6 ms·
Amazon's Japanese headquarters raided by nation's regulator
- gumby 9y agoTitle should point out this is the antitrust regulator, not tax or securities regulators.
- Analemma_ 9y agoDoes it have to? I sort of assumed it would be the antitrust regulator. Amazon is too big and smart to engage in outright tax or securities fraud.
- spyspy 9y agoYes? It could've been their environmental regulator for all we know.
- mfoy_ 9y agoOr labour, if they had illegal working conditions, or anything at all, really...
- hangonhn 9y agoThis is something I've been told when I worked for a hedge fund that had an office in Tokyo: Japanese regulators can raid you, download all your information, and that information can somehow end up in the hands of your rivals. It sounds like regulator raids can be used for corporate espionage and it can happen quite arbitrarily. I don't know if it is true but the fund certainly believed in it enough to setup a whole separate network in Tokyo that was not connected back to the network in the US. Everything done with the US was done via remote console.
- astrodust 9y agoNobody is too big to engage in tax or securities fraud.
- beamatronic 9y agoWouldn’t they keep everything important in the cloud?
- sdrothrock 9y agoGiven that it's Japan, it's very likely that a good deal of it is stored in paper, especially faxed copies and hard contracts.
- williamscales 9y ago> Japan’s antitrust law prohibits a firm from abusing a superior bargaining position to illicitly make a business partner accept unprofitable trade conditions If the trade conditions are really so unprofitable, why would the partner do business with you? This seems like ridiculously broad regulatory overreach. It sounds like it's illegal to be good at business in Japan.
- CPLX 9y ago> If the trade conditions are really so unprofitable, why would the partner do business with you? Because you have no choice. Because they are a monopoly. Which is the basic point of antitrust law.
- positr0n 9y agoProbably lack of business imagination on my part, so can you explain a situation where a company would be forced to do something that would lose it money? If you agree to a deal you must be getting some benefit out of it, right?
- sho 9y ago> If you agree to a deal you must be getting some benefit out of it, right? Well I suppose they get to enjoy the benefit of not simply going out of business. The sharecropper working the land for his fief lord gets "some benefit" out of it, yes, in that he and his family get to eat and thus live. That doesn't make it a good situation.
- CPLX 9y agoSure. Suppose you live on a sunny carribean island and own a banana plantation and sell bananas for export profitably every year and live a normal life and raise a family. Then someone comes along and creates a shipping trust and corners the market on boats leaving the island and says sell your bananas to me at a loss or leave them on the docks to rot. Option A is to sell them at less than the cost it took for you to pay your workers to harvest them, option B is to watch them rot in a matter of days. Yeah sure the free market says that this will cause someone else to come along and create a shipping alternative. But the shipping trust knows this too. So they say if anyone tries to compete with us we'll drop the cost of shipping off the island to free temporarily until your new shipping business fails, and then go back to high rates. Nobody will finance the new shipping company given this predicament, so they can't even get enough money together to buy a boat. Meanwhile, the trust is making a total killing selling bananas at premium prices while buying them below cost, rapidly building a war chest to permanently be able to outlast even a well funded upstart shipping competitor in a price war. Yes the "free market" should solve this problem but the whole point is that trusts and monopolies subvert the free market and prevent market forces from functioning. Thus the role of government in stopping them.
- mfoy_ 9y agoSo it sounds like the issue is that Amazon is using its weight to force suppliers into eating their platform fees rather than pass it on to the consumer. I'm not sure of the exact numbers, but imagine Amazon takes a 10% cut of any sale on its platform. If a supplier sells a widget for $100, they'd only get $90 from an Amazon sale. Amazon is unfairly preventing them from marking up their offerings on Amazon... i.e. preventing the suppliers from selling their widgets for $100 on their direct website, and $111.1 on Amazon (so that a sale is a sale and always gets them $100 in revenue). If a suppliers margins are razor thin this could cause them to lose money on Amazon sales... so they'd either have to mark up their product everywhere and risk losing their competitive edge, or eat the loss on Amazon... or just not "collaborate" at all with Amazon.
- xixi77 9y agoI don't really see why this is necessarily unfair, unless there is literally no other way to reach consumers other than through Amazon: shouldn't their own product pages show up in Google search results, for one, not to mention other online stores?
- xbryanx 9y agoIt's not really about whether it's unfair. It's about whether it's against Japan's democratically defined laws.
- xixi77 9y agoOf course; I know very little about Japan's antitrust laws, it's really beside the point whether they are democratically defined or not. It's on Amazon to argue about their interpretation through Japanese courts or by whatever is the mechanism of redress they have in this case, if any. I was responding to the parent comment calling the arrangement as described in article unfair.
- mfoy_ 9y agoActually, I never said it was unfair, I just elaborated on what Amazon had allegedly done to warrant a raid from the antitrust regulators.