4 ms·
Even easier to policy launder with direct democracy, since most people voting will vote for the headline purpose of the law or treaty without reading the text.
by notahacker 9y ago
Even easier to policy launder with direct democracy, since most people voting will vote for the headline purpose of the law or treaty without reading the text. Or worse still, you get Brexit-style direct democracy where the referendum settles only a broad objective and yet all criticisms of details of policy implementation are dismissed as defying the "will of the people".
- mrec 9y ago> all criticisms of details of policy implementation are dismissed as defying the "will of the people" To be fair, quite a lot of them are.
- notahacker 9y agoPolicy detail was not put to the vote, and not agreed in advance of the vote, and to pretend otherwise for the sake of advocating a particular approach to withdrawal and post-EU settlement is simply dishonest.
- mrec 9y agoAgreed, but things like that attempted Lords amendment to legally require the govt to guarantee the rights of UK expats living in Europe - something not within the govt's power, and therefore sending them to a gunfight with a wooden spoon at the negotiating table - was equally dishonest. I hope you won't dispute that some attempts genuinely are trying to overturn the vote, and often say so quite openly.
- notahacker 9y agoOh sure, there are plenty of people that are openly genuinely trying to overturn the vote. But arguments that the referendum vote for the five words "Leave the European Union" obliges the Lords to reject a policy of prioritising British citizens' rights in the EU post-withdrawal as a negotiation objective could be used as a defining example of laundering policies omitted from the actually voted upon text. Parliamentary bodies imposing conditions on the negotiation process is entirely compatible with the referendum vote and the standard democratic decision making process in the UK, and representatives' votes on them should be determined by whether they think the conditions are reasonable, not by any attempt to infer additional meaning from the five words of the prevailing referendum option.
- mrec 9y agoThat's fair. I suspect we're both nutpicking at this point, facilitated by the abundance of nuts on both sides. I do think it's a little disingenuous to try to limit the mandate to just those four words. If both sides of the referendum campaign made it clear that a Leave win would entail X (e.g. leaving the Customs Union) then it's tough to deny that the result constituted a mandate for X. In the same way, a government that breaks its manifesto promises can't just turn around and say, "Well, we didn't write that promise on the ballot paper itself, so what are you complaining about?"
- notahacker 9y agoAn abundance of nuttiness around symbolic issues is certainly another argument for why referenda in general make policy laundering easy! There's a big difference between a manifesto mandate for a government to try to do X, which the Opposition are expected and encouraged to try to revise and thwart, and an assumption that something as little-discussed and likely irrelevant to most people's voting intent as whether to retain a Customs Union is a non-severable, non-contestable facet of public assent to leave the EU. That would have been the case even if a simple, practical customs border solution had been proposed at any time. As it is, we get "look, we can square this circle with the unilateral free trade we've been advocating for years, and to hell with the people who actually voted Leave because they wanted more protectionism not less..."
- RobertoG 9y ago>>'Or worse still, you get Brexit-style direct democracy where the referendum settles only a broad objective and yet all criticisms of details of policy implementation are dismissed as defying the "will of the people".' Is it not always the case? We vote for a goal a leave the experts to implement it. The point of democracy is that we accept the decision of our con-citizens even if we deeply disagree. Maybe Brexit was the wrong decision, but the idea of not asking because we could get a result that we don't like is totally antidemocratic and hypocritical. Why to bother with the democratic 'appearance' then? Just go with an oligarchy. Anyway, I have the feeling that part of the Brexit result is because, people, already have the feeling of being in an oligarchy and wanted to use the opportunity to express their discomfort.
- notahacker 9y ago> Is it not always the case? We vote for a goal a leave the experts to implement it. No, lawmaking in a representative democracy consists of the wording of a bill being amended as many times as necessary to secure agreement from a majority of representatives - all able to propose amendments themselves - and then being put to the vote before becoming law. This is also the case for some policies put to referenda: the AV referendum was one where the referendum was on a previously agreed text to become law, with no further legislative change implied. And what is being objected to here is not the government attempting to implement the result, it is the government proposing a raft of policy objectives loosely related to some interpretations of the result and trying to curtail further debate and votes over them. If, as you say, part of the result is because people wished to express their discomfort with the feeling of being in an oligarchy, it is even less attractive a method of decision making to assume that the executive's interpretation of the vote must prevail and that criticisms of it from those who voted the other way lack any legitimacy.
- euyyn 9y ago> Anyway, I have the feeling that part of the Brexit result is because, people, already have the feeling of being in an oligarchy and wanted to use the opportunity to express their discomfort. I think that's the problem people see on it, not that "people were asked, oh no!". That, and populists.
- crdoconnor 9y ago>Even easier to policy launder with direct democracy, since most people voting will vote for the headline purpose of the law Only if the direct democracy is set up to behave that way. Any directly democratic system could in principle let people raise objections (e.g. "this law is susceptible to the cobra effect") and have those objections viewed by the people voting on the law.
- notahacker 9y agoSure, anybody can publicise any objection to any law in any system. Ensuring such an argument is actually paid attention to and that revisions are actually made is a different matter entirely. Relatively easy for a representative to make a case for a particular amendment to a particular piece of proposed legislation by addressing the need to rewrite Clause 17b to a group of elected legislators whose full time job is scrutinising that legislation, and then proposing the amendment is voted on there and then, with the proponents of the legislation having a pretty good idea of whether making the change will be necessary to carry the vote. Much more difficult to convince a significant percentage of the public who enthusiastically support the intent of a bill that they should take the time to read objections to Clause 17b and then vote against the whole thing because of Clause 17b. Not least because even members of the public informed and concerned about 17b are aware that the reason for their vote isn't tallied, and voting against a law they want because of unhappiness with one specific provision will torpedo the whole thing.
- crdoconnor 9y ago>Sure, anybody can publicise any objection to any law in any system. Ensuring such an argument is actually paid attention to and that revisions are actually made is a different matter entirely. It's not a "different" matter. It's just a matter of how a directly democratic system is designed. If I were designing such a system, a "reddit style" forum attached to the vote that lets objections or arguments in favor float to the top would be a given - at the bare minimum. >Relatively easy for a representative to make a case for a particular amendment to a particular piece of proposed legislation by addressing the need to rewrite Clause 17b to a group of elected legislators whose full time job is scrutinising that legislation, and then proposing the amendment is voted on there and then, with the proponents of the legislation having a pretty good idea of whether making the change will be necessary to carry the vote. And it's relatively easy for a rich lobby group with a think tank attached to jam their views in to this relatively "unscrutinized" clause by making donations to the politician's campaign. This is the danger inherent with "professional" politicians and "policy experts" of any kind (economists are particularly susceptible to this phenomenon too). And, it usually requires a grass roots movement to bring attention to "17b" issues before the corporation stops getting its way. Instead of marching in front of Congress with placards wouldn't it be easier if we could just click a button to register our displeasure? >Much more difficult to convince a significant percentage of the public who enthusiastically support the intent of a bill that they should take the time to read objections to Clause 17b You could make a directly democratic system that didn't attach a forum to facilitate deliberation, but in my opinion, that would be a massive oversight. Equally I think it would be an oversight to not implement voluntary vote delegation. I don't see why just because I don't want to delegate my vote to a sleazy professional "full time" politician I shouldn't delegate some of my votes to my retired mother or some other person I personally trust with time on their hands.
- throwaway84742 9y agoNancy Pelosi on ACA: “We have to pass the bill to find out what’s in it”. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=hV-05TLiiLU https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=hV-05TLiiLU And they did pass it, largely without reading or understanding, because of how voluminous it was. IMO bills over 20 pages long should be broken up and passed piecemeal.
- CocaKoala 9y agoYou linked a nine-second video and didn't even quote the entire thing. "But we have to pass the bill to find out what is in it, away from the fog of the controversy" What she was saying, which becomes more clear in the context of the full quote that you declined to provide, was that there was a lot of controversy and misinformation regarding the contents of the ACA; you may recall the term "Death Panels" being thrown around, for example. Trying to discuss the actual contents of the ACA had become impossible as a result of the density of misinformation and controversy, and Pelosi's point was that the only way to really find out what was in the bill, what effects the bill would have, was to pass it and then look at the actual effects on people. If you want to talk about bills which were passed largely without reading or understanding, there are better options in more recent history that don't involve misleading paraphrases.
- throwaway84742 9y agoThe main complaint of GP was that people would vote by headlines. Which is exactly what our congresspeople do. WaPo estimates ACA to be 10k pages in total: https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/fact-checker/post/how-many-pages-of-regulations-for-obamacare/2013/05/14/61eec914-bcf9-11e2-9b09-1638acc3942e_blog.html?utm_term=.4fee700e7268 https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/fact-checker/post/how-m.... If you want to tell me that even the majority of the people who voted for it gave it anything more than a cursory, headline level look, I have some fine Florida swampland I’d like to sell.
- CocaKoala 9y agoThen you should find a quote which supports that statement, instead of mischaracterizing one which doesn't.