6 ms·
This is exactly the sort of thing why FCC wants to lock down wlan ap/router firmwares. So, while a cool hack indeed, it is also bit unfortunate that it also kin
by zokier 9y ago
This is exactly the sort of thing why FCC wants to lock down wlan ap/router firmwares. So, while a cool hack indeed, it is also bit unfortunate that it also kinda justifies FCCs position
- jonashoechst 9y agoI think this only shows the insanity of FCCs statement, as the Broadcom firmware _is_ locked down and got hacked either way. If somebody wanted to transmit arbitrarily on this bands he or she could just use regular SDRs.
- taneq 9y agoOr even just build a transmitter.
- awalton 9y agoYeah that's not a strong argument at all. The 2.4GHz and 5GHz bands are known widely as "garbage bands" due to how terrible they are to work with (e.g. rain will heavily attenuate your signal, they're literally how microwaves work to cook your food, etc.). Moreover, there are plenty of radios on the market that transmit all kinds of noise on these channels that isn't WiFi (e.g. my neighbors had a baby monitor that I could tell when it was on by how shit my WiFi was at that moment, FPV drones somewhat frequently use this band with proprietary analog video transports, etc.) This is permitted because these channels are "unregulated" (or, more realistically, "regulated for unlicensed operation"). On top of that, the FCC's official statement on this very topic was that what they really care about is the amount of power being put into these channels, as some aftermarket router firmwares of varying repute would let you crank the output wattage above FCC regulations for these frequencies (<1W power to stay within unlicensed operation regulations for 2.4GHz), and apparently some in-market WiFi routers picked up those firmwares as a "supported" option (I think ASUS and Linksys were both named). Most of these routers have since patched themselves to stay regulation-safe. So, go nuts, just stay below 30 dBm/1W from the transmitter in 2.4Ghz channels or prepare for a visit from the FCC. (You'll have to do your own research for 5GHz).
- exikyut 9y agoDoes this mean the 3W and 5W amplified Wi-Fi dongles all over ebay aren't actually legal? :( I realize they're probably terrible quality, and that they're really just Wi-Fi dongles with amplifiers tacked on, and that overly loud signal amplification destroys close range performance - but still, I'd been meaning to get a couple of these and see how good they are.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- paulie_a 9y agoPlease don't
- colanderman 9y agoThe limits in the 2.4 GHz range are 1 W maximum emitted power, amplified via directed antenna up to 4 W maximum. (5 GHz has more complex rules, but is generally more restrictive of emitted power and less restrictive of directed amplification.) Not sure what these dongles are so I can't comment on them specifically.
- exikyut 9y ago
- swiley 9y agoDoes it? I feel like it would actually have to cause interference before the FCC's position was actually justified. That seems unlikely considering how pervasive and interference tolerant 2.4GHz devices are.