4 ms·
Direct democracy is no picnic either: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tyranny_of_the_majority https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tyranny_of_the_majority Nothing is pe
by koolba 9y ago
Direct democracy is no picnic either: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tyranny_of_the_majority https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tyranny_of_the_majority
Nothing is perfect but I rather like the tempering effect of an electoral based system. I think we'd have better outcomes if the elections of the electorals themselves (with a given State) were improved.
- RobertoG 9y agoIt seems to me that the dangers of direct democracy have been exaggerated (and maybe the dangers of the representative democracy downplayed). I don't see how, at the end of the day, representative democracy save us of the dangers of direct democracy. The people in power always will be worried about what the dirty masses would do.
- crdoconnor 9y agoThis seems like an entirely hypothetical flaw in direct democracy whereas you only have to glance at the news to see that it's very non-hypothetical for our current system of representative democracy. I suspect the magnitude of the "tyranny of the majority effect" in a directly democratic system would be determined by the structure of the system and any checks and balances that were put in place. You could configure it correctly or you could configure it badly. It's not exactly like representative democracy came about because reasonable people got together and agreed collectively that it was the best system for all. It evolved as a result of elites who used to rule non-democratically giving a series of small concessions over a period of centuries, often after a lot of blood has been spilled or a mass protest movement starts to grow to revolution-y size ("ok, some of you can kick us out of office but this time it's only the ones with penises who own land").
- rayiner 9y ago> This seems like an entirely hypothetical flaw in direct democracy whereas you only have to glance at the news to see that it's very non-hypothetical for our current system of representative democracy. Not a very “hypothetical” flaw. If it was up to the majority to decide, interracial marriage likely would’ve been illegal into the 1990s: http://content.gallup.com/origin/gallupinc/GallupSpaces/Production/Cms/POLL/bb8ic2qate-wa_cbgc2ifg.png http://content.gallup.com/origin/gallupinc/GallupSpaces/Prod...
- manjushri 9y agoOkay, and how does that compare to the countless equally bad or worse laws passed in representative democracy?
- crdoconnor 9y agoAsking "do you disapprove or approve?" skews the numbers higher than asking "should it be illegal or legal?"
- LyndsySimon 9y agoAbsolutely. There are tons of things that I don't "approve of", but I would never be in favor of using the force of government to force those views on others.
- rayiner 9y agoSure, but where interracial marriage is already illegal (as it was in the 1950s due to overwhelming popular disapproval) it’s unlikely to be made legal during a period when the majority of voters still disapprove of it. You’re seeing this with marijuana now.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoIf it were up to elected representatives, it probably would have been illegal into the 1990s as well. Interracial marriage was legalized by the court system applying constitutional protections of individual rights to override laws created by elected representatives.
- rekado 9y agoThis is not a binary choice: representation or untempered direct voting by the masses. One variant is deliberative democracy. For an explanation see Fishkin, James (2011). When the People Speak. Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-0-19-960443-2.
- chestervonwinch 9y agoWith a representative democracy, we have vote -> candidate who supports general policies -> specific policies which gives the "tempering effect" that I think you are talking about. However, the step from general to specific is implemented by legislators and therefore, subject to human factors and outside influence. I'm trying to envision a system where something like [1] is used as the actual voting mechanism, but where you'd remove the actual candidates from the picture, and only vote on your general policy preferences. I haven't thought this out completely. I'm not sure how specific policy legislation would result, and I'm not sure if this still be subject to the tyranny of the majority since we could still have the Abandonment of rationality, for example. [1]: https://www.isidewith.com/ https://www.isidewith.com/ edit: I've no idea if such a system has a name, or if the pros and cons of such a system have already been spelled out in literature somewhere.