset of the population, and talent was not any kind of guarantee. These characteristics of life are denied by many people, so to see it reflected in such a simple model is, I hope, instructive.
> Why should capital growth only occur on chance events, when most workers are paid wages in exchange for their work?
The way I see it, chance events that exponentially increase wealth drown out one's piddling wages. Wages don't seem particularly relevant to why Warren Buffet and Bill Gates have billions, and many people live paycheck to paycheck.
- pron 9y agoI completely agree with everything you've said. I think that an interesting way to gauge the accuracy of the model without doing major empirical research is to create models where talent is the decisive factor, and then compare which model's assumptions better capture what we know about the world. My guess is that for a variable to be a decisive factor, it must correspond to excessive control over others, thus not matching our colloquial definition of talent, but rather of power.
- naasking 9y ago> I think that an interesting way to gauge the accuracy of the model without doing major empirical research is to create models where talent is the decisive factor Exactly. This paper should be one among many models explored, but it's a good start. In fact, I'm sure the paper's simulation can be run with a whole variety of parameters for luck's probability, talent, and bad/good luck's effect on capital. We can then see which set of parameters best matches some aspect of reality and possibly gain some new insight there too.
- fjsolwmv 9y ago"empirical research" would be sociology, which a contrarian would reject out of hand.
- pron 9y agoCorrect, and I certainly don't reject it at all (although I have a feeling some on HN would).
- guiscreenshots 9y ago>> It could be that the results were built into the model’s design. >Every true mathematical proposition is a tautology. I don't find this point particularly convincing. As long as the model's predictions match reality in interesting ways, it can lend possible insights on why reality might have certain characteristics. I think the problem is that nothing about the model lines up with reality. For example: - Each agent begins with an identical amount of capital. -- nothing like the real world. - Every 6 months you have the possibility of doubling or halving your capital. -- nothing like the real world. - Chance of doubling capital is proportional to talent. -- nothing like the real world. As an argument for such a simple model they provide: > The previous agents’ rules are intentionally simple and can be considered widely shareable, since they are based on the common sense evidence that success, in everyone life, has the property to both grow or decrease very rapidly. Sure, success/failure _can_ increase or decrease rapidly, but is it the rule? Arguing the basis of your entire model on "common sense" seems weak. It would be better if they had provided at least some real world data where this pattern emerges. In my experience people seem to move a little bit up or down from their baseline, but I have never personally seen a swing from rags to riches or the other way around. If they had begun by drawing parallels to the ways in which we see the real world and letting the model simulate it into the future it would be more compelling. As it stands, it seems like a set of arbitrary rules designed to reach their desired conclusion, albeit weakly through "it looks pretty similar".
- naasking 9y ago> - Each agent begins with an identical amount of capital. -- nothing like the real world. Not relevant. Part of the main point was that even in the case of equal opportunity/equal starting points, bad luck readily overcomes talent, good luck rewards even the less talented, and so talent isn't any kind of guarantee, contra many people's claims. > - Every 6 months you have the possibility of doubling or halving your capital. -- nothing like the real world. I don't think this is relevant either. You can pick any progression you want and it won't affect the final results. The point is to simulate regular opportunities of dramatically increasing one's wealth. So again, even when faced with equal opportunity, dramatic wealth inequality just due to luck seems inevitable. > - Chance of doubling capital is proportional to talent. -- nothing like the real world. The claim that wealth is proportional to "talent" is widely believed. This paper puts it to the test and refutes it. That's one of the main points. > In my experience people seem to move a little bit up or down from their baseline, but I have never personally seen a swing from rags to riches or the other way around. I addressed this in the post you replied to: small swings up and down are probably wage-driven. This doesn't explain wealth disparity, because dramatic swings in wealth will largely not be wage-driven. These events thus aren't of interest. > If they had begun by drawing parallels to the ways in which we see the real world and letting the model simulate it into the future it would be more compelling. Not as easy as you think. We have no idea what factors are involved. That's why we study models, and see how closely the results match with reality. That then gives us insight into how some parts of reality might work.
- dsacco 9y ago> Every true mathematical proposition is a tautology. I don't find this point particularly convincing. As long as the model's predictions match reality in interesting ways, it can lend possible insights on why reality might have certain characteristics. I don’t really understand what you’re trying to say here, do you mind clarifying? Are you saying you don’t find the point convincing because it’s vacuous?
- naasking 9y ago> Are you saying you don’t find the point convincing because it’s vacuous? I'm saying the article's objection that the "results are built into the design" is indeed vacuous, because this will be true of every mathematical model. The question is how well the model's results match reality, which can yield insight on reality. That said, there is of course a "spectrum" of tautologies. Models with simpler input parameters should carry more weight, because they would yield clearer insights and would be easier to match against reality. Models with complex input parameters are not only less likely to match reality, they don't yield much insight into fundamental causes.